You can offer the user the choice between targeted advertising or non-targeted. You can offer the user the choice between paid subscription or advertising.
Cant get enough users to pay or consent ? Then you did not find market-fit in the real world.
You have to handle a "right to be forgotten" query within a month, surely this is enough time for one sysop to run a prepared query. If your database is so byzantine that you cant find all reference to a given customer, you are either google or in need of a new architect.
Backups do not need to be deleted immediately, they should however expires and be destroyed in accordance to your data retention policy (Say what you do, do as you say).
We both know rules are extremely clear and simple. They get complicated when companies try to go around them.
The only places I've seen actually do this are local newspapers in the US. Are there many other substantial companies doing this?
In general, dropping the EU is an expensive game: it's 450 million people, including many rich developed countries. GDPR doesn't mean you can't advertise or do other freemium upselling, it just means you can't precisely track people's personal data to do so, and the rules for that are fairly common sense & clear imo. It's not difficult for most businesses to make good money and stay inside the rules.
I'd rather not interact with a company that disrespects my privacy and it's rather helpful they have to tell me this up front.
I'm not even sure why GDPR is so foreign to the US. Think HIPAA for everyone, not just healthcare providers.
Without making a judgement on the merits of the approach, as a user/individual I appreciate the power this gives to protect my data. As a company/developer the conplexity of navigating the landmines that this poses makes me understand why a lot non EU companies decide to just block EU users. Is it "good riddance " in both cases? Maybe, but still the fact that innovating becomes more expensive sits there.