News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by iqster on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @08:51AM (#2602332)
The way I understand bitcoins might be flawed but would certainly appreciate clarification ...

My problem with bit coins is that early people who start mining have a greater advantage than later ones. While that's not the classic definition of a Ponzi scheme (in the classic definition, payouts at each round are funded by new participants), it is a feature bitcoin shares with them. If someone started mining bitcoin when it first started, they have a significant stash created by now. As people start to assign value to the virtual currency, these people are getting a significant proportion of value for simply being early adopters.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by dualogy on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:26AM (#2602451)
"these people are getting a significant proportion of value for simply being early adopters"

I'm not one of them but have no gripes with that. What you describe is also commonly known as the entrepreneurial taking-unknown-risks for an unknown-future-reward.

It's the same with government currencies -- the government/banking complex gets newly created money first, and gets to spend it when the new money supply still has the purchasing power of the old money supply, ie. before inflation. This is their bonus for successfully defending their monopoly on money creation. Not that I'm in favour of such a privilegue. Which is the appeal to a growing number of users: yes, early adopters may be rewarded in proportion to how early they adopted, BUT no-one can unilaterally create new Bitcoins at the push of a button or by signing some law and even the early adopters could not initially create more bitcoins or faster than prescribed by the open source peer to peer protocol.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by abulafia on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:16PM (#2603453)
It's not the same as taking early risks; this is a very constrained and artificial environment in which bitcoins are generated. One can be pretty certain that if one generates coins early, one can then make money selling them to others. This is much more similar to a pyramid marketing scenario, where the earlier franchises are inherently worth more, and eventually the value generated for the terminal generation of participants is close to nil.

I'd argue you're not exactly correct about the release path of currency in a fractional reserve system, although I don't disagree that elements are currently implemented in quite unfair ways. I'd also suggest, though, that government fiat currency works very much better than anything commodity based, or indeed than a partially fiat system that functions exactly like a commodity based system, as bitcoin does.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by wmf on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:50PM (#2603631)
One can be pretty certain that if one generates coins early, one can then make money selling them to others.

I don't know about that. Back in 2009 or 2010, Bitcoins were worth practically nothing and almost everyone predicted that they'd never be worth anything. And if no one mined, maybe Bitcoin would never have taken off (to the extent that it has) and it would still be worthless.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by abulafia on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:51PM (#2603923)
I'm suggesting that if you believe in the model, and even the most obvious ramifications of such an economy, the value of participating in the system is to be as far upstream as possible. I don't believe in the model, so, I'm not suggesting it has real value now or going forward.

You're also actually assuming something that runs counter to the stated bitcoin model, as described in the FAQ (which seems to be down at the moment). That is that there's an investment in making bitcoins, which they would say is not so. The intent in burning cycles and power is simply to ensure security, while the value comes from faith in the currency. Hence, there is no investment in creation: the investment would instead be in accepting bitcoins in transactions, which iterates the pyramidal nature of the system.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by BarkMore on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:35AM (#2602493)
The situation is not much better with inflating fiat currencies. Those who are closer to the money spigot have an advantage over those who are further way.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by rmc on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @10:28AM (#2602712)
It's no where near as pronounced with fiat currencies as it is with bitcoin. Only a few currencies have experienced this level of hyperinflation that bitcoin has (e.g. weimar republic, zimbabwe), and those currencies have failed.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by BarkMore on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:01AM (#2602831)
If inflation is defined as money supply growth, then bitcoin is not hyperinflating. The rate of bitcoin inflation is decreasing over time until it reaches zero.

If inflation is defined as the rise in prices of goods, then bitcoin is deflating.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by zacharypinter on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:11AM (#2602867)
Isn't bitcoin experiencing some sort of hyperdeflation, not hyperinflation? The strange thing here is not that too many coins are being created, it's that the demand for bitcoins is increasing faster than the supply. The coins are becoming hypothetically more valuable, not less.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by RickHull on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:12AM (#2602873)
Under hyperinflation, each monetary unit is worth less and less. Your complaint about bitcoin is that each unit is worth more and more. Your analogy makes no sense.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by rmc on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @10:27AM (#2602707)
If someone started mining bitcoin when it first started, they have a significant stash created by now

Some of the early adoptors of BitCoins have 1% of all the current BitCoins each.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by DennisP on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:06PM (#2603116)
I see that as a fairly elegant solution to the chicken-and-egg problem. Seems to be working, too.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:28AM (#2602459)
My solution is to expire the BTC to force circulation.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by yrral on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:42AM (#2603008)
If what you're suggesting is that coins can only sit in one address for a limited amount of time, then that would not do anything because people would just create new addresses to send the coins to.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by kragen on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:13PM (#2603156)
The standard Silvio Gesell expiring-money scheme doesn't have anything to do with where the money is at any given time. The way it works is that for the government to accept a note, it must be up-to-date with stamps, one stamp for every month since it was issued. The stamps (traditionally, bought from the government) cost 10% of the value of the note.

