News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:39AM (#25881297)
People like this shouldn't be leading a project that threatens to upend multi-trillion dollar institutions.

If it weren't for his timidity, Bitcoin would have hard forked in 2015 to raise the block size limit to allow for mass-adoption.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 127 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:41AM (#25881544)
Raising the block size is complete nonsense. It will simply kill of nodes and at best create increased transactions per block proportional to the block size increase. A very poor trade-off.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by SnowProblem on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:11PM (#25884054)
Bitcoin's creator thought the block size should be raised and nodes would end up in server farms. Whether you agree with this or not, that was the original vision of Bitcoin. Now, start-ups pivot, and it's great that there are experiments, but BTC should not have used the Bitcoin name to do this. That is the point being made.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:01PM (#25885085)
That is really misleading, in one of Satoshi's last public messages he wrote:

> Bitcoin users might get increasingly tyrannical about limiting the size of the chain so it's easy for lots of users and small devices.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1790.msg28917#msg289...

There has always been a challenging trade-off here, which is presumably why he limited the size in the first place.

This trade-off was widely acknowledged in the community going back essentially as far as records do.

And as time has gone on we've only learned more about how some ideas don't work. For example, Satoshi believed businesses would run nodes to verify their own transactions-- but we've found in practice few do, instead outsourcing it to centralized third parties often with dubious security practices.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by SnowProblem on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:34PM (#25887576)
It looks to me like he's describing a trend he disagrees with. Nobody would describe their own vision as "tyrannical".
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#25886509)
Why don't you quote all of the instances where he endorsed large blocks?

You're singling out one expression of mildly small-block sentiment and overlooking multiple expressions of strongly large-block sentiment by Satoshi.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @08:34PM (#25888039)
There aren't any?

He _implemented_ the block size limit, nothing forced him to. Had he wanted it to change automatically he could have coded it that way. Instead, he tended to describe the design as being mostly set in stone. When someone tried to remove the limit he urgently yelled at them to stop (and stated if it were ever needed it could be phased in). I'm sure that his, like everyone elses, understanding of the requirements evolved over time too.

Meanwhile, scaling Bitcoin via layers was endorsed explicitly by essentially every technical voice in the space for years until some got wrapped up with scammers. Satoshi even built specific affordances for payment channels directly into the transaction format, and was the first person to describe their use.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:39PM (#25888935)
Here:

"At first, most users would run network nodes, but as the network grows beyond a certain point, it would be left more and more to specialists with server farms of specialized hardware. A server farm would only need to have one node on the network and the rest of the LAN connects with that one node."

- November, 2008

Here:

"The current system where every user is a network node is not the intended configuration for large scale. That would be like every Usenet user runs their own NNTP server. The design supports letting users just be users."

-July, 2010

Here:

"It would be nice to keep the [block chain] files small as long as we can.

The eventual solution will be to not care how big it gets.

But for now, while it’s still small, it’s nice to keep it small so new users can get going faster. When I eventually implement client-only mode, that won’t matter much anymore. (note to readers, "client-only mode" refers to SPV mode)"

- August, 2010

Here:

"The existing Visa credit card network processes about 15 million Internet purchases per day worldwide. Bitcoin can already scale much larger than that with existing hardware for a fraction of the cost. It never really hits a scale ceiling."

- in an email to Mike Hearn

Are you really unfamiliar with these, or think they're not worthy of your reader's attention?

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Monday January 25, 2021 @01:55AM (#25900135)
The first was discussing mining.

The second is saying not literally every user, similar to the third. (and in fact said it would be best to keep things as small as possible for as long as possible!)

The last was in a message thread that discussed using payment channels.

So I do not agree with your claim that they unambiguously supported your position, moreover they were made much earlier-- before there was much practical experience. I already pointed out his last comment on the subject...

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:33AM (#25902031)
>>The first was discussing mining.

There's no evidence to suggest it's discussing mining. It's directly in response to a criticism of the Bitcoin design, where a correspondent argues that everyone validating everything to ensure the transactions they receive are valid will get too costly in computing resources. This is the email that the quoted statement was responding to:

http://www.metzdowd.com/pipermail/cryptography/2008-November...

>To detect and reject a double spending event in a timely manner, one must have most past transactions of the coins in the transaction, which, naively implemented, requires each peer to have most past transactions, or most past transactions that occurred recently. If hundreds of millions of people are doing transactions, that is a lot of bandwidth - each must know all, or a substantial part thereof.

So it's unambiguously about validation. Why would you claim otherwise?

