News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by RivieraKid on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:28AM (#25929342)
It's surprising that markets are still so obviously irrational.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by mywittyname on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:34AM (#25929424)
This is pretty rational behavior.

The short sellers are paying (a lot of) interest on their positions and they need those shares. The higher the price goes, the higher the interest rates get.

People long $GME can maintain their positions indefinitely while the short sellers bleed.

This situation could have been prevented if the short sellers acquired enough calls to cover their position in the event of a price spike. One would think that a rich-ass hedge fund manager would do something basic like that.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by tootie on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:37AM (#25929477)
Rational from the POV of investors looking to extract some short-term returns. Completely irrational in that nobody seems to give a shit about Gamestop and they're actual performance as a business.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by thatswrong0 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:42AM (#25929549)
A stock price is never just about the fundamentals of the company. It's not rational to think of stock prices only from that limited perspective. You _must_ consider the supply and demand for the stock and the people that are currently trading it. They are a part of the equation.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by josephorjoe on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:59AM (#25929828)
Exactly. Stock owners are free to not sell their stock and this cannot be ignored.

I have a guitar that I could sell on the open market for ~$300.

But I don't want to sell it.

If someone offered me $300 for it, I'd say no. If they offered $400, I'd still say no. I'd say no at $900.

Why? Because I don't want to sell it and I don't have to.

There is some price that will change my mind, of course, but it has nothing to do with the actual value of the guitar.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Miner49er on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:02AM (#25929862)
An argument could actually be made that Gamestop should be worth about $250 a share, assuming they capitalize on this short squeeze by issuing new shares and turn things around/pivot well.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by kristjansson on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:29PM (#25938185)
One buys a stock on the premise that someone else will pay more for it in the future.

Most of the time the future is years down the road, because you made a good bet on what business would be profitable. Sometimes the future is the following Tuesday because someone got out over their skis and _needs_ your stock now.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Wheaties466 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:43AM (#25930355)
TBH what looks like what is happening right now is more of a game of chicken between the short sellers. We'll find out friday when some options contracts expire. Seems like some shorts are just seeing if they can wait it out.

But there is no one "bleeding" as they won't realize the losses until they sell the contract or it expires.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by TheAdamAndChe on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:33AM (#25929415)
This is a short squeeze. My understanding is that hedge funds shorted the company massively, covering something like 130% the price of the company. These companies are contractually obligated to buy the stock at whatever price it's at in the future, giving people a good reason to pile into the stock for guaranteed gains. This is causing a frenzy.

Someone correct me if I'm wrong, I only learned about it yesterday.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Edmond on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:57AM (#25929793)
I am not sure how guaranteed the gains are...basically there is a common enemy right now in the form of short sellers. Once they're decimated (ie forced to buy shares at higher prices than they anticipated), I suspect a good deal of novice traders are going to still be holding shares at elevated prices. At that point they're basically holding shares worth very little compared to what they likely paid for them.

The same hoard trading phenomenon seems to be happening with Blackberry. A number of insiders have already dumped shares, meaning anyone buying those shares isn't buying shares from a short seller, they're buying from people who recognize the price is outrageous compared to business fundamentals.

Bottom line, short sellers are definitely going to suffer, but so are a lot of robbinhood kiddies.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:03AM (#25929875)
As I understood it, BlackBerry is a different case from GameStop—albeit some redditors are trying to make it do the same thing because it's cheaper. I've been holding that one for years for a reason.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Edmond on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:09AM (#25929965)
If you're long Blackberry, depending on how much you paid for the shares you might come out on top in the years ahead.

I happen to be cautiously optimistic about the company, but that is over a longer time-frame. The stock has more than doubled in a couple of weeks and seems to open consistently higher over the past few days. I don't think that is related to any real immediate business prospects. The Facebook settlement, Amazon deal and Huawei patent sales are all good news but hardly warranting the current frenzy.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:11AM (#25929990)
No doubt. I definitely have faith that the company itself is smarter than the current euphoria so I guess I just hope it does nothing to tarnish them because they've made major strides and frankly I'd just like to see a Canadian tech company do some good. Thankfully, yes, I got in cheap.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by kangnkodos on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:31PM (#25935026)
Compounding this is Robinhood's execution. Back in March 2020, the whole market plunged, and some Robinhood traders were unable to complete their trades in a timely manner.

Will Robinhood's systems and procedures work flawlessly on Friday? My guess is no. We'll find out.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by chrisseaton on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:56AM (#25929787)
> These companies are contractually obligated to buy the stock at whatever price it's at in the future

Normally you set a limit when you short. You don’t agree to pay an unlimited amount of money.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by kangnkodos on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:37PM (#25934333)
If an individual shorts stock at an investment bank, there is a limit to the amount of money the individual can lose.

The investment bank has some type of collateral, usually the rest of your portfolio. When your net worth hits a certain threshold, perhaps $0 net worth of your portfolio, the bet is over. You lost all your money, and you don't end up in debt. In practice, the investment bank will cut you off before you reach this point.

But if you are an investment bank, there is no one controlling you on a daily basis, so you can dip into the negative in theory.

The problems with doing this are:

- Regulators. Once the regulator finds out you're negative, they will shut down your investment bank. Hopefully, they do this before you hit 0, but they may not get it exactly right.

- Counterparties. Other investment banks will refuse to do business with you when they know you are negative, or close to it. Once this happens, it's game over.

