News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by jzer0cool on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:56AM (#25966916)
When programming y'all able to access all the bracket set <>()[]{} and special symbols !@#$....?/,., well without looking at the keyboard? I never gained proficiency to do that. And these days, I feel I use the backspace/delete key too often.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:17AM (#25967868)
My keyboard has no markings, except for the name of the manufacturer.

I have no trouble hitting any key on the keyboard without looking at it. I can lock eyes with you while you dictate and type the email you would dictate, perfectly (albeit not at the a normal dictation speed, I only type about 100WPM at most). I can fix errors as I type using backspace because I always know where I am and where I made a mistake.

The important part is learning this correctly.

I had fortune of going to school where for a single semester I had a course in typing documents on an electric typewriter, with a professional typewriting teacher.

Because it was so long ago I have trouble understanding not being able to type. I lay my hands on the keyboard and they just do it without me even thinking about it. I don't even know where keys are. If you ask me where a particular key is I can only point to handful of them. Otherwise I need to put my all fingers on the keyboard and think the key and then observe which finger goes where, and only then I know where the key is.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by stevekemp on Saturday January 30, 2021 @06:28AM (#25968251)
When I was a teenager my sisters went to typing classes on a weekend, and my parents insisted I go with them. I suspect I was mostly encouraged to make sure my parents had some free time alone, without the children, but it was definitely useful!

These days I can type 55-75 words per minute, and have no difficulty typing "blind".

Edit: Did a trivial online typing test, at typingtest.com, for a few minutes "Typing Speed 98 WPM, Accuracy 99 % Adjusted Speed 97 WPM" So better than I estimated!

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by franklyt on Saturday January 30, 2021 @06:15AM (#25968176)
On the flip side of this, I type at 130-140WPM and never learned to type “properly”. I use my index fingers.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @06:21AM (#25968213)
I think of myself as "mechanically challenged". No matter how much I train, I cannot break 100WPM while typing effortlessly. And this goes to other activities that require hands to be agile and precise like playing instruments, which I never was able to do well regardless of how much effort I put into it.

So I understand that there is a lot of people who are much more naturally agile with their hands.

But I still think learning to type properly has huge advantages. Even if you dismiss every other advantage (say you decide you don't need to type fast), I think it just feels extremely satisfying to be able to focus on anything you want while your hands just produce constant stream of characters on the screen in a flowing, effortless motion.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by aspyct on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:27AM (#25970351)
140wpm only with your index fingers? I'm gonna need a video of that :)
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by franklyt on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:12PM (#25973046)
You’re going to have to take my word for it, not much incentive for me to go through all of that to sate your doubts.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:57PM (#25973399)
Let's do some calculation. 120-140WPM = 600-700 characters per minute or about 10-12 characters per second.

Even in ideal situation where consecutive characters fall are alternating between left and right hand, that gives 5-6 characters PER SECOND for a single finger to type.

This guy does it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9psfOxJysw

But it does not look comfortable or effortless at all.

Add to it that you have to look at the keyboard instead of comfortably focus on the screen, you are straining your hands, your eyes and your neck.

So you still loose.

It is a gimmick, there is no way you can work like this hour after hour, day after day, year after year. Most likely this is some kind top speed you can technically reach, but you will not be able to sustain.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by franklyt on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:34PM (#25973703)
Your calculations are pretty fast and loose and involve heavy-weight assumptions.

I don’t look at the keyboard to type with two fingers (and my thumb, technically).

I can probably sustain 120 effortlessly. 130-140 if I’m comfortable.

I’ve been doing it for nearly two decades and haven’t had a problem.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by lmilcin on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:50PM (#25973828)
How my calculations are loose if it is the numbers you have stated in your post? The rest is just a consequence.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by thejellypen on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:30AM (#25970383)
I'm skeptical..
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by wodenokoto on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:24AM (#25967629)
Do you use US layout?

I’d say most of those very difficult on non-us (especially Mac!) and after I switched from Nordic keyboard to US I had a small epiphany about why we use the symbols we use in programming.

But honestly it doesn’t matter. I glance at the key it while typing. There is nothing wrong with that

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by luizfelberti on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:45AM (#25969959)
I'd second this. Switching to US ANSI layout (not US International layout) is like magic, I find it so much better that I always import my keyboards from the US, and only buy laptops if they have the US layout.

Brazil uses a national standard called ABNT2 (which I consider to be an awful format), but to my advantage, I find the way Macs do accentuation (at least for latin alphabets) to be quite sensible (alt+vowel), and get angry whenever I have to use Linux because it doesn't have "Mac accents"

For your case though, I think the Nordic alphabet might be trickier on the US layout, since it shares less common ground and there's a lot more to it

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by MauranKilom on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:51AM (#25968652)
I switch regularly between German and US keyboard layout (due to different physical keyboards and also having to communicate in different languages).