And the last known statements Satoshi made on it were in emails to Mike Hearn, like this one, from December 29 2010:

>>A higher limit can be phased in once we have actual use closer to the limit and make sure it's working OK.

>>Eventually when we have client-only implementations, the block chain size won't matter much. Until then, while all users still have to download the entire block chain to start, it's nice if we can keep it down to a reasonable size.

>>With very high transaction volume, network nodes would consolidate and there would be more pooled mining and GPU farms, and users would run client-only. With dev work on optimising and parallelising, it can keep scaling up.

>>Whatever the current capacity of the software is, it automatically grows at the rate of Moore's Law, about 60% per year.

That is much more clearly his preference/vision than the brief reference to the community turning tyrannical about block sizes, and it was more recent.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:59AM (#25881630)
Nodes can handle far more than 7 transactions per second of throughput, even if you 4X the data size of that to account for propagation to multiple peers. 10 KB/s is nothing. Keeping nodes so light so that you can validate with a Raspberry Pi with a dialup connection, at the cost of preventing 100X more people from using Bitcoin, is a terrible tradeoff.

There is no technological bottleneck preventing a 100X raising of the throughput limit: not Initial Blockchain Download, which is already being expedited with trusted third party set checkpoints, not computation, not storage and not bandwidth.

The vast majority of Bitcoin agreed with my sentiment, and that was the sentiment expressed by Satoshi any time he commented on it.

It was just irresponsible, overly timid leadership allowing a loud minority to sabotage Bitcoin's widely supported roadmap.

Responding to the comment below:

1. You can prune spent transactions. Only the UTXO set needs to be stored, so you don't need to store 5 TB more each year. But even that wouldn't be prohibitively costly for thousands of hobbyists worldwide. So even if pruning wasn't an option - and it is - Bitcoin's censorship resistance would remain totally secure.

2. You can use checkpointing in initial sync up, instead of downloading the entire transaction history. The hash of the true chain is widely disseminated and Bitcoin nodes already use a form of checkpointing, where they skip validation for transactions before the checkpoint flag, to expedite Initial Blockchain Download.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by jart on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:11AM (#25881681)
Raising the limit 100x means the blockchain would grow 5tb a year. So personal computers would not be able to use Bitcoin anymore. Only companies like Google would have the resources to participate in the Bitcoin network.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by cheaprentalyeti on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:09AM (#25882312)
The block limit has nothing to do with the transaction rate. You'll just wind up waiting longer for a block.

Bitcoin core has had since the Big Forks a larger number of transactions than Bitcoin Cash, which was forked to allegedly fix the transaction rate.

If the rest of you had actually tried /running a node/ instead of just copying and pasting the fifty cent army's argument of the day maybe you'd realize that.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:22PM (#25885248)
I don't think you're disagreeing with the post you're replying to.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 127 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:03AM (#25881645)
If you have to be a server farm to prune past 1 week, Bitcoin will no longer be decentralized and censorship resistant, losing its main point in the first place.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:11AM (#25881677)
A single modern consumer-grade PC can validate 100X larger blocks in real time.

The average web page these days is over 1 MB. The idea that you need to limit every once-in-every-10-minute block to 1 or 1.6 MB is not, from everything I can see, close to approaching a sound balancing of competing priorities.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by mtrycz2 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @11:41AM (#25883639)
My RPi4 can handle 256MB blocks on BCH's scalenet, just fine.

There never was a scaling issue.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:50PM (#25889022)
Exactly. Even 100X larger blocks, meaning 100 MB blocks, would allow for very high levels of decentralization.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:21PM (#25885236)
If the throughput of the network equals the throughput of your device, you'll never catch up if you go offline at all. At 90% capacity it will take you 10 hours to catch up for every hour you are behind. Taking long periods of catch up time for outages isn't acceptable. At 100x capacity most conventional equipment right now would fail to complete its initial synchronization before the participant gave up.

The security of the system comes from decenteralization, so its goals can't be reached if its only workable for the best funded 10% of the participants. Moreover, the operating cost of a node are only compensated fairly indirectly and are a public good (if everyone else runs an honest node, you don't gain from running your own). As a result, it's not sufficient to just be not-astronomical, it has to be fairly close to painless.

Node's ability to keep up is also only one part of the equation. Bitcoin's long term security is absolutely dependant on transaction fees paying for proof of work. With functionally limitless capacity the natural price of transactions is essentially zero-- as has been demonstrated by competing systems which have found that they can only fund security with inflation.

Most critically-- while you can make a fine argument that some moderate increases (more like 2x or 5x than 100x) are viable without too much increase in security risks-- those kinds of changes (heck, even 100x) don't categorically change the situation.

