News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Matt_Cutts on Monday May 30, 2011 @11:27PM (#2601172)
I left a "this isn't true" comment on the original thread but I think the comment will need moderator approval.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by skitzzo on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:44AM (#2601688)
Matt, feel free to answer this in either place but you singled out a sentence in the post and claimed it wasn't true.

Then you followed that statement up by saying that the title isn't true.

While I most definitely appreciate you weighing in on the issue, I feel you would better serve readers by explaining whether the initial statement, the title, or both are inaccurate.

Are you saying email reputation wasn't the reason his site was penalized, that he didn't have a tip from a Google employee, or that email reputation doesn't factor into the search rankings?

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by jakeludington on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:23AM (#2601640)
Matt you left a "this isn't true" without actually saying what about my article isn't true. In fact, you singled out one sentence in the article as being untrue, which would suggest you consider the rest of the article to be true.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by lotharbot on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:37AM (#2602500)
> you singled out one sentence in the article as being untrue, which would suggest you consider the rest of the article to be true.

This is not even remotely valid reasoning.

He weighed in on one part of your article because he's in a special position to know whether or not it's true. Choosing not to weigh in on the rest of the article says nothing about his opinion of the rest of it.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:11AM (#2601419)
Are you at liberty to speculate why those sites may have seen a big dip in Google referrals, or would that be giving away too much of your spam fighting wizardry?
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:57AM (#2601556)
We can't go into detail about specific signals because we don't want them to be gamed, but we did do a blog post with advice for publishers about this update: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2011/05/more-guid...
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by lurker19 on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:29AM (#2601662)
Huh. Most of those guidelines make sense (but they are so redundant they probably would not pass Panda's tests for readable-content vs keyword-stuffing), but this one stuck me as completely inappropriate, biased, and entering the realm of content manipulation: "Does the article describe both sides of a story?"
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by drakaal on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @02:41AM (#2601684)
A system of rules which are only partially known, leaves the the advantage in the hands of those with access at the top of the barrel. You really think your ranks are so tight that information doesn't leak? And there for create more harm than good?

If the article is untrue, put it in writing. "Matt Cutts says Google doesn't use email as an indicator in search rankings" would kill the story.

You haven't said that, so it leaves me to believe that the article is true. And it is only the method of discovery you dislike.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:05AM (#2602844)
Okay, here you go: Google doesn't use email as an indicator in search rankings.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by jakeludington on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:33PM (#2604084)
This patent for "Ranking blog documents" seems to disagree: http://bit.ly/msgrsv

"[0044] References to the blog document by other sources may be a positive indication of the quality of the blog document. For example, content of emails or chat transcripts can contain URLs of blog documents. Email or chat discussions that include references to the blog document is a positive indicator of the quality of the blog document."

Andriy Bihun, the first name on the patent, is still a Google software engineer according to LinkedIn.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by redthrowaway on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:57PM (#2604211)
That's a good find, but the fact that a Google employee has a patent on using email links to rank blogs doesn't necessarily mean that Google's using it.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by drakaal on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:06PM (#2603976)
Realizing not everything Google puts in Patents ends up in search, I think I still don't believe you.

http://www.xyhd.tv/2011/05/industry-news/search-engine-optim...

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by skitzzo on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:32AM (#2601775)
actually, he has put in writing that the title of the story isn't true. I still think there are reasonable questions that haven't been answered but I'm not sure we'll actually get answers to those.

To be honest, I'm surprised we got this kind of response from Google at all. They generally don't weigh in on SEO theory.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by drakaal on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @04:12AM (#2601848)
Matt once told me that if I did a bad thing on my site there wasn't a penalty, I just didn't get as many points as I could. Semantics. When he says "there is no correlation between Email and search" I will maybe believe him. Maybe.

Maybe you are too young to remember the Matt Cutts "use no follow on internal links" debacle where he said that was a good idea.

I read the response from Google as Matt's annoyed a minion said something they shouldn't have, and Google's caught with their pants down on what is a pretty scary thought. "Google Reads Your Email And Does Scary S___ With It"

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by kanetrain on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @04:23AM (#2601863)
Matt - If the search team or gmail team are using email engagement as an indicator of a site's reputation or usefulness... or even to grade the quality of email from a site, it's really problematic. This can so easily be exploited to hurt someone else's site. You just create thousands of fake gmail accounts, sign up for your competitor's newsletter with all of them, and then never open any of their emails. Presumably there are already people doing this... and making sure those "fake" account appear as real as possible so Gmail bots can't tell the difference.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @11:07AM (#2602856)
To the best of my knowledge, we don't use email reputation in any way in our search rankings.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by itswindy on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:37AM (#2601780)
Of course you can't because they are so accurate. 70% increase in traffic one month followed by a 80% decrease on the same site. You people have lost touch and keep experimenting live with people's businesses and jobs. Wake up
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by jamesbritt on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:47AM (#2601800)
You people have lost touch and keep experimenting live with people's businesses and jobs.

Not sure who's out of touch here. Is Google really experimenting with people's businesses and jobs, or are they experimenting with their own service on which people have, perhaps foolishly, bet their businesses and jobs?

If their changes are pissing off one segment of their users it may be because they are trying to please another, more profitable, segment of their users.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by itswindy on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @03:57AM (#2601827)
Jamesbritt - [i]Not sure who's out of touch here. Is Google really experimenting with people's businesses and jobs, or are they experimenting with their own service on which people have, perhaps foolishly, bet their businesses and jobs?

If their changes are pissing off one segment of their users it may be because they are trying to please another, more profitable, segment of their users.[/i]

Fine, all Google has to say is "we will use arbitrary ways of ranking and will support more those that $upport us with adwords" not spew nonsense.

P.S. With 70% market share Google is a monopoly and totally different rules apply.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Groxx on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @05:21AM (#2601955)
ps:

  an *italicized* word, or *more than one*.
results in: an italicized word, or more than one.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by itswindy on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @06:33AM (#2602047)
Thank you very much Groxx.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by lionhearted on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @05:41AM (#2601977)
Hey Matt,

It's been said before, but I just wanted to say thanks again for coming into HN and sharing some perspective. It's very cool and insightful and appreciated.

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by OpenAlgorithm on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:08AM (#2611789)
Posted this on the original article, but had a feeling you might not return, so here goes:

Surely that points a crucial flaw in the system, how can you manually penalize a site and not put any tests in place that would let you know when the reasons for the penalization have been removed.

If Jake hadn't filed a reconsideration request he would have continued to be "trusted less" by Google thus presumably receiving less traffic.

Google should create a simple algorithm that would alert the webspam team who I presume take the manual action on websites that the reason for penalty has been removed and they should take another manual look at it.

As I see it the only reason Jake was informed of such penalization is because he filed a recon request, what about the thousands of other websites who inadvertently had bad links or another reason for penalization on the site and didn't sport the traffic dip and didn't file a request.

Maybe I'm wrong, Matt, do Google have these stops/tests/algorithms in place to stop incorrect penalization?

Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by roshodgekiss on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @12:44AM (#2601344)
Sorry Matt, just approved it then. Thanks for weighing in on this thread, it's really appreciated.
Re:Email Reputation Causes Penalties in Google Search Results by Matt_Cutts on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @01:55AM (#2601548)
No worries, happy to clarify.