So in both cases, individual or investment bank, there is a practical limit on how much you can lose from one short bet. That limit is equal to your net worth.

You could lose any amount of money up to that on one short. It's risky.

There are also ways to limit your losses. You can purchase other contracts to limit your losses. This is kind of like insurance. In general, you are not required to buy this. Some people and institutions do not do this because of the expense. Most institutions structure each deal so there is no way one deal will risk the entire business. Smart people also take steps to make sure one trade does not wipe them out.

But sometimes mistakes happen.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by sidr on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:18AM (#25930073)
This runs completely counter to my understanding of shorting and I just checked on my brokerage - there is no limit. The unbounded losses bit is the whole point of put options instead of shorts.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by chrisseaton on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:31AM (#25930237)
> Many short sellers place a stop order with their stockbroker after selling a stock short—an order to the brokerage to cover the position if the price of the stock should rise to a certain level. This is to limit the loss and avoid the problem of unlimited liability described above. In some cases, if the stock's price skyrockets, the stockbroker may decide to cover the short seller's position immediately and without his consent to guarantee that the short seller can make good on his debt of shares.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Short_(finance)#Risks

Otherwise you'd make yourself liable for a literally unlimited sum of money. Any short could completely bankrupt your entire personal finances or your entire institution in that case.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by phoe-krk on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:31AM (#25929390)
Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent -- Keynes.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by RivieraKid on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:34AM (#25929433)
Yeah, I know... But it's annoying to see money getting transfered from people who are good at valuation to people who're clueless.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by _jal on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:37AM (#25929472)
And here I've been told that the market price is the price, because that's the price, and don't get emotional about the market.

I guess that only applies when the 'right' people are involved?

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by johnhartigun on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:43AM (#25929569)
See, this is what I mean by clueless. Price and valuation are completely different concepts. An asset that will never generate any cash has a valuation of zero, but its market price could be anything.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by _jal on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:48AM (#25929649)
See, this is what I mean by how econ 101 reasoning makes people weirdly arrogant and impossible to talk to.

Parent is so quick to try to score a point arguing definitions that they entirely missed the point.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by johnhartigun on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:53AM (#25929743)
I'd be happy to discuss substance but your comment brings up no actual points, only ad hominem.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by tylerjaywood on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:52AM (#25929731)
I press f on the worlds smallest keyboard to pay respect to the billionaires betting they could grind the company out of existence through aggressive shorting who lost money on this.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by thatswrong0 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:36AM (#25929460)
> people who are good at valuation

I wouldn't call people who short 140% of available shares good at anything

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by stephenhuey on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:43AM (#25929561)
Greedy gamblers who assume everyone else is incapable of calling their bluff?
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Bakary on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:00AM (#25929844)
The real conclusion would be to realize that the people "good at valuation" are glorified gamblers and not on another plane of existence from the rest.

In fact, it's tautological to state that if they got burned, then they are not that good. Or perhaps the entire thing is pareidolic nonsense.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by RivieraKid on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @03:33PM (#25933558)
Disagree. The short-sellers are correct about GameStop's valuation. In a liquid and competitive market they would profit and help the price move into the direction of correct valuation.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by zeusk on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:18PM (#25936217)
Well, the market thought otherwise and market is always right.

They just forgot that efficient market hypothesis is just that, a hypothesis. Real world markets behave differently thanks to finite resources and secondary markets (essentially leveraged derivatives caused 2008 crash and I believe they'll cause another before regulators wake up from their sleep).

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Bakary on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:38PM (#25936462)
Isn't that essentially magical thinking? The market is what it is, and their strategy failed. It doesn't really make sense to blame the market when the scheme fails and presumably celebrate the individual or group's purported brilliance when the scheme works. What actually happens is the ultimate arbiter of who profits and who doesn't, not the hypothetical fairer environment that "should" have existed to reward certain strategies.

It's similar to blaming the roulette wheel when the gambler fails and praising the gambler when they succeed.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by josephorjoe on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:44AM (#25929582)
not to pile on here, but what is happening is money is getting transferred from one gambler to another
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by phoe-krk on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:38AM (#25929497)
Right now, money isn't getting transferred from people who are good at valuation to people who're clueless. I'd say it's quite the opposite.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by johnhartigun on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:45AM (#25929590)
Well any reasonable GameStop valuation is at least an order of magnitude below current market price.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by phoe-krk on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:07AM (#25929944)
The whole affair isn't, and wasn't, about GameStop's valuation, or even about Gamestop as a company whatsoever. It's about stock market mechanics and the ability to leverage them to make a profit.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by fileeditview on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:01AM (#25929856)
The value currently is not in GameStop itself but in the need for the short sellers to buy back the shares. So there is value in buying & holding. How much is still open..

The situation is pretty bonkers but I hope in the end that the hedge funds have learned a lesson.

Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by Symmetry on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:40AM (#25929516)
There is a weird asymmetry between moving a stocks value up and moving it down. Shorting is weird and sort of dangerous as we're seeing here and doesn't move the price down very directly. By contrast, a group of people can move a price up pretty easily.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by brightball on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:37AM (#25929482)
I think it was Buffet who said that the stock market is a voting system.
Re:GameStop Opened at $300+ Today by mcv on Thursday January 28, 2021 @07:17PM (#25951596)
And it just got a lot more democratic.