News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by jarin on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:23PM (#2589084)
Hopefully if this gets blocked they'll do something about DHS arbitrarily seizing domain names.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by code_duck on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:45PM (#2589149)
The underlying issue there is 'civil forfeiture' in general. My view is that this practice is unconstitutional for any sort of property, and it's causing a lot of problems with the motivation of individuals in law enforcement. Automobiles, cash, and real estate have been being seized with no due process, no warrant and even no arrest for years. Domain names are just a new twist in that story.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by dailyrorschach on Thursday May 26, 2011 @04:03PM (#2589208)
Indeed the entire statute around these things needs to be re-thought out. And even if you are eventually acquitted the property can still remain the property of the state.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture#Asset_forfeitu...

Just traveling with "an unusual amount of cash" can get your money taken from you on a traffic stop even if they don't find any evidence of you selling narcotics.

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by SoftwareMaven on Thursday May 26, 2011 @04:40PM (#2589364)
I have never understood how those seizures could not be unconstitutional. The laws shouldn't exist, but if they do, the people enforcing them should not be receiving the benefits for enforcing them.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by CWuestefeld on Thursday May 26, 2011 @05:02PM (#2589427)
The underlying issue there is 'civil forfeiture' in general. My view is that this practice is unconstitutional for any sort of property,

But property -- cars, domain names, cash, etc. -- is not human, and therefore is not protected by our Bill of Rights. Your domain name does not have the right to a trial, and so, when it is accused of being an accessory in a crime (e.g., the domain name was a person who set up the meeting between the customer and the purveyor of stolen IP), the government is within its authority to detain it and keep it locked up for as long as is deemed necessary.

(Not that I buy this bizarre logic, but that's the rationale for asset forfeiture.)

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by code_duck on Thursday May 26, 2011 @06:41PM (#2589691)
The 4th amendment regards "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizure". That appears to cover seizure of property fairly well, though I suppose the key word is 'unreasonable'. It's also unclear how this is applied to civil matters vs. criminal. Though forfeiture is usually hand-in-hand with criminal charges, they claim it's a civil matter.

The 5th amendment says citizens shall not be "deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." In the US, police can currently take your car, money, or other possessions without even placing you under arrest. This seems to me to violate the spirit of this amendment as well as the 4th.

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by CWuestefeld on Friday May 27, 2011 @09:54AM (#2591431)
Things are never easy, when you start to break things down to the atomic level.

For example, if my wife were to commit a crime, they'd take her away from me without giving me any kind of hearing to protect my interests in her. And believe me, my interest in her is much stronger than in any domain name, or a car.

The only difference in this hypothetical is that she, being human, gets to have her own hearing. But with inanimate objects (or intangibles), there's not even an obligation to give the object a hearing.

Disclaimer once again: I disagree with my own logic here, I'm just trying to play devil's advocate, illustrating the course that an argument might take.

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by palish on Friday May 27, 2011 @03:40AM (#2590728)
And there is absolutely nothing we can do about it.

(I challenge anyone to prove otherwise. I hope I lose.)

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by yummyfajitas on Thursday May 26, 2011 @08:25PM (#2589960)
It's strange how so many people find this logic insane when applied to a domain name or physical property [1], but accept it wholeheartedly when applied to a corporation.

[1] This logic is often used by police departments to rob people of cash/cars on the theory they are somehow involved in drugs.

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by CWuestefeld on Thursday May 26, 2011 @10:44PM (#2590271)
I'm not sure what you mean when you refer to applying to to a corporation. Can you expand that a little?
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by yummyfajitas on Friday May 27, 2011 @02:21AM (#2590604)
One example: people often advocate for restrictions on "corporate" speech (or more precisely, the right of the corporations owners to use their property for expressive purposes) on the grounds that a corporation isn't a human and therefore doesn't deserve freedom of speech.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by SamReidHughes on Friday May 27, 2011 @03:03AM (#2590668)
But of course corporations don't deserve freedom of speech. They use their speech to influence the electoral process. When G.E. runs ads supporting candidates, they undermine the principles of democracy. Except for the New York Times, NBC, the ACLU, and all the others whose speech I often agree with, corporate rights should be tightly controlled and regulated, and you should only be able to create corporations that create speech that legislators can deal with.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by code_duck on Friday May 27, 2011 @01:00AM (#2590483)
The basis of corporate law is that a corporation is considered to be an individual in certain respect - hence the root of the word. A corporation is given certain rights and responsibilities that a natural person would have.
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by palish on Friday May 27, 2011 @03:42AM (#2590734)
I never noticed that "corporation" is so close to "corporeal".
Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by Natsu on Thursday May 26, 2011 @05:37PM (#2589535)
You're right about that logic being dangerous. The sad thing is that I can think up similar reasoning that would allow them to sidestep the Constitution with respect to the internet entirely too easily and to derail any opposition with meaningless partisan bickering.

The more I think about it, the more I think that we need to extend the Bill of Rights.

Re:Sen. Ron Wyden places a "hold" on the Protect IP Act by chc on Thursday May 26, 2011 @06:20PM (#2589644)
But doesn't the Fifth Amendment explicitly protect property? (I'm not saying you're wrong about their rationale, but the rationale doesn't seem based in reality to me.)