News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ng12 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:56PM (#25937120)
> On both Discord and Reddit, wallstreetbets users frequently refer to themselves collectively as “retards” and “autists,” and have been known to deploy the kinds of racial slurs and deliberately offensive language that have become commonplace in 4chan-style posting forums.

I read WSB daily for years and cannot recall a single usage of a racial slur. They definitely referred to themselves as autists/retards in a self-deprecating manner but that's hardly the same thing.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by koheripbal on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:09PM (#25937227)
This is one of the dangers of using "hate speech" as an nebulous term. You can then turn it around and use it as an excuse to ban whatever you want.

I could easily read through any of the front page posts on Reddit, and find what I consider to be hate speech, and if I were in a position of power, I could just use that as a justification to ban the entire domain.

Moreover, it easily allows adversaries the ability to plant hate speech in forums they dislike, and then pressure the authorities to ban it.

At the end of the day, I am an adult, and I reject the notion that sites need to protect me from speech.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by cambalache on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:22PM (#25937305)
"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him."

Cardinal Richelieu (Alledgelly)

A lesson this generation will have to learn again.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by bpcpdx on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:20AM (#25940577)
"Give me 280 characters typed by the hand of an honest man, I will find something in them to cancel him."

Anon paraphrasing Cardinal Richelieu (Alledgelly)

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by cycloptic on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:32AM (#25938899)
I'm confused, what is the lesson here? That quote seems to get thrown around so often that it can be applied to anytime that anyone gets criticized for anything. The moderator's statement appears to be asking for more help with moderation, not advocating for less moderation or advocating for more hateful behavior to be allowed.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by TeMPOraL on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:38AM (#25939233)
> That quote seems to get thrown around so often that it can be applied to anytime that anyone gets criticized for anything.

That's the point. It serves to show the perils of judging people by what they say, particularly if single offence against some perceived norms becomes a standard for punishment.

And there's another quote from that same period: "like Saturn, the Revolution devours its children" (Jacques Mallet du Pan).

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by Guthur on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:46AM (#25940698)
The point should be deeper than that, the character, methods and legacy of the Cardinal Richelieu are the important aspects.

The man cement centralised power within France by through a multitude of authoritarian methods.

And so in my opinion it's the motives behind such a statement that are important.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by cycloptic on Thursday January 28, 2021 @09:48AM (#25942488)
I have to say, that still doesn't mean much to me here. In a real court system, we judge people by their actions and behaviors, sometimes their speech can play into that. I assume that's what the author was referring to. (Apparently the origin of this quote is not clear, but it does seem to come from that same time period) This can't be compared to social media, the only way to judge anyone in the context of a social media platform is by what they say. That's all there is on these platforms, if you take that away, there's nothing left. You are judging someone every time you make a decision whether to like/follow/reply/retweet or not. If your view is that all that doesn't matter and the speech is meaningless, then it follows that any perceived punishments are also meaningless.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by bsder on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:34AM (#25940293)
There are two lessons:

1) Language is imprecise. We do not communicate with the idea that our words have a unique, specific meaning. This means that you can do things like quote my statements out of context in order to change their intent.

2) People are not perfect. You can almost always find some "fault" in even the best people. People should not be punished for a "fault" unless it does measurable harm to someone else.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by marcus_holmes on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:47AM (#25940381)
Also that meaning is created by the listener, not defined by the speaker. Anything you say can be misinterpreted, either genuinely or maliciously. The message communicated is whatever the listener hears, with all their history, biases and intentions.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by cycloptic on Thursday January 28, 2021 @09:58AM (#25942698)
Those don't seem to matter here, the business apparently is saying that the language was precise and they were experiencing measurable harm from it.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by dfxm12 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#25943577)
The lesson in that quote is that it doesn't matter what you write, if someone with the right authority wants you hanged, or wants to shut down your discord, it'll happen regardless of due process.

