News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by Tomte on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:14PM (#25991468)
Economically it is very simple and beneficial to Germany.

There are two foreign-policy angles:

The Eastern-European states (mostly Poland and the Ukraine, but also the Baltics) are constantly afraid of Russia. Especially to the Poles it looks a bit like Germany and Russia diving Poland between themselves in WW II.

That's the good foreign policy opposition.

Then there's the bad one: America. America wants to sell liquid gas from fracking.

That gas is more expensive, so Germany builds ports for those LNG ships, but also the pipeline.

America warns that Germany makes itself dependent on Russian gas, but that's bullshit. Germany can switch over to American LNG at any time. The infrastructure is there. As soon as Russian gas stops, gets too expensive, or strings are attached, Germany can almost instantly get American gas.

The only problem is: America wants to sell their expensive gas right now.

And so the impose sanctions, not against Germany, but against everyone remotely connected to that project. It sounds like an exaggeration, but they literally impose sanctions on some janitor working for a port that let a ship enter which was working on that pipeline. And the mayor of the town the port is in. And everyone else.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iguy on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:35PM (#25991738)
> As soon as Russian gas stops, ... Germany can almost instantly get American gas.

Is it really so simple? Even if the domestic infrastructure is identical, you need the port facilities (at both ends, with spare capacity), and you need ships.

Anyone know what sort of percentage of the world LNG shipping market today this would be? (To replace the whole Russian supply to Europe, say.) That would influence how easy it is to rent the ships you need.

Edit -- quick googling, Nord Stream 1 & 2 each 55 billion m^3/year max, the whole world's LNG fleet about 90 million m^3, liquid is 615 times the density, thus 55 billion m^3 total capacity of gas. So if every single LNG ship made one trip US-DE, that would replace a year of Nord Stream 1 alone. The trip is about 12 days, one way, at 20 knots.

Maybe I should google more but I thought lead times were also a constraint -- that gas pipelines are close to real-time, unlike oil, while renting some ships to sail across the atlantic would take a while. Anyone know the details?

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday February 01, 2021 @04:14PM (#25994043)
You could look at https://www.gie.eu/index.php/gie-publications/maps-data/lng-... which shows the already existing infrastructure and capacities. Also existing LNG-terminals in for instance Rotterdam, and the pipeline networks from there to Wilhelmshavn, Hamburg and Brunsbüttel. We don't even need that. It's non-sense. Uncle Sam is just angry about us giving our money to Russia instead of him. That's all.

/me shrugs.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iguy on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @10:20AM (#26001930)
Thanks, that's a useful map.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iSnow on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:10PM (#25992288)
I am not an expert, so be kind, but I think you got a thing or two wrong:

- Germany imported close to 110bn m^3 (https://www.statista.com/statistics/332218/gas-trade-imports...)

- a typical big LNG tanker has a capacity of 266,000 m^3 ( https://www.wartsila.com/encyclopedia/term/lng-tanker)

- 110.000.000.000 / 266.000 = 413,533 trips or 1133 tankers unloading every day.

Against the 90m m^3 "whole world fleet capacity" that's still a factor of 1222, so every single LNG tanker would have to do the USA <-> 4 times every day for this to work.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iguy on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:19PM (#25992443)
I have literally never looked up these numbers before, so it's entirely possible I messed it up. But I think you might be missing a conversion factor, as it appears that tankers quote liquid volume, while pipelines quote gas (at 1 atm I presume). With that it becomes 2 ships/day, which could be in the ballpark.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iSnow on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:30PM (#25992594)
You could be right, but I was under the impression that pipeline gas was liquified as well, but maybe I am wrong.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by vaduz on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:55PM (#25992905)
Nord Stream and Yamal both transport pressurized natural gas (at 100 to 120 atm). LNG is not really suitable for long pipelines.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by Tomte on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:38PM (#25991792)
America is building those ports right now, because they have LNG to sell. Germany is building those ports right now, in order to placate the Americans.

