Re:Losing faith in UX
by hulitu on Friday January 29, 2021 @02:07AM
(#25954869)
Almost all new legitimate uses of a GUI those days look like a workaround. Why is Edge and Chrome and Word and... stealing my windows titlebar ?
Why can i not access the favorites menu with one click as it used to be ? Why do i need a big label which uses 30 % of the screen and does nothing ? Why everything looks like a label ?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
What's interesting to me, is that those that shape the platform guidelines (Google/Android, MS/Win, don't have apple so can't say) often are the worst offenders to completely disregard them.
Just as an example, I've turned off auto updates on my phone and inspect each app update individually, but the google apps often just say "bug fixes and performance improvements".
When that's the case, such general guidelines become useless. "If they don't follow them, then why should we?"
Apple's HIGs are here: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...
Re:Losing faith in UX
by whywhywhywhy on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:59AM
(#25956091)
They don't really mean anything on desktop anymore seen as only a small minority of MacOS apps are built using those frameworks. Everything else is either Electron or custom cross platform UI frameworks like Adobe Suite, Alberton, Cinema4D etc.
The HIG is just as applicable if you use Electron, even it might take more work to follow the guidelines if you don't use the system-provided widgets.
That some choose to ignore the HIG and use the same GUI on multiple platforms is a problem, but it's not a problem that any guidelines can solve.