I get what you are saying, and agree with your decision to not talk to the police, but it isn’t true that there can be NO upside to talking to the police.
For all the bad things police do, they DO also solve some crimes and arrest some dangerous people. If someone killed one of my loved ones, I would hope the police would be able to find, arrest, and successfully prosecute the murderer.
If no witness will speak to the police, it makes solving a homicide much more difficult.
This is why the current approach to policing is so awful. We should work on fixing the system so talking to the police is a good thing.
Exactly. Addressing your example, as it's a good one: To be blunt, me risking the legal standing or overall safety of my family just to bring your family some closure is not a trade-off I'm willing to make. I'm genuinely sorry because I would absolutely like to help, but the downside risk is too great.
I am in an incredibly privileged position in our society, and I've gotten grief at the hands of the police while I was being a "good citizen" and offering information. Never again. If they want to know something we will be doing it in full view of the public out on the street or with my lawyer present.
"public out on the street or with my lawyer present."
Isn't a large reason why one shouldn't talk to the police because they may intentionally misconstrue what you say? Being in public won't solve that, hence the lawyer bit.If I absolutely must speak to an officer without a lawyer present, we will be outside in public, not indoors in private. If that's not acceptable to the officer...well, too bad.
(Though, the hilarity of it is, I am in a position where I can even say no to an officer and the officer will likely respect it. I "look like" I have the resources to push back on police abuse, so police are less likely to abuse me. If I didn't look like that, I probably wouldn't even have the chance to say no, at least not without a lot of pressure.)
That's why you need a lawyer present.
And it's probably even more risky if you are a witness or have useful information. Putting yourself at a crime scene - even if you saw nothing - seems like a bad idea these days. "Oh you were there but you did see anything? Reeeealy?"
Getting back to the headline, I think they need to at least be required to tell the truth in court.
I'll be happy to provide the police with any information as long as I'm under the advisement of a lawyer.
I'll willingly testify in a court.
The problem is talking to the police directly by myself, as the police naturally see all related people as suspects. You are a witness in your own eyes; you are a suspect in theirs.
If I can't get a lawyer when question by a police officer, I don't answer a question.
(It's different if I'm in a courtroom, obviously)
> I get what you are saying, and agree with your decision to not talk to the police
They DID talk to the police. (They said, "We'll answer any questions here")
Bringing them inside your home really doesn't have an upside. I don't invite armed strangers inside my home as a rule, and making an exception is unnecessary.
If your trust in a police officer is so low that you put them on equal ground as people who carry guns (criminals or police, in my country) then something is very wrong.
You might be paranoid, you might live in a country where the law is corrupt, a combination of that, or something else. For sure, something is very wrong.
I've helped the police with crime cases. Doing so, makes my society a little bit more safe and just. I also got help from police when I needed them. Then again, not living in USA. My secret is sauce is simple: be honest. If being honest gets you into trouble in your country, something's off.
I don't know what you think the upside is of letting someone in a police uniform you don't know to come into your home is, no matter how rosy your view of the police.
That does not mean being completely unhelpful. That does not being unfriendly to police officers you know. That does not mean being unwelcome to police officers places that are open to the general public, like your porch, your business, your club's facility, etc. It just means that you keep your private residence private to people you didn't invite in unless legally required not to.
I'm glad you think your cops are great, but we're trying to talk about how to reform them, we already know there is a problem. US police can lie to you in order to get information, in addition to a host of other abuses. Saying "be honest to cops and everything will be fine" feels a bit glib.
If police are not allowed to lie while civilians can lie, the police are in a severe disadvantage. Perhaps the balance is tipped the wrong way, but the mere notion that police are allowed to lie isn't wrong in itself.
The authoritarian worship in this comment really says enough about the totalitarianism of your country.
Police are public servants. As such everything they do or say should be held under perjury. Police, leaders, government officials, lawyers, judges should know more about the laws than average citizens to.
Being in a position of authority and having that power should come great responsibility, so great in fact that you should have to serve 3x the prison sentence for betraying that trust.