This is different from what the parent poster is implying. It's about the dangers of authoritarianism. No plants or justification are necessary.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by Rastonbury on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:39AM (#25938932)
Ah yes we should learn to self-censor to save the powers that be the trouble!
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by theinverseidea on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:36PM (#25937417)
Its terribly sad, and equally confusing has to how we got here.

At least they'll have a firm understanding of just how sexist light speed is.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by prawn on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:05PM (#25938015)
I don't think they're protecting you from speech, but protecting themselves from it. A murky reputation harms their ad revenue or corporate opportunities, I imagine.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by _ifvv on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:33AM (#25938588)
> They definitely referred to themselves as autists/retards in a self-deprecating manner but that's hardly the same thing.

I fail to see how 'autist' is any less of a slur than e.g. 'trap' or 'gay', when used in the right (wrong) context.

It's not a racial slur, but it's quite certainly a slur.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by blackearl on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:35AM (#25938910)
It makes no sense to pick a specific word and draw an arbitrary line. You can be far more offensive without any "slurs" by asking if one's mother was frequently drunk while pregnant.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by _ifvv on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:54AM (#25939001)
Yes, and I see no problems with being offensive in a joking or ironic manner (as seems to be the case on WSB). However, when you decide to use a slur to do so, you are deciding to insult an entire subgroup of the population as collateral damage.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ACow_Adonis on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:00AM (#25939376)
isn't the above poster's example explicitly insulting to everyone who's mother was drunk repeatedly/for long periods of time while pregnant? and everyone with foetal alcohol syndrome?
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by capableweb on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:57AM (#25939739)
No? The insult is to the person you say "was your mother frequently drunk while pregnant with you", not everyone else who might fit that particular profile.

If what you're saying would be true, then calling someone an idiot would be an insult to all the idiots out there. They are clearly not the target of the insult, the person you say it to is the insulted.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by TeMPOraL on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:08AM (#25940141)
That's the point, though. WSB folks aren't insulting whole classes of people either, they're mostly insulting each other, in a playful way.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by Guthur on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:53AM (#25940744)
And more importantly why have we ever allowed it to get so far.

"oh, he hurt my feelings, stop him"

It's fucking moronic for us to have demonised speech like this, we should have held on to the old "sticks and stones" because frankly this Orwellian alternative is bonkers.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday January 28, 2021 @07:45AM (#25941093)
>"oh, he hurt my feelings, stop him"

We're long past the point where feelings need to actually be hurt to take action.

Half the time it's "oh, he might hurt someone else's feelings, stop him"

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ACow_Adonis on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:47AM (#25940707)
it seems pretty clear to me the insult of "idiot" can only be a successful insult if it is inherently offensive to be in the state of idiocy (well, I mean, they're idiots so maybe they don't know they're being insulted, but the point stands).

Or in short, of course it's an insult to the idiots out there. That's literally what makes idiot an insult.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ALittleLight on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:58AM (#25938732)
I'm not sure what your point is. There are appropriate and inappropriate ways to use words. Making fun of the neuro-atypicals is inappropriate, joking with likeminded folks in a community built around such is likely appropriate. You've just that word you are complaining about, should you be banned?
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by slg on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:43AM (#25938952)
> joking with likeminded folks in a community built around such is likely appropriate.

Would you say it is okay for white people to use the n word if there are no Black people around?

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ALittleLight on Thursday January 28, 2021 @04:00AM (#25939752)
I think it depends. Certainly it could be used in a way that conveys racist positions and it could be used in a way that doesn't. Is someone singing along to a rap song a racist? Kids being edgy?

I am not saying though that I think use of the term is okay, only that I don't think it should be prohibited either by law or by the pressure of big companies punishing people who say what is forbidden for them to say. I'm perfectly happy with people who make the judgement that they may never say certain words. I'm not happy with people telling others what they can or cannot say.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by atypicaluser on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:47AM (#25941647)
Yes. And even with them around. All depends on the context and the willingness to get one's nose bopped.