I have no idea whether it can substitute for the whole of Russian gas, probably not. But for Nord Stream 2, yes.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by vaduz on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:40PM (#25992720)
Total capacity of the completed Nord Stream 1 (~55 bcma, billion cubic metres per year) and Yamal-Europe (~33 bcma) is barely sufficient to cover the German demand (~88.7 bcma in 2019), assuming no sales to Poland or Austria and other countries on the route of the latter - but one of the swan songs for Germany was the prospect of being the transit country for the remainder of the capacity that Nord Stream 2 was to bring (another 55 bcma!). It would also allow Germany and Russia to exert more political pressure on some of its neighbours, in particular on other central European countries (Poland, Slovakia, Austria) - it is not unreasonable these countries not exactly thrilled about the prospect. Not to mention, it helps in those times when Germany needs to give the finger to the US, of course.

Plus there is the little thing that most existing terminals can't accept Q-class ships (i.e. vessels with capacity 200 thousand cubic metres), so it is not exactly possible to replace total demand with LNG - it's actually doubtful if you could even replace the ~9 bcma of Nord Stream 2 gas that was actually earmarked for Germany. We are talking different orders of magnitude here.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday February 01, 2021 @04:15PM (#25994067)
Where exactly do we build them? War schon irgendwo "Spatenstich"?
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by kilotaras on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @08:13AM (#26000550)
Using "the Ukraine" is heavily discouraged, please use Ukraine instead.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine#Etymology_and_orthogra...

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by Tomte on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @08:25AM (#26000659)
Interesting, I had no idea.

I think I heard the variant without article in German, as well, but I'm not aware of a similar discouragement.

The German Wikipedia seems not to have anything on it, as well.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by sremani on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:18PM (#25991517)
The terms of alliance are you do not enrich the guy we are protecting you from.

It is that simple!

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by antientropic on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:44PM (#25991866)
Western countries traded with the Russians during the Cold War so this seems like a weak argument. Where does the NATO treaty stipulate a trade embargo against the Russians?
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by iguy on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:26PM (#25992542)
Trade seems fine, it is being dependent which is potentially dangerous.

In the cold war, it was the USSR which was more dependent. Without food grown in North America, they were (IIRC) looking at WWII levels of rationing, in the 80s, which would have made people pretty unhappy. They sold oil to buy this food, but most of the west could have got by without this trade. (Not sure how dependent W.Germany was, at that point.)

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by hef19898 on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:49PM (#25992820)
Western Germany got gas from the Sowjets since the 70s. It is more the eastern eurpean countries that risk being in trouble. Using "German energy dependency" is just a straw man. Oh, I have the impression the real reason a commercial conflict between the US and Russia.
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by Udik on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:48PM (#25991926)
You can also say "we lose money and influence if you trade with that guy, so we'll pretend you need to be protected from him".
Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by sudosysgen on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:42PM (#25991845)
The US is not protecting Germany against Russia militarily. The US is opposing Russia because it is in the US's interests to oppose Russia

Germany is more than able to protect itself against Russia.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by baybal2 on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:19PM (#25992441)
> Germany is more than able to protect itself against Russia.

Germany only have ~300 tanks.

It is not by any stretch of imagination.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by sudosysgen on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:37PM (#25992681)
Germany isn't going to fight Russia alone, it's going to fight Russia with the entire EU per article 42 section 7 of the TEU.

France has 530 MBTs, Spain 550, and Italy 480. This compares favourably with the 2600 Russian tanks, and with proper logistical backbone, advanced air support, infantry support, and competent missile defence systems, is way more than necessary to stall a Russian offensive.

Of course, once the Russian offensive is stalled, Germany alone can vastly outproduce Russia, and that's the worst case scenario.

The US is not necessary for Germany to defend against Russia.

Re:Russian Pipeline Is Germany's Greatest Foreign Policy Emb... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday February 01, 2021 @04:24PM (#25994168)
Honestly, the free falling B61 you let us 'participate' in storing and delivering aren't protecting us, they make us a target. So Fuck OFF, will ya?