Nobody wants to be sitting on a pile of this sort of cash at the end of the month, because they'll lose 10% of the pile of cash. The intended effect is to dramatically increase the velocity of the money, so that a small stock of it can sustain a very large flow.

I don't know enough about this stuff to sensibly evaluate the claims its proponents make for it.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:12PM (#2603431)
this is one of the worst ideas I've ever heard. the amount of wealth that would be destroyed is beyond all measure.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by kragen on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:47PM (#2603610)
Wealth consists of things like cured diseases, tasty and nourishing meals, being dry when it rains, and seeing the people you love as often as you want; and the resources and skills we use to create those other kinds of wealth, such as antibiotics, bread mold, spices, beans, houses, corrugated steel, iron ore, blast furnaces, airplanes, kerosene, and CAD software.

Gesell's scheme does not destroy any of those things; it only destroys money. Money is not wealth. Money is just a way to facilitate cooperative ventures with people we don't know and trust. With money, I can cooperate with 200 other people to pay for an intercontinental flight, and with the hundreds of thousands of other people who drilled and refined the kerosene, aluminum, and other resources needed to keep us in the air.

But the money game has a lot of drawbacks. So it's sensible to experiment with it and see how we can improve it. Gesell's scheme was one such experiment. It was reported to be very effective at creating wealth by its proponents when it was tried.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by prodigal_erik on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @02:42AM (#2606254)
I don't understand the rationale for penalizing saving. The car I couldn't afford on this month's paychecks alone is wealth. Food and shelter after I'm too old to work will be wealth.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:19PM (#2603747)
it was reported to be beneficial by its proponents. what a surprise. call me back when you have a control group.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @01:41AM (#2606123)
You can hardly expect anyone but a proponent to advocate for an idea...

Also, asking for a control group in an artsy fartsy field like economics is too much. Where is the control group that guides the decisions of the central banks? There is none! OMG GREAT DEPRESSION!

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @01:39AM (#2606116)
As the other poster said, money != wealth. Wealth is things that make life better. Money is a medium of exchange.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @01:38AM (#2606115)
Yes, I thought that would be one thing. Fine with me.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by weavejester on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:11PM (#2603718)
I'm not sure how you expect that to work. How would expiring bitcoins increase circulation?
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @01:38AM (#2606114)
"You will have 10 BTC expire next month"

So you spend it.

Also, once the BTC expire, they don't disappear. They are made available for mining. This is possible because the block chain has full history.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by weavejester on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @07:03AM (#2606767)
In order to spend bitcoins, you need someone willing to exchange them for goods or services. Why would anyone do that if the bitcoins they received were going to expire?

For instance, let's say I wait until the literally last minute to spend my expiring bitcoins. I want to exchange my almost-expiring 10 BTC for $100. Would you accept this offer, knowing that those 10 BTC will vanish shortly after you accept them?

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @06:11PM (#2609627)
I was not clear. They only expire if YOU don't spend them.

Once you exchange your 10 BTC, the expiry date is reset.

Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by weavejester on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @07:06PM (#2609799)
So what's stopping me from creating multiple accounts and swapping bitcoins between them to prevent them from ever expiring?
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by cheez on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @07:39PM (#2609890)
Nothing. I didn't say I've thought it out completely :)
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by Andys on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @10:23AM (#2602693)
So you're saying its like the housing market?
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by iwwr on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:00AM (#2602364)
Alternatively, maintaining a hard limit on the number of BTC saves resources, compared to a system that allowed for a fixed growth. Once the 'mining' stage ends, no new computational resources are invested. The system accumulates a kind of computational capital (a mathematical problem difficult enough to be intractable) which needs no further upkeep, other than a network presence to provide verification.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by caf on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:44AM (#2602527)
Even after the mining phase ends, the hash chain continues to be extended, requiring the same computational resources.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by iwwr on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:57AM (#2602592)
It would only be extended with new transactions, not blocks. Computational resources will be devoted to verification rather than brute-forcing hashes (a much less computationally intensive matter).
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by caf on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @10:02AM (#2602605)
No, blocks are still created in exactly the same way, the only difference is that no new bitcoins are created as a side-effect. It is necessary for new transactions to be locked into the block chain with a bruteforced hash, as it's this expenditure of processing power that makes the transactions permanent and prevents double-spending.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by iwwr on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @10:11AM (#2602652)
I just imagined that the bitcoin world post-mining (after or near the 21M BTC is reached) would just consist of the transactional interfaces and not need the specialized GPU miners.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by caf on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @08:23PM (#2605302)
Unfortunately, that's not how it works. The "miners" are really "transaction settlers". It's the longest block chain that represents the globally consistent view of which transactions have settled.
Re:Resources are being utterly and completely wasted on mini... by iwwr on Wednesday June 01, 2011 @10:10AM (#2607310)
OK, that was an aspect I was unfamiliar with. So after the mining phase ends, transactions become zero-sum BTC games, where the biggest 'miners' accrue their proportional share of the total fees of transactions validated.