I would, for example, encourage an actor to use overly offensive expletives, even repeating them ad nauseam in the presence of their fellow actors so they feel more comfortable using such words in a production dealing with racial strife, historical storytelling or what have you.

No word is so beyond the pale it must be Voldemorted.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by djbebs on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:33AM (#25941529)
Whats wrong with using that word even if black people are around?

If listening to a word causes you so much trouble, thats your problem as the listener, and its up to you to deal with it.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by _ifvv on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:48AM (#25938972)
> You've just that word you are complaining about, should you be banned?

The commenting guidelines state: Be kind. Don't be snarky. [...] Don't sneer. Regardless, I will indulge your curiosity.

1) There are certainly other terms in use on WSB that one could take offense to. I personally find this one to be particularly problematic. (The fact that I am myself autistic probably plays a big role in this ;)) 2) I have posted many comments here on HN, and as far as I know this one and the one you replied to are the only ones I've posted on the topic of slurs. I fail to see why I should be banned over this discussion.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ALittleLight on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:56AM (#25939735)
I don't mean that comment to be snarky or sneering and I apologize if it came off as unkind. What I mean to convey with that comment is that clearly you believe there are acceptable uses of the word. In other words, you don't think that every use of the word should be prohibited.

Once we've reached that point it seems like a negotiation. Why would it be wrong to say sometimes and not wrong other times? My intuition here is that this is tied to whether the word is used with intent to offend or harass someone. In your case, you weren't using the word that way, and I would argue that the same applies largely to uses of the term on wallstreetbets.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by vbsteven on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:46AM (#25938963)
Joking among friends using slurs is not appropriate in my eyes. Doesn’t matter if the slur is based on neurodiversity, race, age, gender or something else.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by Kranar on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:04AM (#25939044)
People of various backgrounds often refer to themselves or close friends of theirs by what would otherwise be offensive slurs. That goes for black people, LGBT people, women, Asians, Jews, heck even white people often refer to themselves or another white person they are close with using a slur. There is actually evidence that people who refer to one another using slurs that would otherwise be offensive do so to strengthen social bonds with each other and there's some interesting game theory for why this is the case.

It's also quite common among comedians and other entertainers to make fun of their own ethnicity using slurs or use slurs in various performances.

You personally may not find it appropriate and that's a subjective point of view that you are entitled to have, but consider whether you have a good rational justification for it or whether you are exercising too much caution to the point that you are getting offended on behalf of others even when those others are not themselves offended.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by kelnos on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:58AM (#25939364)
I don't think people are talking about using slurs to describe themselves, but slurs to describe others.

The WSB folks are in a weird position where they're using slurs to describe themselves that don't actually apply to them (well, not as a whole; I imagine there are some autistic WSB members, just like there are in most populations). I'm bewildered as to why they think that's funny (or whatever justification they have for it), but it does strike me as potentially offensive.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ALittleLight on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:53AM (#25939711)
Why does it matter what you find offensive though? What you're saying sounds like an excellent reason for you personally not to visit wallstreetbets, it doesn't sound like any kind of reason at all for the community to be curtailed, censored, or banned.

As an example, I grew up in a very religious home. My family would find things like cursing, taking the Lord's name in vain, or advocating for atheism to be very offensive. And yet, I hope it is very easy for you to understand that it would be wrong to take what my religious family finds offensive and apply those ethical rules to other people. Jehovah's Witnesses think birthdays and holidays are offensive, Muslims think graven images are offensive, etc etc. All sorts of people believe all sorts of things. Every group of people is not obliged to not be offensive to every other group of people.

You may be inclined to say that people can choose not to be religious but have no say over things like mental type or race. I don't think that's true because the majority of religious people are in the same religion as their parents, implying there isn't much free choice involved. Even if that were true, why is something you believe less respected than something that you are?

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by DiggyJohnson on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:00AM (#25939024)
I just cannot understand this take, genuinely.

