News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by jackfoxy on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:38PM (#25971056)
Consider this:

Every Satoshi can be traced back to when it was mined. The IRS now requires Americans and resident aliens filing income tax returns to report on their crypto holdings. Lots (maybe most?) people use exchanges like CoinBase. (Remember, not your keys, not your coins.)

If the government believes (they do not even have to prove) your Satoshis were ever used for illicit transactions, they can legally seize those assets. (Sorry, we don't think you were involved, but these coins are criminals.) To simplify things they just need to show a judge reasonable cause of structuring sometime in the coin's history. That has to be super easy to do. https://www.goldinglawyers.com/structuring-cash-transactions

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by rrll22 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:05PM (#25971904)
> Every Satoshi can be traced back to when it was mined

This is blatantly wrong, do you have a source for that? Transactions can have multiple inputs and multiple outputs; "which satoshi comes from which input" is not a valid question; transactions are about value sums of inputs and outputs.

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by acdha on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:02PM (#25974327)
Is there any reason to think that the taint bit wouldn’t be applied to all outputs from such a transaction, just as a mob money laundering operation didn’t avoid prosecution because some of the income was legitimate?
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by mrtksn on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:06PM (#25971319)
Most non-techies I know simply buy and sell from an exchange, never touching the real chain. For them, bitcoin is the number on the screen they see when they log in.

Unless the USA imposes the strict FATCA and AML to all global exchanges , forcing countries to act as if exchanges are banks and comply,It would be easy to just use non-American exchanges stay out of trouble.

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by jackfoxy on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:48PM (#25971742)
Sure, your coins are where the government can's touch them. But if you do not comply with the IRS reporting rules and your body is where the government can touch you, watch out.

But you're right. If USG does go down this path of crypto suppression (and this is pure speculation at this point) US based exchanges are vulnerable first.

I imagine nothing like this would unfold without coordination with the EU and five eyes.

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by andrewjl on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:37PM (#25973725)
Tax enforcement prioritization roughly follows the shape of wealth/income distribution. Focusing on the long-tail isn't impactful, as far as fiscal concerns go.

You'd achieve about the same result tax wise w/ muscular KYC/AML requirements for crypto exchanges/custodians in the US as you would w/ a ban.

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by paxys on Saturday January 30, 2021 @03:06PM (#25972481)
Saying "the government can technically do XYZ" is pointless when there is no precedent and it has never been challenged in court. What would the reaction be if the government bust into your home and took your wallet because one of the dollar notes in it was used for a robbery 10 years and hundreds of owners ago?
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by y04nn on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:46PM (#25971133)
This this a known issue, not all coins are the same, but I read recently that there is work in progress to use Schnorr signatures that would fix this problem by mixing multiple signatures into a single one.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by vmception on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:43PM (#25971100)
Structuring doesn't apply to cryptocurrencies and there is no reporting threshold to be avoided yet. There are some proposals to make thresholds. Structuring currently only applies to physical cash passing a boarder or physical cash entering or exiting a financial institution. It does not apply to institution to institution transfers of any type and it doesn't apply to cryptocurrencies at the moment. I’ve had this discussion before, FinCEN is trying to change that.

Because structuring is a criminal law, they would need to show a court a bit more to convict. But before a conviction they could make your life complicated with dumb rationale to a judge for a warrant or seizure notice, and that has nothing to do with cryptocurrency, everyone relies on the government and private persons not making their life complicated.

Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by jackfoxy on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:39PM (#25971630)
Yes. This would be new legal territory, but not radically new (IANAL). USG would certainly pick the case and the court to try it in carefully in order to establish the precedent.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by vmception on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:27PM (#25973173)
Structuring regulations are very clear about physical cash in and out of a licensed financial institution (or avoiding declarations to customs). Most agencies and representatives have made it clear they aren't trying to debilitate bitcoin or bitcoin use. This fanfiction of the government not letting bitcoin be useful as a competitor is a weak argument mostly because the ship has sailed, about a decade ago.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by me551ah on Saturday January 30, 2021 @02:17PM (#25972020)
Bitcoin mixers do a pretty good job of obsfucating transaction history and maintaining anonymity.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by jackfoxy on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:39PM (#25973743)
Smells like money laundering.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by louloulou on Friday February 05, 2021 @08:08PM (#26043166)
It's called financial privacy. Most people don't want all their past and future transactions to be visible to anyone they happen to pay for something.
Re:India proposes law to ban cryptocurrencies, create offici... by SerLava on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:43PM (#25971103)
Damn, you're probably right, even though it would never work that way for a greenback.