I don't understand how this is a paradox. You can't extend tolerance to people who commit arson and murder, or e.g. refuse to hire black people because they're black.
You can let people say whatever they want, because then you can refute their arguments and refuse to implement their proposals.
Indeed, you can let them say whatever they want. But that doesn't mean that anyone else should or should not. It's not like there aren't companies and service providers willing to host the content.
> refuse to implement their proposals
There are real practical limits to free speech.
A "proposal" that is an incitement to organized violence is of the same kind as yelling "fire" in a crowded theater.
That is fundamentally different than a proposal to eliminate the estate tax, provide a universal basic income, or organizing to peacefully protest using civil disobedience.
Isn't the service currently down?
> yelling "fire" in a crowded theater.
https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim...
> A "proposal" that is an incitement to organized violence
But then you need not worry about what some website or service is doing because that is illegal and the police can arrest them for it.
Basically, a call to violence isn't information, it's action, like ordering a hit. The prohibited act is really the order, i.e. participation in a conspiracy to commit an act of violence, and the communication is only the evidence of it.
Compare mob boss who says "whack that guy" and goes to jail for it vs. news reporter who reports that mob boss ordered a hit, unintentionally informing a hit man who wasn't aware of the order. News reporter doesn't go to jail for that because their intent was only to communicate information, not enable the act of violence, even though they conveyed the same information and it had the same result.
They are working on getting it up and running under a Russian ISP, DDos-Guard.
https://www.cnet.com/news/parler-website-is-back-online-in-l...
If sites like Gab and its ilk can figure it out, so cab Parler.
> > yelling "fire" in a crowded theater. > https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim...
From that article:
"[In Brandenburg v. Ohio] the Court held that inflammatory speech--and even speech advocating violence by members of the Ku Klux Klan--is protected under the First Amendment, unless the speech "is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action"."
> But then you need not worry about what some website or service is doing because that is illegal and the police can arrest them for it.
You don't need to worry, but the website is well within their rights to worry about what people are posting to their site and take action to limit that if they see fit.
The article this discussion is attached to is called "DDoS-Guard to forfeit internet space occupied by Parler".
> If sites like Gab and its ilk can figure it out, so cab Parler.
Parler was bigger than Gab. It remains to be seen whether the scale presents an issue.
> "[In Brandenburg v. Ohio] the Court held that inflammatory speech--and even speech advocating violence by members of the Ku Klux Klan--is protected under the First Amendment, unless the speech "is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action"."
But that isn't the case where the phrase "fire in a crowded theater" came from and that quote doesn't even appear to cover the phrase itself, since a panic is potentially dangerous but not illegal.
Here's some more on why the phrase should be discontinued:
https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-ha...
Bottom line, it's too vague to mean anything because all it implies is that unprotected speech exists without specifying any meaningful boundaries for it, so people regularly quote it in support of arbitrary overreach.
> You don't need to worry, but the website is well within their rights to worry about what people are posting to their site and take action to limit that if they see fit.
But we were talking about tolerance.
Tolerance for incitement to violence? I don't personally support tolerance of that, which is my right, and what I personally feel is better to avoid the spread of toxic cultures like found on Parler. Tolerance of diverse and non violence-provoking political opinions, including those I disagree with? That is something I totally support.
Parler clearly does tolerate incitement to violence, which is their right. Good for them for exercising it, but nobody has to support them, nor should anyone be prevented from supporting them. Likewise, if there are consequences (commericial or legal) for tolerating incitement to violence, Parler owns those too.
You are also free to tolerate it and provide services to support those who do.
That's the thing which is illegal because it isn't speech. It isn't information, it's action. See above.
> Parler clearly does, which is their right.
No, they don't. It violates their policy and they removed all that was reported to them.
It's a distinction without a difference. I don't want to host violence provoking content. I don't think others should either. You think they should, and you have your reasons. Everyone (and every organization) can make up their own minds.
Clearly, we disagree about which approach is better for society, and happily we do so cordially, which is just the sort of conversation we need more of.
> No, they don't. It violates their policy and they removed all that was reported to them.
That's false, and that it is false was upheld by the Federal judge today. Quoting https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-parler-violent-content-w...
"This case is not about suppressing speech or stifling viewpoints," Amazon's lawyers stated in a court filing. "Instead, this case is about Parler's demonstrated unwillingness and inability to remove from the servers of Amazon Web Services ('AWS') content that threatens the public safety, such as by inciting and planning the rape, torture and assassination of named public officials and private citizens."
"Parler's refusal to moderate content resulted in a "steady increase" in violent content on the network, breaching Amazon's terms of service, AWS contended.""
Still no. Nobody wants to be hosting it. The question is what happens when perfect moderation is impossible, which it is.
> That's false, and that it is false was upheld by the Federal judge today.
You're quoting Amazon's lawyers, not the judge.
Wanting to do something hard and being less than 100% successful is not the same thing as not wanting or trying to do it.
https://www.thestreet.com/phildavis/news/a-game-designers-an...
Show them the method of operation of the theory building so they can recognize it and stop participating in it.
Doing something like this can be great, but it takes time and effort, meanwhile acts of terrorism are being committed now.