Same should go as well for ethics violations for clergy, medical professionals, teachers, etc.
you said earlier if it was your family who was murdered you'd hope the police would do something, no?
What if it was the police who murdered your family? In L.A. the police are in actual "cliques" which are basically "gangs" with special tattoos and other gang related rights of passage.
How do you trust the police when https://reddit.com/r/policebrutality2020 has thousands of links of police hurting people, yet when people in the "in group" that they respect (white nationalists) try to destroy the foundations of our democracy, they step aside and let it happen?
With regards to police brutality, its a one sided view. Its an angle from a camera, from one point of view. It lacks different views, it lacks context. A body cam can show the context from the police PoV.
To give an example [1] shows a woman who gets blasted by a water cannon. These are meant to drive people apart. However, at that point, these people were in an area where a demonstration (which was escalating into a riot and pillaging). The area was at that point forbidden to be (which always happens for a reason). If you don't listen to such, you're on your own.
If resolving the adversarial relationship between citizens and police would improve that then it’s something we should explore. Right now I’m not sure how that could happen, given the deep problems with American Law Enforcement, Correctional, and Justice systems.
I don't think I will live long enough to see it, at least in my country. The French police is less dangerous than the US one, but they're still dangerous, even for those that committed no crime, and and not only for minorities. A (white) delivery driver was recently strangled to death by police officers in Paris in broad daylight, despite repeatedly telling them he could not breath. No administrative penalty was applied, though an inquiry has started due to the large popular outcry.
In a broader perspective, the worst terrorist attack in French history was in Paris in autumn... not 2015 but 1961. The French police wanted to terrify the Algerian people (which had French citizenship at that time). Police killed 150-200 unarmed people in a single night. The man in charge (M. Papon), like many other members of the police, had played an important role in the deportation of Jews during WWII. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_massacre_of_1961
There was a recent commotion when French policemen could be heard joking about this event, especially about "drowning the Algerians". Some sociological studies prove that the racist terms dating from the Algeria war are still pervasive in the French police more than 60 years after the war.
I thought it was bad here in USA, but I guess it's a global problem. We need to stomp out authoritarianism everywhere but heck if I know how to do that.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/194213/crime-clearance-r...
A murder case basically starts with police opening a file saying "X has been murdered" and goes on from there. So if the death looks enough like accident or natural causes or suicide, no murder case is opened and it doesn't count as an uncleared murder.
Therefore it wouldn't surprise me if the majority of murders (51%, anyway) are unsolved.
Imagine a life insurance broker that moonlights as a serial killer offing someone's spouse soon after the policy is open. The remaining spouse is going to prison for a very long time every single time.
Seems it’s only about 22% of serious crimes which are solved. Of course the beauty of these “facts” is they differ wildly.
Note I didn't say, "Never talk to the police." You need someone with you that can understand the law and how work within the system. You never know when they might consider you part of the suspect pool. You can be helpful, just be helpful while protecting your own best interests.
It's not even about understanding the system, the presence of the lawyer forces the police to establish "scope".
If I'm just a witness, then the lawyer can make sure that what I say can't later be used against me for something unrelated.
If I'm a suspect, this prevents the police from going on a fishing expedition to just "find anything". Once they talk to the lawyer, they have to go hunting for "what they told the lawyer" as opposed to everything in the world.
Interesting...do you have a reference to that handy? Thanks!
The lawyer's name is "James Duane", but I can only find his CATO Institute videos and they're not very good. :(
Yeah. Even innocuous things like having a hole in the wall changes the line of inquiry from whatever crime is being investigated to a domestic violence or child protective services intervention on your account...all because you wanted to help.
It would be in the best interest of law enforcement to grant by default some amount of immunity to witnesses in order to encourage their cooperation.
Nobody should be punished by the justice system for cooperating-- witnesses already risk retribution from whoever they're willing to make a statement against.
Long time since I watched it. I think one argument was that it’s very easy to make a mistake in what you tell and it might sound bad later on.
It's an incredibly important video that shows why there is no good that comes out of police interactions.
"Don't Talk to the Police"
Old video but still funny and very instructive.
