> I'm running a GTX680 on my primary Linux box, but it won't be nVidia next time.
Well, you're kind of making their point. Your business is probably insignificant for them, you have an 8 year old GPU :-)
Linux users don't have to refresh hardware as often. Long-term support is a cornerstone of linux. Linux gamers may spend less per year on gaming hardware but they are not broke. Give them a reason and they will drop that banked cash on anything they can trust to play nice with linux.
I'm well aware of that (since I'm one of them too), however I didn't make it clear I presume.
Thanks for highlighting it again.
It's also stems for efficient utilization of the hardware, too.
The flip side is that if you want to do GPGPU work (even if it's just local testing) you more-or-less need an nVidia card.
ATI was left in the dust while the foundation has been forming, unfortunately, but the history is not that straightforward.
TBH, while I appreciate what nVidia is doing, I don't appreciate how did they came to this point.
I have some close friends who're doing game engine and very low level 3D development. His thoughts about nVidia's driver behavior, even under Windows, is worth another rant.
Have they ever taken proper care of the visual part? I've thought that it exists in the first place because of the SFX industry's heavy use of GNU/Linux and Nvidia. That's a fraction of their market share so only got a fraction of their attention, likely mainly to avoid vacating the area for competitors than to actually make money (bad ROI compared to Windows).
Windows is essentially just the gaming market. Gamers are fickle, only buying a card every couple years and are very price conscious. But AI, and any other datacenter uses of GPUs (mining) buy cards in bulk, are not fickle, and are not obsessed with daily price fluctuations. Those are the markets Nvidea wants to be in and they are dominated by linux. Not playing nice with linux gamers will come back to haunt Nvidea.
Also, one should not underestimate the bias that gaming generates. All those linux gamers who suffer poor drivers while gaming saturday night walk into jobs at datacenters and AI research groups each monday. They remember. I certainly do. All things being equal, I lean towards AMD whenever the boss asks my opinion on our next purchase.
There are also Quadro cards aimed at professional OpenGL acceleration for GIS, 3D modeling, CAD, etc. These applications run on both Windows and Linux (soem are cross platform, some are platform locked) and, the ROI pie is a complicated picture.
Windows is dominated by gamers and casual users, that's right, however it's not the sole market for gaming. Steam is pushing for Linux in a relentless pace. Steam in Linux is getting rooted like a Sequoia tree. When it becomes visible, its roots will be much deeper and stronger than the trunk (which is a good thing).
nVidia used to care for Linux users. Extensions required by composition, off-screen rendering and other stuff came to nVidia first (when compared to AMD). Video acceleration is also the same (AMD's video acceleration technologies can were much better than nVidia due to their legacy but, they acted slow. They're even now. Maybe AMD is still better. I need to test).
This trend reared its ugly head ~3 years ago for me. I've upgraded my monitor to a DP one and DPMS went out of window. Screen suspension and standby has gone. They didn't fix it for older cards for ~1 year IIRC. Currently I'm experiencing a strange frame-rate drop. Will investigate when I have time. If an onboard Intel card can drive same DE (KDE) on a same resolution screen better with a much inferior CPU when compared to a triple-slot, out of the box overclocked GTX680, then there's something very, very wrong.
nVidia was top of the line, just works out of the box GPU vendor. Now due to its arrogance and dominance, cracks start to appear. Even Intel's driver blunders are solved faster (ah, they're open source).
In their defense, from their point of view, gaming on Linux is a tiny fraction of their overall business and, presumably, even their Linux one. For them, Linux is the same as HPC and ML model training and, maybe, cryptocurrency mining.
These companies aren't rewriting tens or hundreds of millions of lines of code for Linux. The difference is probably a fraction of a fraction of a percent.
Well, they don't — AMD drivers for new hardware famously take a few kernel releases to stabilize. (G)GP specifically noted their stability problem started only 5 months ago, which means at least that issue is not really systemic. The real differentiator here is handling of existing complaints: Linux has mailing lists, Mesa has a normal open for everyone bug tracker, while Nvidia has a user support forum, which they mostly ignore.
Closed source GPU drivers are not ordinary drivers. They have a lot of quirks and workarounds for programs, especially games.
When a dev studio makes some mistake in its engine or the engine doesn't fit well to current workflow of the driver, a new driver is shipped with specific workarounds for this game. These quirks generally add shims between the program and the driver by basically modifying calls to the driver to increase performance.
e.g.:
- A game is calling too many clears while it shouldn't? Pool them in the shim layer and let them through in batches of 1000.
- Is a particular benchmark is overloading the card by forcibly drawing off screen portions and hurting scores? Insert a shim to prevent drawing off-screen parts and chea... ehrm, optimize the performance.
- Is an important legacy application exploiting a quirk in an older driver for something? Introduce that quirk via another shim.
When you try to port these drivers as-is to another platforms, things get awry. Also the drivers were tremendously Windows specific. This is why FGLRX had (or does it still have) various daemons, HAL layers, during its teething years.
OTOH, free/OSS drivers has no shims, workarounds and other stuff. They are just drivers. Plain, simple, vanilla. They are easier to maintain and develop. Radeon driver is such a driver. Also AMD/ATI has some more tricks up their sleeve for more stable, better drivers regardless of their platforms.
- IP separation: All of the NDA bound parts of the GPU (currently it should be the HDCP stuff only) is a different IP module on the GPU. The cards are designed so that even the Radeon driver can work with HDCP module while being completely blob free. ATI/AMD specially altered silicon and GPU architecture to enable FOSS drivers on Linux and I think its effects are huge.
- "Factory Team:" Radeon driver is carried forward by volunteers but AMD also has a dedicated team working on Radeon driver full time. This group cannot communicate with FGLRX team to prevent tainting each-others wells. So, Radeon is blessed by AMD/ATI on hardware, software and management level.
When you publish your specs, dogfood it with another team, and optimize your GPU silicon and board to accommodate these open source exceptionally well, you have a killer combination.
The quirks part is a bit of a meme. Mesa contains a few application-specific overrides here and there: https://github.com/mesa3d/mesa/blob/c62996796cc46f1a1406f365..., https://github.com/mesa3d/mesa/blob/a678ec9b8c057311ed7e9697.... The reason Linux drivers, including the one from Nvidia, have fewer quirks is simply that Linux has fewer 3d applications overall. Those quirks also reside in userspace driver parts and should not affect system stability.
> When you try to port these drivers as-is to another platforms, things get awry.
Again, quirks are a property of a relatively high-level userspace part of the driver. There is nothing hazardous about porting them.
Quadro cards are used for real-time rendering of ultra-high resolution models for post-compute analysis or pre-prod/pre-analysis design work.
Quadro cards are not more useful in CUDA computations when compared to the Tesla cards.
They're different beasts for different scenarios.
Disclaimer: I'm an HPC administrator.
Moreover, they stay silent in the forums now. They don't listen to customer feedback or at least give any signs of hope or assurance. Their company image became too dominant and arrogant (I think it runs more than skin-deep).
Some of the nVidia's huge market share is coming from the momentum they have. Linux users do not refresh their hardware too frequently generally.
I'm running a GTX680 on my primary Linux box, but it won't be nVidia next time. I'll be returning back to red team and I'd be a happy camper.