News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by auggierose on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:53PM (#25973853)
A personal experience is a fact. It is a fact we can be pretty sure of, and we know the context of that fact. Obviously, once we extrapolate from that experienced fact, it becomes bias.

A fact that is not a personal experience is difficult to trust. Even if I trust the source of that fact, I am often not sure if I understand the fact properly. Anyone who has ever tried to understand a math theorem might relate.

It is entirely rational to trust more in your personal bias. In fact, I would argue that the only way to trust a fact is to make it somehow into something that you can personally experience. For example, to understand a math theorem, it helps to look at lots of different kinds of examples where it holds (and where it doesn't).

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by hashkb on Saturday January 30, 2021 @06:05PM (#25973929)
Eyewitness testimony is a personal experience that's been well proven to be poorly correlated with others' personal experience of the same event. You may be redefining "fact".
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by auggierose on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:56PM (#25976116)
I am not redefining fact, but you are trying to reinterpret a personal experience as something it isn't. A personal experience is not an objective accurate fact about the world. There is no such thing. It can only ever be a bias. Just as an example can usually not be the proof of a theorem, just an indication that the theorem might be true.
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by hashkb on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:19PM (#25991522)
There are facts. Like: "My laptop will not run indefinitely without power". Right?
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by auggierose on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @09:53AM (#26001590)
Tell that "fact" to a person not speaking English. Or to somebody who has never seen a laptop. Or to somebody, who doesn't know what "power" is. If you interpret "indefinitely" as in "within my lifetime", will that sentence still be true in the future?

Once we've stripped the contextual stuff from your sentence, your sentence is a fact in a similar way to "1 = 1" being a fact. These kinds of facts are not that terribly interesting, because they are context-free, and context is usually the entire point of a fact.

Oh, and I would argue that your laptop does not run indefinitely without power is a very personal experience, at least for me.

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by 6AA4FD on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:39PM (#25974917)
I agree that person experiences are not exactly reliable, but I think it's also good to remember that they can have the appearance of facticity and accuracy, as indicated by the sentiment of the person you were replying to.
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by space_rock on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:52PM (#25975723)
Please tell me where you get your input if not from personal experience? Logical fallacy to say because interpretation of sensory inputs is not perfect therefore we are bind and know nothing about the world
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by hashkb on Monday February 01, 2021 @01:14PM (#25991470)
You're attacking a straw man.

My point is that there's a method by which we start from observations and, through a process that (critically) involves other people, we reach an objective understanding of a subject. The observations aren't facts, but the conclusions can be.

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by jmcqk6 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @04:20PM (#25982663)
> A personal experience is a fact. It is a fact we can be pretty sure of, and we know the context of that fact. Obviously, once we extrapolate from that experienced fact, it becomes bias.

> A fact that is not a personal experience is difficult to trust.

I think this is a very common sentiment, because of the immediacy of the experience, but that doesn't make it true.

My biggest gains as a human came when I started questioning whether my natural interpretation of the world was actually very good. It turns out, my natural inclinations for understanding things is pretty bad, and now that I recognize that, I am a much more effective human being.

Having gone through that journey, I now spot it all over the place with others. People misinterpret the world all of the time, and they do it without question because it's their personal experience, and how can that be wrong? It's too bad. We waste so much potential not accounting for our own limitations.

Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by auggierose on Monday February 01, 2021 @05:22AM (#25987358)
I don't disagree with you. You just don't understand what I wrote.
Re:Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides b... by inadequatespace on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @01:38AM (#25997990)
Right, STEM-types tend to lampoon religion due to being based on "mere faith" rather than "hard evidence."

But anything that is not directly experienced by oneself requires some substantial faith; one cannot possibly redo all science experiments oneself and personally collect evidence.

Therefore one must have faith that the aggregate scientists had no motivation to skew or misrepresent evidence.

As a scientist, I know how reasonable doubting this to be.