News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by reedf1 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:57AM (#25926683)
As an amateur photographer the reporting at the beginning of the pandemic was journalistic poison. Anyone even vaguely interested in photography knows about lens compression. There wasn't a single photo of a beach or a high-street I could find that wasn't intentionally composed to compress the crowds.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by phreeza on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:14AM (#25926822)
On the contrary, I explicitly remember this effect making the rounds in many outlets in April:

https://nyheder.tv2.dk/samfund/2020-04-26-hvor-taet-er-folk-...

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by noneeeed on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:43AM (#25929571)
I'm not sure this was contrary to what the parent comment says. Back in April the newspapers and other media were regularly using photographs that made crowds and beaches look much more densly packed than they were.

This was being pointed out by articles like the one you linked to, but that doesn't negate original offense. Far fewer people were reading articles like this than were seing toxic scare-mongering photos on the front pages of major national newspapers.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by thinkingemote on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:18AM (#25926847)
It depends where you are I imagine. Some countries have cultures where any attempts to lessen the messaging in coronavirus news is on par with being morally wrong (or even dangerous). Other cultures are more critical or resistant. HN has a very diverse mix of users from a range of places.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by XorNot on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:13AM (#25927277)
Perspective distortion misuse was neither of these though. It was simply dishonest journalism which distorted the messaging everywhere: are people following lockdowns and distancing or not? How does this relate to case numbers? Who could know because the pictures being put out there meant nothing.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by gabriel34 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:15AM (#25927829)
This may, in fact, backfire in a couple of ways:

1. It may reduce societal pressure to isolate by making it seem only a minority of people are actually doing it (much like the broken windows theory)

2. It fuels distrust in media outlets. Deservingly so, even if machiavellianly this choice seems to serve the greater good.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by ghaff on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:08AM (#25928402)
"Misuse" is something of a judgment call though. Pretty much any photo makes choices of perspective, framing, etc. There are certainly cases of clear distortion but, especially in the context of distancing, arbitrary photos--even with "'normal"-ish focal lengths can tell very different stories depending upon where the camera is pointed.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by t-writescode on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:46PM (#25936530)
If you're standing 100 feet away to use a movie-magic trick to make two objects seem next to each other when they're very much not, you're (edit: probably) being dishonest.

edit: when that standing next to each other is attempting to introduce a narrative that people are doing something contrary to what they're actually doing

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by thinkingemote on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:17AM (#25927296)
Yes we agree with each other.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by ornornor on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:04AM (#25927190)
I’m not particularly into photography so I would probably have never heard of that effect if it were not for HN. That’s why I keep coming back here, I always find something interesting!
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by mcguire on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:20PM (#25934101)
A 300mm telephoto lens gives a narrower field of view than the standard eyeball, making objects in the field of view seem packed closer together. A 24mm wide-angle lens gives a wider field of view, making objects in the field of view seem farther apart. ("Objects in mirror are closer than they appear"? Yeah, same thing.) Both can be used for artistic effects as well as being dishonest. (I really like a 150-200mm lens for portraits; for one thing not having the camera and photographer nearby makes people look more natural.) A good match for the eye is a 50mm "standard" lens. (All lens sizes are for 35mm cameras; I don't remember what the correction factor is for my DSLR's CCD.)
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by girvo on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:37PM (#25935102)
1.5x if it’s an APS-C sensor, 2x if it’s a micro 4/3rds, and 1x if it’s full frame (this is most likely if you’re shooting Nikon or Canon, Fujifilm mirror-less are APS-C, Panasonic et al are m4/3)
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by pottertheotter on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:14PM (#25936800)
How is it that people's heads look the same size when they can be so far apart? I guess I need to learn more about all this.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by Pinus on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:30AM (#25938573)
The relative sizes depend on the relative distance from the camera. Say you have two persons, one standing one meter in front of the other, and the photographer standing one meter in front of the frontmost person, shooting with a wide-angle lens so that the nearest person fills the frame. The far person is then twice as far away as the near person (2m vs. 1m), and will appear half the size of the near person (assuming they're the same size in reality!). The photographer then moves 50 meters away, and shoots with a (really!) long telephoto lens, so that the nearest person still fills the frame. The near person is now 50 meters away and the far person is 51 meters away, and will appear 50/51 of the near persons's size.

(This would still happen if the photographer kept the wide-angle lens, but then a lot more of the surroundings would have been included in the frame, making it obvious that the persons were far away. Whether tele/wide-angle "affects perspective" is a favourite topic of endless debate on photo-related Internet forums. The answer hinges on which parameters you maintain constant, and which ones you allow to vary.)