Why would police and city councils change anything, when after somebody sues the government files a motion to dismiss because of government immunity and the motion is granted? There won't be accountability until this changes.
Good thing for everyone. That includes victims who had courage and took the risk of retaliation and perpetrators who talked about former associates.
Always talk to the police -- AFTER GETTING IMMUNITY. Basically first if they ask you anything, say "I will happily comply with any questioning if you give me immunity in writing to this case or anything resulting from my answers."
The cop who gave that presentation even mentioned getting an IRS call, and said that, they never called back.
Point is, ask for immunity.
No no no, a thousand times no. Immunity is a very nuanced thing that, in the US especially, is beyond the understanding of laypersons. Talk only to and through YOUR lawyer. Don't go anywhere near any talk of "immunity" without several days to discuss the matter with paid legal counsel.
Federal means that subnational units have some limited sovereignty, versus unitary where only the toplevel government has sovereignty.
IANAL, but if you're arrested, just ask for a lawyer. Don't try to play weird games like asking for immunity. The police have played them way more than you, you don't know the legal system and you will probably lose.
FTFY ;)
A cop can't grant you immunity, and most people wouldn't know what it meant if you did have an immunity agreement.
Obviously different if your lawyer says that requesting immunity might work, probably because you're knee deep in someone else's mess and their experience tells them that prosecution will be far more interested in your testimony against them than stuff you might need to admit to.
The bigger lesson was not to ask for immunity, but to refuse to say anything without your lawyer present. (...and then, obviously, to only say things if your lawyer advises you to do so.)
Some of these might not really be de jure OK for the cops to tell you, but would you want to rely on a court upholding that?
( https://reason.com/2011/03/08/tennessee-cops-posed-as-a-defe... in this case, the trial court even allowed it-- it had to get overturned on appeal )
There is a whole subreddit (/r/legaladvice) where the moderators are all (almost all?) law enforcement officers, where they remove good information from actual attorneys and promote bogus "cop law" that is highly detrimental to the interests of the users.
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2017/10/suspect-asks-for...
The worst case outcome is that police officer testifying to a jury that you agreed to answer questions about a crime once you had immunity.
This is a terrible plan that ends terribly for you. Smart people think they'll be able to logic and reason themselves out of the crosshairs of the criminal justice system. But they're playing a game they don't know how to play and the odds are stacked for the house.
“Officer, was there anything strange about the defendants response to finding out his ex-roomate had been murdered?”
“Well he immediately asked for immunity to cover his actions in the crime”
Never talk to the police, refer them to your lawyer.
And given that cops can legally lie, that promise of immunity seems empty.
Either they go do the legwork or you avoid random liability for whatever you might have said.
When your lawyer asks for immunity it can’t be used against you in court. If you ask, it almost certainly will.
I won't trust myself to handle legal processes, and I certainly won't be able tell if the police had forged a document for me to sign.
Why? Because if you end up in front of a jury, that police officer is going to testify to that jury that you said "you'd tell them anything when they granted you immunity", a truthful statement, and the jury is going to fill in whatever gaps the prosecutor suggests they fill in.
If you are in police custody you ask for nothing from the police. You tell them that you are remaining silent until your lawyer arrives. And then you shut up.
Police can and do lie to people to get them to confess to stuff. "We'll go easy on you, we promise", or "this is off the record, you can tell us anything now" etc. So what stops them from saying something like "sure, you got immunity, now let us in".
The IRS would never call you in a situation where that would matter, and in fact they try very hard to make that public since fake IRS enforcement calls are a very common scam.
So the cop was either lying to you, or was caught in a scam and accidentally scared them off by showing they weren't going to immediately buckle under, without even realizing it was a scam.
Ask for a lawyer, not immunity. And take legal advice from your lawyer, not from cops who, as a class, have neither the knowledge nor the motivation to give good advice.
We didn't have anything to hide, but you never know what law you may've broken. You never know what they may say and how you will react. The system sets up an adversarial relationship.
It would be in the best interest of law enforcement to play by the same rules as regular people.