It is terrible that ( and ) are on the 8 and 9 keys in German layout and on 9 and 0 on US. It frustrates me to no end (add in how IDEs will auto-complete parentheses and I'm constantly lost in a complex decision tree of how to recover from being one key off) and I can't seem to build muscle memory well like this. The other symbol keys are also a wash. Particular offenders are y and z, ? and -, " vs Ä vs @, as well as + (who came up with the idea of requiring shift for that?!).

I just can't intuitively keep up with what layout is active and/or how to adjust my typing, even if it's always the same for the same application. Frequently I settle for "try one thing and correct if necessary". Obviously slows me down a lot.

Any suggestions welcome.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by CuriousSkeptic on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:24AM (#25968847)
Can mostly offer my sympathy. Have the same problem with the Swedish layout. Especially the fact that all systems seems to have their own placement of the | character is quite hard on me.

At the moment I’m trying to handle it my learning to code in the se-layout. Isn’t looking promising though, don’t think I’ll ever get used to the {} (it’s a bit curious that the Mac has the Swedish letters printed on the keys but not the other symbols you need)

I think when I finally give up on this I’ll try a en layout that lets you type the required umlauts and rings by combining instead.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by Asraelite on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:57AM (#25969083)
I have my keyboard set to UK Extended. It's able to do most diacritics, so I just stick to it even when typing German and other suitable languages, like French.

Umlauted vowels are done with AltGr+[ followed by the vowel. ß is done with AltGr+S. It's a tiny bit less ergonomic than having dedicated keys for these letters, but I consider the tradeoff worth it since the letters don't occur too frequently in German and I only need to memorize one keyboard layout.

I don't know if something similar is available for US layouts.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by codethief on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:08AM (#25970153)
Of course there's only so much you can do if you're facing a (physical) US keyboard (as it lacks a key or two, compared to the German keyboard) but you could, at the very least, adjust its (virtual) layout so that it resembles the German one more closely. Of course this assumes that you're touch-typing and not looking at the keyboard because otherwise its labels might confuse you.

As for communicating in different languages, though, why do you feel the need to regularly switch between the German and US keyboard? IMO the German keyboard can do everything at least as well as the US one can (in terms of accents and so on), except for braces and brackets.

If the latter bother you (I know quite a few people who use the US keyboard for this reason): Why not adjust the second and/or third layer of your (German) keyboard layout and make braces and brackets more easily accessible? Same goes for any features that you might be missing.

A lot of people seem to be recommending switching to an entirely new (first-layer) layout while your issue could probably be fixed by:

1. changing the second and third layer

2. using that same layout everywhere, on both US and German keyboards.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by type0 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:01AM (#25969117)
Get yourself an US ISO keyboard or US keycaps and then set up a modifier key combination for special characters, it's best if you have some extra keys dedicated for macros though.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by yiyus on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:04AM (#25969615)
> suggestions welcome

I had a similar problem (Spanish and English keyboard share the () problem, and we have ñ where ; usually is, but Spanish keyboards are qwerty and not azerty). I switched to the US-international keyboard layout and use that to write in any language now. I find it a good compromise, although it's not perfect neither to write in Spanish nor to program/write in English.

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by Aerroon on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:32AM (#25969852)
The problem is that it's much more difficult to type the üöä needed for your other language.
Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by mr_t on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:35AM (#25967683)
Never used it so far, but recently came across the NEO keyboard layout [1]. Unfortunately the website is in German only, but just looking at the interactive graphic should give you sufficient information how it looks like. The only German word you need to know to understand the graphic is „Ebene“, which means layer. What I find particularly interesting is „Ebene 3“, or „layer 3“ and the corresponding repurposing of the capslock key. Personally I definitely intend to try the NEO layout soon.

[1] https://neo-layout.org/

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by richardw on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:39AM (#25968953)
I use a keyboard called “programmer Dvorak” that makes those characters first-class citizens. You need shift for numbers. I can do the numbers fine but it took a while.

Not sure I’d recommend it though, need to learn normal Dvorak for use on other computers where you can’t install a keyboard.

I can’t look at the keyboard. If I do I’m instantly confused. And I can’t use a Dvorak view on mobile - just looks too different. Maybe I should try again...

Re:Keyboard that shocks you if you type with incorrect techn... by StavrosK on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:50AM (#25967747)
I don't have 100% accuracy with the symbols in the numbers (except the parentheses), but am pretty good with them. Nowadays I've remapped the parentheses to left/right shift and the brackets to Tab+hjkl, so it's much easier.