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by pottertheotter on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:47AM (#25970558)
What a great explanation. Thank you so much!
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by mcguire on Thursday January 28, 2021 @10:33AM (#25943388)
Thank you! That is a great answer.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by FalconSensei on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @01:35PM (#25931977)
This article has way better examples than OP. Thanks for sharing!
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by handedness on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:43PM (#25934399)
The poisonous journalistic atmosphere which the GP referenced was precisely the impetus behind that much-needed exercise.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by trhway on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:52PM (#25934512)
Damaging the trust in media and government is a classic "penny smart, pound foolish", and the next time the boy cries wolf things may go differently.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by MichaelZuo on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:28PM (#25934998)
The media industry seems to be trapped in an enormous sub optimal Nash equilibrium.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by throwaway0a5e on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:10AM (#25941288)
Quarterly earnings are built on eyeball-hours so everyone is optimizing for short term maximization of eyeball hours.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by re on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:10AM (#25927252)
> journalistic poison ... intentionally composed to compress the crowds

The article addresses and explores this viewpoint and attempts to add nuance.

> If you search for "compression effect corona" in Japanese on the internet, you'll discover a flood of criticism of newspaper and television images related to the pandemic, including allegations of "creating crowding," "lies," and "faked shots." [...]

> The photos were lambasted as "exaggerating" the crowding, "manipulative," and "stoking public anxiety." However, there is no proof that the photographer was deliberately seeking to create a distorted impression of the scene.

> Shooting crowds with a telephoto lens is standard procedure among photojournalists. I had never questioned the practice, because I thought it was intended to express crowdedness. And as far as I am aware, there had never been criticism of the technique before the pandemic. [...]

> I don't think us news photographers can keep using techniques we'd always taken for granted without talking about why we use them. We are in a time when we must try to shoot our subjects from multiple angles, and explain the effects lens compression and exaggerated perspective can have.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by goblin89 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @01:24PM (#25931809)
Using telephoto lenses and angles that preclude the audience from understanding distances between people in a crowd without knowing the specifications of photography equipment is absolutely fine for artistic effect, but in documentary shots IMO it treads the line next to bad (regardless of the times) journalism, especially if another composition that allows the viewer to approximate crowd density objectively is possible.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by goblin89 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:28AM (#25977135)
To clarify, the blame does not lie entirely with the photojournalist. They may choose to get a shot using a telephoto lens to capture, say, which face expressions dominate the crowd (which may be unfeasible with a wide lens).

Now, if this is the only picture the photographer has taken, then both the editor (who had not had a lot of options, though still could go without a photo entirely) and the photographer are guilty of contributing unprofessional journalism.

On the other hand, if the editor chose to use only the tele shot while having other angles available, then the editor is culpable (the photographer, only in so much as they do not raise a concern and choose to continue to work with that editor).

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by stretchcat on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @01:59PM (#25932298)
> However, there is no proof that the photographer was deliberately seeking to create a distorted impression of the scene.

How could there be? Do you expect the photographer to outright admit that intent? Short of such an admission, what would proof of the photographers' intent look like?

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by tomatocracy on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:36PM (#25934309)
I suspect it's unfair to blame the photographers on the ground directly for this. Often photographers will take a number of shots from different angles and at different focal lengths and at different moments. At least in some publications after that they will have then had only very limited input into which images got used (or whether their images or someone else's were used).

In these cases it is/was an editorial decision. If editorial staff had multiple images to choose from like this then it's hard to see a decision to use the most crowded-looking photos (which it's pretty hard to argue isn't what happened) as a completely innocent one.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by not2b on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:24PM (#25936870)
Yes, if the subject of the story is "overcrowding at popular park despite coronavirus" it is intensely dishonest to exclusively use shots taken with long lenses.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by chasd00 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:58AM (#25928306)
that was incredibly depressing to me. I think the manipulating of perspective when trying to make the fish you caught look bigger is harmless enough but manipulating perspective to push a political agenda is harmful and depressing. Any photo i see on a news outlet i now have to tease out what manipulations may exist.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:48AM (#25927079)
> Anyone even vaguely interested in photography knows about lens compression.

And here I thought lens compression doesn't exist:

https://fstoppers.com/originals/lens-compression-doesnt-exis...

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by mannykannot on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:59AM (#25928970)
I suspect the illusion comes from assuming the picure is realistic, in the sense that there is a place where one could stand and perceive the scene as depicted.

In my experience, which is limited to phone cameras and the like, they seem to produce realistic images at short ranges, but a landscape picture looks much smaller and more distant than how the scene seems to me as I take it, unless I zoom in. That has me wondering if there is some geometry that would give realistic-looking pictures at all distances? Perhaps if the camera is sized such that the lens-to-sensor distance is about the same as the eye-to-picture distance when viewing the images?

