Re:Decentralization Is a Narrative Mirage
by rapjr9 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @11:43AM
(#26027017)
I've had experience writing distributed, decentralized software (mobile agents, distributed wireless sensor networks, animal wireless sensor networks) and the biggest impediments to building decentralized systems is that there is very little prior work to rely on. There are few libraries, examples, or clear explanations of the different approach that is needed. There are also some difficult trust problems with decentralized systems (are you OK with trusting your data is secure stored on several of your neighbors devices? Are you sure any random computer is secure to run your app on or use your data? Are you OK with letting some unknown vendor run tasks on your device and your data? There are solutions to these but they are not widely known or used.) In particular, decentralized systems can be very difficult to troubleshoot, especially if you are moving code from machine to machine and executing it wherever it lands. These problems can be solved but right now everyone has to solve them themselves from the ground up instead of relying on known common solutions. Some types of decentralized technologies are essentially the same as computer viruses and figuring out how to keep them under control is essential. Centralization became widespread because it was cheaper and offered centralized control (which is attractive to primates with hierarchical societal tendencies). Decentralization is possible, it's just going to require a similar amount of work to make it competitive and available.
Re:Decentralization Is a Narrative Mirage
by pdimitar on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:06AM
(#26044518)
> * There are solutions to these but they are not widely known or used.*
Do you have any links?
Re:Decentralization Is a Narrative Mirage
by vineyardmike on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:45PM
(#26022344)
I feel like the article wasn't about any protocol-level of centralization. It reads more as a social/business level article than a technical one.
Re:Decentralization Is a Narrative Mirage
by beckman466 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @04:25AM
(#26023993)
I’m not sure there’s a difference between them like you make out. I would argue the social depends on the technical and vice versa.
Do you have an example to help me understand what you see or mean?
It's true that at the core, many decentralized technologies not only enable more diversity of locality but also more holism. So it can be to some degree a "centralization" towards certain public but well-distributed and non-centrally-controlled protocols.
But you really need to dig into the details to appreciate how decentralized protocols work and provide advantages over literally centralized often privately controlled closed systems.
It's really about using technology to work together effectively. Part of that is staying in sync in some way, and part of it is avoiding control chokepoints, and part of it is just allowing for freedom.