News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by lucasmullens on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:05PM (#25960321)
"The company reportedly said that Google’s policies explicitly prohibit reviews aiming to manipulate an app’s rating"

Literally the only reason someone rates something is to affect/manipulate the rating.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by jbay808 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:19PM (#25960493)
If I think an app deserves three stars, then I should give it a three star review, even if it currently has four stars.

If I say "well, this deserves three stars, so I'll give it a one-star review so as to pull the average closer to three" then I'm aiming to manipulate its rating, rather than rating it.

Note: I'm only guessing at Google's thought process here at the distinction between reviews and manipulation, and guessing at their detection algorithm; I'm not myself suggesting or implying that one-star reviewers are always engaging in manipulation. Of course you could honestly think an app deserves one star. The difference is unknowable to an outside observer. Only you can really know whether you're being honest, but that won't stop Google from assuming the worst.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by gnicholas on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:21PM (#25960502)
True, but it seems that most of the current reviewers think that it should have 1 star, so giving 1 star reviews isn't an example of this kind of manipulation.
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by jbay808 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:26PM (#25960564)
I agree that that's what happened here, but maybe Google didn't think so, or automatically assumes that the above is typically the scenario where one-star reviews are given.

Such reviews will naturally be at one end of the spectrum or the other - either one star or five stars, so as to maximize your voting power. So they might detect it in the case of reviews being bimodally distributed. I'd expect that two star reviews should always be treated as honest, so I'd recommend that as a review floor to prevent getting accused of manipulation and deleted.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by gnicholas on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:36PM (#25960691)
I think reviews are naturally bimodally distributed because people are most likely to take the time to review a business when it is either amazing or horrible.

I would speculate that this is the reason that Yelp created its Elite program — to incentivize people to write tons of reviews, including for places that were neither amazing nor horrible. This gives Yelp the crucial middle ground reviews that as you say are more likely to be accurate than just the highs and lows.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by skeeter2020 on Friday January 29, 2021 @02:02PM (#25960962)
This is why NetFlix switched to thumbs up/down, and the reviews are just as useless as before but more explicit in their useless-ness.

Funny that Steam does this too, but I find their reviews quite useful and accurate. Maybe because you rationalize your review and then give it an overall UP/DOWN, vs all these other approaches that ONLY give you the GO/NO-GO signaling...

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by jbay808 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:58PM (#25960922)
Yes, I agree. They are naturally bimodally distributed, but I'd expect Google is arrogant enough to think that they can tell the difference between an honest and manipulative review using such statistics anyway.

They obviously can't, and that's why people are outraged.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by PKop on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:32PM (#25960642)
What if it deserves 1 star? You'll then tell me it deserves 3 stars and erase my rating right?

Why is it a controversy that an app that doesn't let you buy stocks when it hurts insider hedge funds gets rated a derservingly minimal 1 star?

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by jbay808 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:44PM (#25960766)
I'm not Google, and I agree that obviously they made the wrong call here. I'm just showing that there is a distinction between a review and an attempt at manipluating the score, even if proving it requires insight into the heart of the reviewer. Google doesn't have that insight, but they are pretending they can guess.

As I suggested in a sibling post, a two-star review should be immune to this accusation, so if I were you I'd use a strategy of "two stars is the new one star".

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by bogwog on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:53PM (#25960857)
It's not like people actually take the time to determine exactly how many stars is considered fair. I believe that if this rating system were replaced with a binary vote, like thumbs up/thumbs down, Google would've still removed the thousands of votes.

I understand the argument for removal, since Robinhood likely had no choice but to stop the trading. Ratings are meant to inform consumer choice, so a brigade of downvotes due to some recent controversy/memery is more likely to hurt consumer choice since it reduces the amount of information available. It means that one detail is drowning out all of the others, and regardless of whether a new customer would care about that detail, the fact is that it's the only one they'll be able to base their decision on while those votes stay up.

But on the other hand, app ratings are one of the very few powers consumers have to affect change in companies they do business with. Brigading the rating system (which has the effect of turning away new customers) is no different than bad word-of-mouth, where angry customers go out of their way to prevent others from doing business with the company that screwed them over. Even if a disgruntled customer goes a bit too far with hyperbole, that's their right. And it's a good thing that those things are possible, because it forces companies to always stay on their toes and think twice before doing something to hurt consumers.