Another issue that I am wondering about comes from the fact that telescopes (and, I am assuming, telescopic lenses for photography) have an objective lens to produce an image that is much closer, and then an eyepiece (or whatever the equivalent is called in photography) to view that image. Does this have different perspective and foreshortening effects than a simple lens which merely casts an image directly on the sensor plane? To put it another way, for a given telescopic lens, is there, at least conceptually, an equivalent simple lens which would produce an identical image of any scene?

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by bitcurious on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:53AM (#25929733)
> In my experience, which is limited to phone cameras and the like, they seem to produce realistic images at short ranges, but a landscape picture looks much smaller and more distant than how the scene seems to me as I take it, unless I zoom in. That has me wondering if there is some geometry that would give realistic-looking pictures at all distances? Perhaps if the camera is sized such that the lens-to-sensor distance is about the same as the eye-to-picture distance when viewing the images?

If you have access to camera with a manual hardware zoom, put it up to your right eye, keep your left eye open. Adjust the zoom on the camera until what you see with your right and lines up with what you see with your left.

That’s the perspective that you see at. Do this with a few friends and you’ll find out that you all see at slightly different “zoom levels,” meaning there can’t be an out of the box universal “eyesight lens.”

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by vilhelm_s on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @12:47PM (#25931295)
Telescopes etc are already designed to give the same perspective and foreshortening effects as a "simple" lens or a pinhole camera. There can be some imperfections (e.g. "barrel distortions"), but these are pretty small. Compared to a single lens, a fancy telephoto lens captures more light (producing a brighter image), it may blur the out-of-focus part of the picture more, and it has less chromatic aberration, but the perspective projection is the same.

The perspective distortion comes for landscape photos are due to the field of view. So the absolute distance between lens and sensor doesn't matter, what matters is the ratio between that distance and the width of the sensor. As long as that ratio is the same as the ratio of the eye-to-picture distance and width of the picture, the perspectives will match.

The problem is that if you are looking at a landscape with your bare eyes, you will look at a quite large field of view. To reproduce that field of view when looking at the picture, you probably need to print it several meters wide, and look at it from a meter away or so. If you take a photo with the same field of view but print it at a handheld size, it will look "too small" and the perspective will seem exaggerated.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by KineticLensman on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:43AM (#25929559)
I use cameras practically and can’t quote the theory, but my understanding is as follows:

> That has me wondering if there is some geometry that would give realistic-looking pictures at all distances?

I don’t think so. Compared with wider angle lenses as in phones, camera telephoto lenses produce the compression effect when the nearer and further objects are relatively close to each other compared with their common distance to the camera. If you had three people at 5, 100 and 105 metres away the 5m one would probably be out of focus and look significantly larger than the two at 100 and 105m. A zoom lens allows the degree of compression to be changed, but the image changes as you zoom.

> Another issue that I am wondering about comes from the fact that telescopes (and, I am assuming, telescopic lenses for photography) have an objective lens to produce an image that is much closer, and then an eyepiece (or whatever the equivalent is called in photography) to view that image.

Cameras don’t have an eyepiece lens in the same way that telescopes and microscopes do. In DSLRs, there is a mirror that routes the light to the camera viewfinder. When a picture is taken, the mirror moves out of the way and the light from the lens directly hits the sensor. In mirrorless digital cameras, the viewfinder image is created electronically rather than optically from the sensor.

Most serious camera 'lenses' in fact have multiple elements. By way of example, a Nikon 20-200 lens has the following: 21 elements in 18 groups (including 6 ED lens elements, 2 aspherical elements, 1 fluorite element, 1 SR lens element, elements with Nano Crystal and ARNEO coats, and a fluorine-coated front lens element) [0]

[0] https://store.nikon.co.uk/nikkor-lenses-nikkor-z-lenses/nikk...

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by mannykannot on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:02AM (#25929868)
It is certainly true that a camera does not have the equivalent of a telescope's eyepiece lens (at least when capturing the picture), but I think one could say that in a telescope, the combination of eyepiece lens and the lens of the viewer's eye functions in the same way as a camera, by casting a real image on the sensor (the retina, in this case.)
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by ajuc on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @01:16PM (#25931698)
> In my experience, which is limited to phone cameras and the like, they seem to produce realistic images at short ranges, but a landscape picture looks much smaller and more distant than how the scene seems to me as I take it, unless I zoom in.

That's another issue, not caused by different lens or physics but by how our brains interprets what it sees. Our brains pick up and zoom on details subconsciously (and "compress" the uninteresting background) so you remember the details "bigger" than they are in reality.

