News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:49PM (#25975298)
I have worked with Deloitte on two projects (on clients' side, I would never willingly work for Deloitte). Generally expect them to do absolute minimum necessary to meet the contract. The code was obfuscated to ensure support contract. The people employed to write it were not interested in the quality in the slightest but were interested a lot in specifics of the contract.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:08PM (#25975825)
Serious question: why doesn't the government have its own internal software development department at this point? One that's familiar with all the regulatory and bureaoucratic hurdles and the legacy systems, but doesn't have the incentive to grift. For the amount of money they spend on these contracts surely they could afford to pay competitive salaries?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by offtop5 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:27PM (#25975948)
For various reasons this wouldn't work, you have the various bands of government salary

https://federalnewsnetwork.com/pay/2020/01/more-top-career-e...

>But for a GS-15, step 10 in Washington, his or her salary should total roughly $185,509 in 2020. But due to the federal pay ceiling, that same GS-15, step 10 in Washington will make the limit of $170,800 this year.

And that's the absolute Max, after you go to the trouble of getting a security clearance, which you just don't need in the private sector.

Even government contracting involves so much red tape, more innovative engineers would probably just rather not do it.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:30PM (#25975973)
That may be a low salary compared to FAAMNG, but it's quite reasonable for the rest of tech. It's a good bit more than I make with 6 years of experience in Austin, and I currently make almost twice as much as I did when I started.

They don't need industry-leading researchers, they need people who can build a maintainable business systems.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by offtop5 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:41PM (#25976023)
That's the absolute Max though. You need to justify that.

It's infinitely easier to make on 170k happen in the private sector, then as a federal employee. Unless the government wants to create like a special ops tech department which doesn't use the government pay grades, more money can be made in the private sector.

I'm only mid-career or so and I'm already at around 200. But I don't, at least on paper have the qualifications to architect out a whole system. And while we all want to act like we could whip up this entire thing with VueJs in a weekend, pretty sure there's some God forsaken legacy system it needs to hook into.

Since most engineers don't want to work with legacy systems for less than market pay, the engineers who end up working on this stuff tend to not be all that great.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:44PM (#25976038)
They only have to be better than the Deloitte grifters
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by offtop5 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:04AM (#25976152)
The article mentions Florida using Eventbrite.

That seems like a much better solution rather than rolling your own.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brabel on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:48AM (#25977220)
Tell that to the people on this thread trying to justify how 45M is reasonable for a project like this because "software development is just a small part of the process". If a state can use freaking Eventbrite for this, clearly they are wrong.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by pas on Sunday January 31, 2021 @06:21AM (#25977985)
Are they justifying or explaining?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by philipkiely on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:25AM (#25976569)
Also, the core benefits (health insurance, retirement, etc) are better than most companies. Sure, you don't get the perks, but the core stuff is there.

For example, I'd rate access to Blue Cross Blue Shield Federal Employee Program health insurance for you + spouse for life and kids through 26 as worth 2-3k per month, and invaluable if you or a dependent has a serious health condition.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by hakfoo on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:24AM (#25976880)
I hear this sort of objection for all sorts of civil-service employment.

TBH, I'm surprised we've never seen a proposal of the form "Federal employee salaries are not subject to income tax."

With a single line of legislation, that makes all federal job offers immediately 10-35% more competitive, without actually increasing salaries directly.

Once you get that as precedent, I could see it being used aggressively as a social tool: "We can't pay a public school teacher more than 60k, but we can pay them 60k tax-free, which is a little more competitive with a 75k private-sector position", for example.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by flurben on Sunday January 31, 2021 @09:47AM (#25979185)
As far as federal employees go, making their salaries tax-free would cost the government lost tax revenue. It would also make a lot of voters angry because they still pay taxes, but "those bureaucrats in Washington DC exempted themselves from taxes." I can see the speeches now.

Approximately 50% of American politicians are anti-government as an ideology, and use the argument of "cutting overpaid government salaries" as a plank in their economic policy, so having well-paid gov't staff is just "waste" in their minds.

As far as teachers go, they are not employed by the federal government. In most states they are county-level employees and the counties obviously do not have authority to dictate federal income tax levels.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by s1artibartfast on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:28AM (#25979921)
I can't think of a worse solution. Sure, it effectively raises their salary, but it is full of moral pitfalls.