How can you know what is a slur and what is not when judging the way others communicate in their relationships? What if it’s a nickname from childhood? What if...anything really?

How on earth would you take action on this point, besides teaching our children to be kind, thoughtful, and curious.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by joubert on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:16AM (#25939108)
> How can you know what is a slur and what is not when judging the way others communicate in their relationships? What if it’s a nickname from childhood?

How can you know what is an insult and what is not when judging the way others communicate in their relationships? What if it’s a nickname from childhood?

How can you know what is a threat and what is not when judging the way others communicate in their relationships? What if it’s a nickname from childhood?

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by heyoni on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:05AM (#25939051)
Why? You mentioned that you don’t ever think it’s ok but never mentioned why.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by acct776 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:34AM (#25939208)
That's your opinion.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by globular-toast on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:45AM (#25941634)
It's not a slur. It's just part of their humour. Are we into telling people what they can and can't say within their own private groups now?
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by RubberbandSoul on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:16AM (#25940183)
Spillover from medical terms is very common. You sometimes hear someone being called a "psycho" or a "sociopath" but you don't make the assumption that the accuser is a trained psychiatrist.

"Idiot" used to be a medical condition, someone suffering from idiocy.

"Retard"; someone whose mental development had been retarded and remained in a childhood state into adulthood.

These words are not supposed to be taken literally (when used colloquially) but to suggest that the person in question displays signs of the medical condition.

I guess we could try to label this as misuse of the terms and try to end the practice, but where would that lead us? "Bob is double plus ungood at thinking"?

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by marcus_holmes on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:51AM (#25940407)
It's known as the "Euphemism Treadmill" [0]. I remember "spastic" being a playground insult having been a medical term a couple decades previously.

[0] http://englishcowpath.blogspot.com/2011/06/euphemism-treadmi...

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by grumple on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:17AM (#25941344)
You make some good points, I think. The extrapolation I’d make is that even that last statement is offensive. As some say, “if you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all”. There’s a culture of decency, and it is opposed to a culture of liberty. Which isn’t to say we shouldn’t have decency, but that everything should be kept in balance. We shouldn’t embrace Gilead’s “freedom from”.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by smichel17 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @10:12AM (#25942973)
I'm not quite sure how these are inherently in conflict. It seems like a community might allow the use of slurs as insults while also discouraging insults in general. In different words, "Please be nice to each other. We don't ban for the use of any particular words, but we do ban for disparaging others."

I could easily imagine a policy like this in, say, a linguistics forum, where it's totally allowed to discuss the usage of slurs, as long as they're not directed at someone.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ng12 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @09:57AM (#25942672)
I am entirely comfortable with the fact that some people on the internet choose to use words I don't like.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by sam_dal on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:12AM (#25939442)
Discord has to worry more about it's financial sources than community. I suppose "power that be" applied little pressure to boot out the community.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by BillinghamJ on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:31AM (#25940272)
Unfortunately they are consistently homophobic though - particularly on the Discord :\
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by melomal on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:05AM (#25939050)
Yup, I've been on WSB for some serious time now and sure they call each other autists/retards to no end but nothing racial. F##K cancel culture.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by Infinitesimus on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:42PM (#25937478)
Reddit was clean but some channels in discord had ... questionable users. Most channels were heavily moderated and kept clean though.
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by xg15 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:24AM (#25940599)
> They definitely referred to themselves as autists/retards in a self-deprecating manner but that's hardly the same thing.

A self-deprecating slur can still be a slur.

Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by bombcar on Thursday January 28, 2021 @07:28AM (#25940990)
Options expiring this week are still referred to as FDs - even though the subreddit banned the first word (D is delight).
Re:Where do we go from here and who is going to step up to h... by ceilingcorner on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:33AM (#25941520)
Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray’s case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the “wet streets cause rain” stories. Paper’s full of them.

In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.” – Michael Crichton (1942-2008)

Every time you read an article saying “X community is filled with Y horrible thing,” remember this.