It's the question of whether a consumer should have to "suck it up" when a company screws them over, or whether a company, whose full-time job it is to provide a particular service, should be held to a higher standard and be hurt when they provide bad service.

IMO, Google really should have not gotten involved here. This is an issue between Robinhood and its customers, whether or not you think what Robinhood did was fair. Google, a company being investigated for anti-competitive practices, just took another anti-consumer action.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by newfeatureok on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:25PM (#25960543)
Who makes that distinction?
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by skeeter2020 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:59PM (#25960929)
My immediate response too. Even more ridiculous than "prevent the manipulation of a stock", you know the entire point of economics and markets...
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by kerng on Friday January 29, 2021 @02:22PM (#25961214)
Is Google not following the news and sees what's going on? These seem legit reviews of upset customers, not some random prank.
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by xiphias2 on Friday January 29, 2021 @03:26PM (#25961969)
The news doesn't have experts in securities tradings law, and it's still not clear what happened.

What's going on right now is unprecedented, so it has to go through a complex review process. Just following the news is witch hunting.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by 3327 on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:19PM (#25960482)
Google is trash the system is rigged. Never thought i would join the camp but the days events have proven all the “its rigged” sayers right.

They were right. GME , BB, NOK to the moon.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:07PM (#25960341)
> Literally the only reason someone

Well, no. Maybe we're splitting hairs but when I rate something its to describe my experience, not to affect its overall rating. At no point do I think my one rating would have a meaningful impact on its overall score unless it has very few ratings to begin with.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by osrec on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:14PM (#25960422)
I think it depends on whether your experience was positive or negative. If positive, I think your description applies. If negative, I think people really do want to impact the rating negatively.
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:17PM (#25960464)
So if you were to leave a 1 star review on the facebook app on the google play store, you actually think you're impacting their overall score in a meaningful way?
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by t-writescode on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:20PM (#25960500)
How is your question different from asking "when you vote for a particular candidate, you actually think you're impacting the overall vote in a particular direction?"

Validated app purchase, app-store rating is a democracy.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:24PM (#25960536)
> "when you vote for a particular candidate, you actually think you're impacting the overall vote in a particular direction?"

I absolutely don't.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by cryptoz on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:34PM (#25960672)
What is voting then? Nobody's vote matters? Is democracy a sham to you?

The math is simple though. Your vote is 1 added to a total. So is everyone's. The totals don't go above 0 tied with 0 based on your description. But clearly our votes don't all end in a 0-0 tie.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:45PM (#25960780)
I can guarantee you that my vote in the 2020 presidential election had absolutely zero impact on who my state electors voted for, let alone impacting the race at a national level.

I would have to be a complete moron to think my vote had any impact on choosing the winner.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by osrec on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:32PM (#25960651)
I don't know if I will have a meaningful impact or not, but my intention is certainly to impact the rating.

Otherwise, why rate at all?

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @02:44PM (#25961485)
> Otherwise, why rate at all?

to describe my experience.

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by osrec on Friday January 29, 2021 @03:29PM (#25962015)
To influence others? To express an opinion?

Or just for fun?

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:58PM (#25963931)
Probably the same reason I post comments on hackernews. I'm definitely not expecting too influence or change an outcome
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by osrec on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:32PM (#25964263)
But you're certainly persistent in trying to get others to agree/see to your viewpoint on here.

Perhaps you want to influence opinion more than you think?

Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by RobLach on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:20PM (#25960499)
If you're joined by a billion other people...
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by wnevets on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:23PM (#25960524)
most people rating apps aren't expecting to be joined by a billion other people. So there MUST be another reason why people are leaving ratings. AKA the complete opposite of what the original commenter is claiming.
Re:Google reportedly scraps thousands of negative Robinhood ... by jessriedel on Friday January 29, 2021 @01:16PM (#25960443)
When I find a good product and review it, it's because I want to benefit the developer and help other people find it. I am trying to affect the overall rating.