It is already outrageous that government employees are exempt from social security taxes.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by andrewflnr on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:23PM (#25980487)
Uh, what? Former federal employee here. I've got one of my pay stubs in front of me and there is definitely a social security line.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by s1artibartfast on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:06PM (#25982053)
It is primarily state employees (police & teachers) that are exempt from social security if they have a different state funded pension plan. Take a look at table 2 and chart 1 of this report from the social security administration[1] for some examples of rates in different states.

>In 2018, one-quarter of state and local government employees—approximately 6.5 million workers—were not covered by Social Security on their current job

I find this offensive because one of the main functions of SS is to subsidize the retirement of low earners at the expense of higher earners. As a private citizen, I don't get to opt out of this social obligation just because my 401k gets a better return.

Not only that, but as a tax payer, I will be on the hook for bailing out the public employee pension funds when they go belly up.

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v80n3/v80n3p1.html

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by dopylitty on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:09AM (#25976187)
As someone with a degree in software "engineering" and more than a decade of experience in the industry I'd gladly take a stable government job creating or maintaining important applications that help the government provide high quality and necessary services to people. I would take pride in working on such a system as a vaccine administration management platform. Instead those jobs are doled out to contracting firms whose sole purpose is to fleece the government.

Can you imagine how much better it would feel to work on important and needed systems than working on the 100th food delivery app or yet another social media facism incubator?

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by flurben on Sunday January 31, 2021 @09:56AM (#25979263)
The public sector has a whole layer of complexity that doesn't exist at all (edit: as much) in the private sector, and I can promise you it frequently does NOT feel good at all.

It is difficult to explain but people tend to use the word "bureaucracy" as a catch-all for several dozen discrete problems that crop up in different combinations depending on what level of govt you're operating.

Typical examples might be :

-a developer not having the authority to work on a system

-a developer being ordered to work on a system, but not being given permissions to the necessary tools (even if they're available), or they may prohibit certain common-sense tools, or they may force you to use certain tools.

-a developer being ordered to work on a system where the design is severely irrational, maybe impossible, and but he or she has no authority within the hierarchy to push back on requirements

-a developer being ordered to work on a system that some powerful person wants to see fail

Imagine the "client from hell" that many of us have dealt with before, who doesn't know what they want. Now imagine that person is like 3 levels higher than you, calling the shots, and you're not even allowed to speak to them, much less push back against their crazy expectations.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by davemp on Sunday January 31, 2021 @05:46PM (#25983367)
I’ve experienced a few of those situations. Absolutely soul crushing, the only feasible move is to run as fast as possible.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by gunsch on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:04AM (#25976768)
There are government contractors who are doing this kind of work! There's a group of younger companies that grew up around the Healthcare.gov rescue and work in conjunction with USDS, trying to build cultures of better software development practices in government. Check out the companies in the Digital Services Coalition (https://digitalservicescoalition.org/) and you'll see a lot of companies doing the kind of work you talk about.

I work for Ad Hoc (one of these companies) on software projects at the VA, and I'm happy to chat with anyone who's interested to hear more about this kind of work. I left a cushy Google job to work on important and needed systems, and it does feel so much better!

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:20AM (#25976867)
But why does it have to go through a contractor system at all? Why can't they keep developers on staff, who among other things can retain institutional knowledge?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by gunsch on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:23AM (#25977118)
I replied to your other comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25975825 about that exact question!

One weird thing we've discovered working on VA.gov for the last five years is that we on the contractor side actually have retained a lot more institutional knowledge than the VA has. It's a problem! We think that knowledge should be on the government side, but the structure isn't there yet: USDS and 18F have rotational term limits that keep people moving through, and at the VA (not sure about other agencies) they're just in the last couple years building out an organization to do that long-term product ownership and institutional knowledge retention, even if implementation teams come through. It's moving in the right direction but it's slow, large-organization change, with a lot of extra slowness that's unique to government.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by flurben on Sunday January 31, 2021 @09:57AM (#25979276)
This would mean having elected officials, top-level managers, who knew what software development was, and prioritized those capabilities over extended periods of time.

The top 2-5 layers of management tend to be the types who want solutions, and they don't care how it works, and they don't really want to be bothered with the details.

To the extent they expend thought at all on systems, they tend to be focused primarily on questions like, "why is all this stuff so confusing?" "who do I blame when this thing goes wrong?"