That's why medieval cities on paintings have often towers twice the height compared to a photo of the same view. Same thing happens when you look at the Moon and then make a photo of it (without zooming). You have to zoom 2 or 3 times before it looks as big as "in reality".

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by moron4hire on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:13AM (#25927802)
This is the kind of "technically correct" that is "usefully wrong".

The concept of "lens compression" is understood to include composing the subject to the same apparent size with the different lenses. Yes, of course standing in one place and compositing multiple telephoto shots will create the same image as a single wide angle shot. That's not how people shoot. You're not going to compose a 3/4ths portrait shot with a telephoto, swap lenses, and just stand there. You're going to walk in on the subject and recompose to a 3/4ths portrait.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by bonoboTP on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:23AM (#25929282)
The problem is, people do misunderstand it, especially more artistic photographers, who are not as engineering minded as people here. Many actually think it is some kind of lens distortion, comparable to radial distortion or some kind of artifact or noise caused by the lens doing some lens magic. But the same effect persists with a pinhole camera too, the lens is a red herring. Not technically but fundamentally.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by rozab on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:21PM (#25935558)
But in the real world, it is the choice of lens that determines the level of distortion. Nobody's digitally cropping their photos to 1/16th the size.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by bonoboTP on Thursday January 28, 2021 @09:12AM (#25941958)
No, it is just the distance.

If you switch to a lens with higher magnification, that's an indirect reason. It may or may not make you move farther away. But the distortion/appearance is due to the distance.

Also, you may crop photos (ie digital zoom) or use a different sensor size or sensor distance.

At the end of the day, the necessary and sufficient condition for the change in appearance is the distance.the lens is neither sufficient nor necessary.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by kzrdude on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:34AM (#25928032)
It's an explanation that helps the photographer understand how it actually works - greater understanding that generalizes better.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by reedf1 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:52AM (#25927111)
Yes, lens compression is how people colloquially know a variety of perspective distortion (foreshortening). I have a background in optics and there is quite a bit of lingo discontinuity.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by VBprogrammer on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:20AM (#25927328)
I always find the running scene in The Graduate a great illustration of this effect. He is running flat out what feels like an age and yet barely seems to get any closer to the camera.

The last 30 seconds of this clip https://youtu.be/yRBNA27N0ts

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by rootusrootus on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:42AM (#25928803)
Another really good example are amateur videos taken of airliners landing in crosswinds. Usually taken head-on, they are necessarily taken from a very long distance, so it looks like the plane just hovers as it gently drops to the ground.
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by schoen on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:25PM (#25936874)
I remember someone mentioning this example:

https://vimeo.com/152514220

In this scene (if I remember correctly) the man on the right is coolly allowing the man on the left to believe that he's being threatened with being sent (by the approaching airplane) to another country where he would suffer a terrible fate.

The scene is meant to make it look like the airplane pilot has deliberately executed an impressive landing right next to the men, but apparently in real life it was quite far away (like a runway's length or so).

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by kzrdude on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:12AM (#25927790)
Fstoppers also made this video to go with it, it shows what they mean very well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_TTXY1Se0eg
Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by dreamcompiler on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:50PM (#25935844)
Indeed. Typical "correlation is not causation" phenomenon. Compression is caused by distance; not by your lens. But telephoto lenses are usually used when you're far away from your subject.

Another example is "we use AC power on the grid because it's more efficient than DC for transmission." Nope. High voltage is more efficient for transmission; we use AC only because Thomas Edison didn't have silicon carbide power transistors.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by brudgers on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:54AM (#25930501)
Theory aside, in a pandemic, the longer lens is more conducive to social distancing. Its use may be simply a matter of sound hygiene and not editorial stance.

For a journalist, a long focal length may be the most practical way to get a shot. Nick Ut carries a DSLR with a 60-600mm in addition to his Leica these days.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by core-questions on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @12:12PM (#25930752)
>the longer lens is more conducive to social distancing

Why, because you're liable to hit someone with it when you swing around if they don't give you some space?

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by ISL on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @12:30PM (#25931051)
Some of the most-impactful photojournalism images are made with focal lengths between 24 and 50 mm. To fill the frame with your subject requires being well within their personal space.

70 mm and higher really allows a lot of distance. The pandemic has definitely changed things, at least temporarily.

Re:Telephoto fear: how lenses affect views of crowds by m463 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:36PM (#25934305)
I think that's what photographers do. They pull out the formula menu.

Most movies about city things show that shot - the people walking walking walking - moving up and down and never getting closer or further away.

And movies in the country always have an aerial shot over the countryside showing trees and roads below, finally zooming in on the car driving.