But we do have technology to categorically change the situation, tech that was thought of and made accordance for before Bitcoin was ever released and has always been part of the long term plans-- regardless of whatever lies motivated parties might want to tell you-- tech like lighthing adds essentially unlimited transaction throughput to Bitcoin because it doesn't require public broadcast for each and every transaction. I was talking to someone this morning who is doing a test sustaining 400 transactions per second.

> and that was the sentiment expressed by Satoshi any time he commented on it.

Sorry, that is just a flat out lie-- at I pointed out in a prior comment literally the last public statement Satoshi made on the matter of scalablity/resource usage was: "Bitcoin users might get increasingly tyrannical about limiting the size of the chain so it's easy for lots of users and small devices."

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1790.msg28917#msg289...

There is a long history of the position I'm presenting, going back to many of Bitcoin's earliest participants.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:39PM (#25886392)
If you're going to interpret Satoshi's single "tyrannical" reference as endorsement of restraining block sizes to 1 MB, it is a much weaker 'endorsement' than multiple explicit calls for a much higher on-chain throughput, including his directly saying that the intended network configuration for Bitcoin at scale was for validation to be done only by users with server farms, which implies even greater than 100X boosts in throughput from current levels.

As for initial synchronization:

There is no basis for claiming users cannot keep up with it at 100X current throughput levels, and like I said, relying on trusted third party set checkpoints to completely do away with validating the entire blockchain history is always an option, and already one being utilized to some extent with the flag in Bitcoin Core to skip validation on transactions older than a TTP-set checkpoint.

Saying every one should validate, but then limiting the world to 300,000 on-chain writes a day, meaning limiting who can use Bitcoin without third-party intermediaries to 0.1% of the world population, is a bad trade-off. Better 10% of Bitcoiners be able to run their own fully validating node, and all 7 billion people be able to generate transactions *with their own private keys*, than let every one with a PC run a fully validating node, while only 0.1% make writes to Bitcoin with their own private keys.

In a scenario where a party cannot write a transaction to Bitcoin, due to limited on-chain capacity, there is little point in running a fully validating node. Emphasizing full node validation accessibility over main chain write accessibility to this extent is not a sensible prioritization.

Regarding this off-chain payment channel networks Red Herring, there is no reason to be confident that PCNs like the lightning network can provide a mix of trade-offs that will make them compelling to a wide set of users, and indeed the LN has still failed to get traction nearly 6 years after first being proposed.

The capital lock-up requirements, especially in a setting where on-chain transaction fees are high, the need for being online to trustlessly receive funds, and the routing challenges, are all potentially fundamental showstoppers for the LN being a viable technology for widespread utilization/adoption.

Finally, even if payment channel networks work - which is a very speculative 'if' and not one that the entire empowerment of humanity with access to electronic cash should be made dependent on - blocks would still need to be on the order of 100X larger to enable global mass-adoption, as payment channel networks do not completely do away with the need to have on-chain throughput.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by tromp on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:30PM (#25884254)
Checkpointing very much runs counter to the decentralizing philosophy of bitcoin. Nodes should be able to fully verify the transaction history with reasonable resources.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:50PM (#25886478)
In practice, checkpoint is not a big deal. For history older than X, where X is a sufficiently distant time in the past, there will always be widespread consensus on the hash of the true chain, and numerous reputable parties that the hash of the true chain can be obtained from. Some poison node attack where fraudulent websites provide a hash of a fake history will not be viable.

Checkpointing is also currently being utilized in Bitcoin Core, so relying on it further is not a major departure on how things are currently done.

And at 100X current block sizes, validating the entire history with no checkpoints will still be possible for thousands of hobbyists with beefed up but still modest hardware/bandwidth.

The empowerment from 100X more people being able to write transactions to the main chain, with their own private keys, will be well worth the relatively tolerable compromises on full node validation.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by tromp on Sunday January 24, 2021 @02:30AM (#25890108)
Bitcoin Core never did checkpointing in the sense of skipping prior history. They merely required a particular block at a particular height.

Not fully verifying history is a complete departure from how things are done in bitcoin full nodes.

And Bitcoin Core removed even those checkpoints [1].

[1] https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/75733/why-does-b...

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @05:39AM (#25890941)
Bitcoin Core removed that form of checkpointing, and added in another.

Currently it has checkpointing in the form of assumevalid, which by default causes a full node to skip validation of transaction older than the checkpoint when synchronizing. [1]

[1] https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/88652/does-assum...