Where I work, they go through cycles; a higher-up will say "Hey let's build a staff of in-house developers." And they'll do that for 2 or 3 years, until someone reads an article in CIO magazine about how outsourcing is superior. Then they'll start unfairly purging and firing developers, writing code is now "bad", configuration is "Good." This goes on for several years, until the cycle starts over. So as a developer, after you survive your first purge, you begin to see that invisibility is the only way to survive.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:32AM (#25976315)
Exactly! That feeling of improving society would go a long way toward balancing out the pain of working on legacy systems
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by offtop5 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:11AM (#25976811)
I mean I do this for the money
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by deathgrips on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:26AM (#25976577)
If you are interested in doing software development for the government, please browse USAjobs.gov or the careers section of any government department/agency you are interested in. It's a pain in the ass to apply and the government will take months to respond to your applications, but if you're highly qualified you will get a call.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by baby on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:48AM (#25976680)
That's actually much more than I imagined o_O and a government job is usually pretty stable as well.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by clintonb on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:27PM (#25975949)
It does: https://www.usds.gov/. It's my understanding that USDS also bids on projects, but isn't necessarily the go-to team for such work.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by gunsch on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:13AM (#25976820)
As others have mentioned already, 18F and USDS are in this space. They do some work, but their scope and manpower is limited, and they try to multiply their impact through contracting. Part of that is helping federal agencies write better contracts to be able to source the kind of contractors they want --- ones who think in terms of product development, user research ("build with, not for"), and are using modern software development practices. Bringing in contractors helps them multiply their impact, especially with how difficult hiring people into government is. (and a lot of people in tech simply didn't want to work directly under the Trump administration, which --- as liberal as the tech field tends to lean, seems to be a factor on hiring at 18F and USDS).

I work at one of the contractors in the space (Ad Hoc [1]) and get to work with people from USDS every day. Like others have commented here, the government salary ranges are a problem for them to hire enough. Our last COO had been an administrator at OPM, and would say things like "on the government side, I couldn't ever hire the kinds of software developers that we're able to here on the contractor side."

[1] https://adhoc.team/ -- we're hiring, full-time remote!

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by info781 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:23AM (#25979882)
Nothing against your company, but when smaller companies get good long term contracts, they get bought up by larger companies and the good people leave and start new smaller companies.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:47AM (#25976399)
I'm reminded of a guy that used to go on Leo Laporte's podcast and had a program or joined a program where Silicon Valley tech people join government entities to make their tech and websites better. I'm sure they took massive paycuts to do this but they felt it was their duty, like military service. This guy and others like him are true heroes and patriots to me.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ergocoder on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:38AM (#25976348)
Generally, it's much better for the government to outsource. More competency and reduce corruption.

I came from a country where government tries to do all these things in house. It was bad. Paying premium isn't a big problem.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by brundolf on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:55AM (#25976442)
I mean, the main theme of this thread is the existing incompetency and corruption
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by catlifeonmars on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:20AM (#25976552)
Based on the rest of its thread, it looks like the corruption has also been outsourced.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by test6554 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:59AM (#25977032)
"One that's familiar with all the regulatory and bureaoucratic hurdles and the legacy systems"

How much does it cost to get a qualified person to put up with all that though?

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by et-al on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:27PM (#25975947)
There's 18F for the US government, but unfortunately they're limited by government salary caps and other policies.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by thrwn_frthr_awy on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:53PM (#25975727)
I too worked with Deloitte. The goal was to get the project signed-off on as quickly as possible because once that is done they get to bill time for maintenance/bugs. QA did not exists.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by throwhtrhwthrow on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:44AM (#25976666)
throwaway for obvious reasons. I've worked with Deloitte, PwC, KPMG, and other big consultancies for a diverse range of reasons (regulation audits, security reviews, staff augmentations, etc.) and the value you get for the money you're paying is pretty insane. I'd say the value you're getting is probably 20% of the price you're paying, and I'm being optimistic. You can get good value if you know the people you're hiring, if you scope your project well, and if you have clear expectations. But let me tell you, nobody knows how to do this, unless they've been on the other side.

Now, you don't always have a choice, the expertise is sometimes there, or you need one of the big four to do a prior audit before a real audit from another big four. But be prepared to have a team of OK people who will spend a lot of time producing slides and organize unproductive meetings with lots of other people (including yours) to give out a false sense of "we're making progress here". You'll have to do the PM'ing and be extremely strict with what you want from them, and you'll have to be ready to collaborate heavily. What I mean by this is: don't wait for them to ask questions, you'll have to do most of the work of onboarding them, almost like they're your coworker except that they don't have connections with the folks they need to work with, they don't have access to internal stuff, they don't know how to get there.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by aasasd on Sunday January 31, 2021 @04:45AM (#25977537)
Sounds like one should split the system into small parts, order each one as a separate contract and basically micromanage the contractor into delivering the actual thing.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by madaxe_again on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:54AM (#25977245)
The people doing the development were likely not developers. A particularly common path is studying a random subject at university, doing a law conversion course, failing to get a pupillage or a position with a commercial solicitors, and going to Deloitte as a trainee consultant.

There, they put you through a six week course in which you become a developer, and you’re then hired out for £800 a day as a technical expert.

Source: literally half the people I went to university with.

Fond memories of sitting at the kitchen table and trying to coach my flat mate through unfucking the air ground traffic control system that they were writing for BAA in VB5, in 2005. No idea if it ever went into production.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by bitcharmer on Sunday January 31, 2021 @06:55AM (#25978170)
I worked on huge projects in telco where big consultancies where a common thing. We had a joke about Accenture and their tactics. Upon being questioned about the quality of the software they delivered they would reply:

"There was no requirement that the whole thing should work. We can put in a change request and bill separately".

Also - the "no one has ever been fired for hiring IBM" syndrome among the higher management.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by sillysaurusx on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:00PM (#25975381)
Lol.

How was the code obfuscated?

That brings back memories of php obfuscator. What a strange world that was. I think there was even a deobfuscator that tried to rename the variables sensibly, or something.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:02PM (#25975392)
Well, you can make simple functionalities so baroque that you will not be able to work with them without some kind of notes. It is not easy to define in contract what is sane code.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by sillysaurusx on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:04PM (#25975404)
But that just sounds like regular big company codebases. I see no difference.

At Scottrade, I was horrified to find a 5k or 10k line Date C++ class. They'd copy paste functions to handle each leap year individually. The function names themselves contained the specific year.

They also yelled at me for downloading the source code to `touch`.

It was nice to get to see the crazy side of software. Everyone was deadpan serious about it too.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:11PM (#25975448)
Well surely there were tests...
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by sillysaurusx on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:20PM (#25975527)
Nope! They solved it the opposite way. Their bug tracking system consisted of individual customers who called up to report bugs. I.e. Joe Blow would call up and say "Hey, I'm supposed to see 231 shares, but I only see 219 shares."

That would result in a bug report. The bug report was that Joe Blow saw that outcome. In other words, the bug report didn't contain anything about the code itself.

They had an entire division of support people whose job was to track these bugs, and to fix them.

In order to fix the bug, they would manually edit the database, or do whatever was necessary to make sure Joe Blow saw the right value again. But they never changed the code; they weren't programmers.

Once Joe Blow was happy, they closed the bug report as "fixed."

Therefore, no tests were ever required.

It was ... impressive? I think? I couldn't mentally process what I was seeing at the time. But "impressive" is probably the right word. After all, the system worked.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by lonnyk on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:53AM (#25976432)
How did they verify that Joe Blow was actually supposed to have 231 shares instead of 219?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by sillysaurusx on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:42AM (#25976656)
I always wondered that! I assume they had a "ground truth" financial order book somewhere (which presumably was held to much higher standards of correctness) and that the support staff manually verified their balance.

But ... that logic doesn't work if you chase down the implications. And sadly I was both too shocked and too young to press my coworker for details. (He was a cool older fellow who seemed as amused with the craziness.)

Eventually I became a pentester at Matasano. During my one-year stint, I was parachuted into around 70 codebases. I got to see first-hand that Scottrade wasn't an outlier; they were the average. Most companies have similar WTFs, and the codebases are just as onerous.

The world is held together with duct-tape. That's why pentesting is so crucial.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by StrauXX on Sunday January 31, 2021 @05:37AM (#25977777)
In Austria (at least in the province I am living in) the provincial government does have its own software development departmant. I am currently working with them (for free :)) on a software project of theirs for a class.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:19PM (#25975513)
They're getting paid for a deliverable. Why do you expect free work?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by eCa on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:48AM (#25976690)
I have only worked directly with an external consultancy company once, and the problem (the way I see it) is that the incentives are mis-aligned.

A good internal developer will notice that requirements are missing, or could be improved, and has the incentive to bring it up with the project manager and get it fixed.

That incentive does not necessarily exist for a consultancy developer, because as you say that means their employer loses money.