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by tromp on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:24AM (#25891470)
Well, that is depressing to learn. So by default, a bitcoin full node DOESN't fully validate transaction history. If it finds a particular block at a particular height (that a group of developers have signed off on), then all signature validations in prior blocks are assumed to be successful. The reasoning is that you have to trust those developers anyway not to sign off on malicious source code.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:28AM (#25892259)
Yes, and that is why the alleged initial synchronization concerns surrounding larger blocks are mostly baseless.

As it is, tens of millions of people can easily stream 700 KB/s HD video 24/7, yet Bitcoin is being kept to a throughput of 2 KB/s based on the claim that increasing it to satisfy market demand would lead to Bitcoin becoming centralized, with only large corporate entities left being able to fully validate.

It's pure FUD.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by pcdoodle on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:33AM (#25881770)
Get out of here with this bullshit. Do you know it is bitcoins resistance to change that makes it appealing?

Layer 2 is where the scaling happens. END OF STORY.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Saturday January 23, 2021 @01:37PM (#25884906)
Problem is, there is no working layer 2, after all these years and tremendous effort. That project has failed. END OF STORY.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by b10c on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:47AM (#25881332)
There is no single leader in Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:57AM (#25881378)
He could have authorized the hard fork.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by robjan on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:09AM (#25881432)
The miners are ultimately the ones who decide whether to fork or not.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by jart on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:57AM (#25881614)
Miners can't change Bitcoin without the consent of full nodes, who run the core client. That's why SegWit2x didn't happen three years ago. All the miners supported it, because bigger blocks means bigger transaction fees. Full nodes and core devs didn't support it, because big blocks means you won't be able to run Bitcoin on PCs much longer and therefore centralized online service providers will control it.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:29PM (#25885295)
FWIW bigger blocks actually mean much much smaller transaction fees, both in theory and practice. Though it's true some miners erroneously believed arguments otherwise.

BCash, for example, some loopy "large block" clone of Bitcoin has only rarely had more than $1 in fees in blocks-- and not primarily because it has fewer transactions (though it does), but because there is no cause to pay more than negligible amounts when both capacity isn't scarce and mining isn't completely centralized.

The result is that the BitcoinUnlimited (one of the BCash clients) "chief scientist" proposes that security must be paid for by perpetual inflation... and they've been moving towards abandoning Bitcoin's decentralized consensus-- e.g. bcash clients will no longer reorg so if there is a split deeper than a few blocks (caused by a network partition or a block race), their nodes will just split off into separate networks. Quite a mess.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @11:21PM (#25889215)
>>FWIW bigger blocks actually mean much much smaller transaction fees, both in theory and practice.

Ethereum has larger transaction fees than Bitcoin right now, on a larger volume of transactions, so in practice, that is not true.

The addressable market will necessarily shrink with too small blocks.

Now of course when Bitcoin Cash launches, with most of the world unaware of it, it's not going to get as much as adoption, and by extension transaction fees, as Bitcoin, irrespective of its block size limit, so your comparison is inappropriate.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Monday January 25, 2021 @01:31AM (#25899998)
Ethereum has a what is effectively a block size limit, which is limiting usage to pretty similarly to Bitcoin's and it is operating hard against it. ('volume' of transactions is not particularly comparable because the average bitcoin transaction now makes multiple payments in a single txn).

Back in the past the issuer of Ethereum stated publicly that online money should not cost more than 5cts/txn... and yet here we are with $50 transactions there.

BCash has not only fewer transaction in spite of tens of millions spent promoting it, but it has vastly lower fees per transaction. If its blocks were half full at 10x the current feerate (and many times larger than bitcoin blocks), its fee income would still be a tiny fraction of Bitcoin's-- and nowhere near enough to support even the extremely low level of security it currently has.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:13AM (#25881687)
Miners were solidly behind a hard fork. Every major stakeholder group, minus the Core development team, was solidly for it.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by nullc on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:31PM (#25885306)
That is simply not true. You can even look to the public markets, there were futures on each of these fork attempts and they traded at a tiny fraction of the price of Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by CryptoPunk on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:46PM (#25888990)
The majority of mining power signalled support for several attempts to do a hard fork to raise the block size limit:

https://twitter.com/btcinchina/status/804163370043588608

"3rd largest #bitcon #mining pool BW signal support for 8M blocksize, following the consensus from scaling conference."

And another initiative:

https://www.coindesk.com/btcchina-support-gives-bip-100-bitc...

"BTCChina Support Gives BIP 100 Bitcoin Hashrate Majority"

>>there were futures on each of these fork attempts and they traded at a tiny fraction of the price of Bitcoin.

The futures predicted the likelihood of the fork happening, not what percentage of miners supported them.