My conclusion: Use consultans for very well defined and testable problems that don’t require too much business-specific domain knowledge.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by alasdair_ on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:09PM (#25975832)
> They're getting paid for a deliverable. Why do you expect free work?

And this is how we get the 737 Max.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:26PM (#25975945)
You're right, we should just expect free work from all developers. Because if you want to be a good developer, you have to meet this imaginary bar made up by other developers who want to show off about how "much extra work we do."

The point is the ask for the 737 Max wasn't a "plane that doesn't work." It was for a plane that does work. That was the deliverable. It wasn't met. That is not doing the bare minimum.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by civilized on Sunday January 31, 2021 @12:14AM (#25976216)
And this situation is different how? The CDC needed a website that works. Deloitte did not deliver a website that works. If it had, it would not have been abandoned, flushing $44M of work down the drain.

You could also apply this weaselly BS to Boeing. Their "ask", if there was one, was to make a plane that customers would buy and that would pass FAA review. Not "a plane that works".

No one's contract just says "make an X that works", even though that's what everyone wants. Because an X that works is hard to define. Fundamentally the system depends on honor and trust. Which is why we despise losers that just try to get paid and fuck the customer.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:36AM (#25979981)
They didn't meet the deliverable so they shouldn't be paid.

This isn't rocket science. Think.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by awestroke on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:47AM (#25976673)
Free work from developers? Deloitte got 44 million. Do you think they would get no salary for the extra hours spent on making it not suck?
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:36AM (#25979983)
If they didn't deliver a functioning website as per the CDCs requirements they shouldn't have been paid.

If the CDC signed off on it, it isn't deloitte's fault. Sorry.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by raverbashing on Sunday January 31, 2021 @04:38AM (#25977499)
Obfuscating the code and deliberately adding technical debt is not "the bare minimum", but it is shipping a planned obsolete product.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:37AM (#25979990)
That's your fault for buying it then. If you don't state what you want in a contract, this will always happen.

All you SV elitists do it, you just want to hoard the wealth for yourselves. It's not just deloitte, all the SVs do the same damn thing.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by imranq on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:37PM (#25975626)
No good engineer I've worked with only did the bare minimum. Usually it was 2x or 3x beyond that e.g. thinking about the customer, understanding the right technologies, designing for scale, etc.
Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:28PM (#25975954)
The bare minimum is the deliverable. If it's "a working website that does X, Y, Z" and they deliver that, what is the problem? That's what was asked for.

> thinking about the customer, understanding the right technologies, designing for scale, etc.

If they were asked to design something for a customer then they're fulfilling what is asked - e.g., the bare minimum.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by lmilcin on Sunday January 31, 2021 @06:25AM (#25978007)
Imagine you are signing a contract with a car shop to add a spoiler to your car.

The car shop spends months of your time obsessing about the dimensions of the spoiler. Then the car is out of service for as much time and you start wondering what they have been doing.

Then the car arrives and there is a bunch of paint missing around the spoiler, the spoiler is completely unpainted an it falls off when you accelerate to 100mph.

So you ask, "WTF?" and they tell you that none of these things were specified in the contract.

That's more or less how it worked.

I have been contracted for a number of projects and I always assume some level of standard that my client would want me to meet.

For example, around 2003 I have been contracted by a publishing house to restore couple of their servers. Their employees made a mess they were not able to get out of, completely mangled Linux distributions, took out drives out of RAID5 and did not know what to do with them, etc. Drives had files with only copies of texts of books they had so it was extremely valuable to them.

So obviously I did what ANY sane person would do:

- I have discussed with responsible employees what exactly happened,

- We went out on a little trip to buy backup drives

- We made backups of every single drive involved in the mess (I keep saying we because I involved the guys in the recovery so they know how it works)

- We put together the drives and they worked

- We fixed OS-es which they mangled

- We tested that everything works

- We have discussed why they need some procedures and especially backup procedures

- I have showed them how to construct couple of these procedures so that they know how to do that.

I didn't have to do all that. I was already being paid handsomely for the recovery and would not suffer (other than lost pay) if I failed recovery. But I also recognize how important this data was for the company and so I took necessary precautions proportional to how important this.

Re:CDC website built by Deloitte at a cost of $44M is abando... by ntsplnkv2 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:38AM (#25980000)
This isn't how life works.

If spoiler work fails instantly you can say it wasn't done properly, which is true. You then withhold payment, or sue.

Not that complicated. Not worth a damn novel post from you either.