Most qanoners dont really believe it, and if separated from their echo chambers, will deradicalize themselves
Not only that, for many of them it's just fun - in exactly the same way that some people find supermarket tabloids entertaining. The audience for these conspiracies is quite similar (probably overlaps) with the audience of the National Enquirer.
I know a qanoner in real life, and when i talked to him about it he denied easily provable facts, shifted goalposts, assumed i made arguments i didnt make, and now has taken to literally yelling over me so he cant hear the words im saying
I never liked that study because people always read it like that.
When people receive new information, they try to make it consistent with what they already believe by making the smallest possible change to the existing belief system to make them consistent.
That could be as simple as just not believing you.
This can strengthen their belief in the existing thing because they just evaluated it against some potentially conflicting new information without rejecting it.
Just not believing you doesn't work for an article like that because it's reasoning rather than facts. They have to find a hole in the logic if they want to keep their existing beliefs. So they'll come up with something like, maybe that's how it works for other conspiracy theories, but this one is real so it doesn't apply.
But now the logic is in their head, so the next time the conspiracy theory has to be reframed to match a changing reality, they notice that what's happening is consistent with the logic. It makes them doubt.
And the more information and reasoning they're exposed to which is inconsistent with the conspiracy theory, the more they doubt. It just like how the Big Lie works, but in reverse. You expose them to truth and logic over and over until they can no longer make the conspiracy theory consistent with it.
> Doing something like this can be great, but it takes time and effort, meanwhile acts of terrorism are being committed now.
"Acts of terrorism" aren't speech so as soon as they go there they go to jail. I mean they were planning it openly on Facebook, it was kind of a discredit to law enforcement that they weren't arrested for the conspiracy to begin with.
> Most qanoners dont really believe it, and if separated from their echo chambers, will deradicalize themselves
But that's why we need free speech, right? To avoid echo chambers.
Even if private censorship is allowed, that doesn't make it a good idea if it causes people to leave for some Voat-like cesspool where they won't encounter ordinary people anymore.
Absent access to "ordinary people" to recruit to violent causes, the inhabitants of such a "cesspool" will likely bore of their own conversation.
If, as you state, any of them are engaged in illegal provocation to violence, they will be easier to find there, since they lack the shield generated by the noise of "ordinary" conversation.
Besides, nobody is going to "helped" away from violent provocation by casually interacting with them social media. The only thing that can help such people is real in-person and trusted interaction, like at church, with a community help group, or with a therapist.
At best social media can be used to identify candidates to be offered an off-ramp from the road they are on, but that needs to be done by people who do de-radicalization as a full time job or mission, not casual social media acquaintances. Very few people are dedicated to that kind of work today.
So then there is nothing at all to fear from Parler and all of the efforts to keep it offline are misguided?
> If, as you state, any of them are engaged in illegal provocation to violence, they will be easier to find there, since they lack the shield generated by the noise of "ordinary" conversation.
Even in a garbage fire like Voat, the vast majority of posts aren't illegal. You need the ordinary people there because they're the ones willing to report violence to the police when they see it.
> Besides, nobody is going to "helped" away from violent provocation by interacting with them social media. The only thing that can help such people are real in-person and community interaction, like at church
Something something COVID.
If you fear Parler being online, you are being tricked by the media.
> "Acts of terrorism" aren't speech so as soon as they go there they go to jail.
preventing terrorism is generally considered better than just arresting people after it happened
> But that's why we need free speech, right? To avoid echo chambers.
Unless you are suggesting we ban all moderation, no echo chambers form due to selecting information sources you only agree with and information sources pandering
> Even if private censorship is allowed, that doesn't make it a good idea if it causes people to leave for some Voat-like cesspool where they won't encounter ordinary people anymore.
censorship at least gets rid of the non true believers, the reason stuff like qanon spread so quickly is because they used sites like facebook and twitter and didnt stay in cesspools like 8chan, we cant get everyone but most is better than none
Even people with psychological conditions have the capacity to modify their behavior.
> preventing terrorism is generally considered better than just arresting people after it happened
That premise came out of 9/11 when the terrorists didn't care if they died. In ordinary cases such as these you don't need a precrime unit because catching them after the fact provides a deterrent that prevents them from doing it to begin with.
But also, the police already do that. They send under cover officers into extremist groups and get warrants to conduct surveillance on individuals suspected of plotting violence. Then they get arrested for the plotting violence, not for speech.
> Unless you are suggesting we ban all moderation, no echo chambers form due to selecting information sources you only agree with and information sources pandering
The largest sites could exclude only that which is illegal.
> censorship at least gets rid of the non true believers
Until you actually implement it and end up censoring a bunch of stuff which is true, preventing some other lie from being corrected. And then people find out about that happening and lose faith in the censors, start looking for "alternative" media that doesn't do that, and get sucked back into conspiracy theory land.
> the reason stuff like qanon spread so quickly is because they used sites like facebook
The reason it spread so quickly is that Facebook promoted it, because their algorithms reward controversy.
And that's the real problem. If you carry on promoting "engagement" there will just be some new conspiracy theory, which you don't even notice until there are already a million people sucked into it and somebody gets killed. Stop doing that and there is nothing to censor.
This is incorrect.
Not tolerating intolerance is objective.
Sad so many people can't wrap their head around this incredibly simple paradox.
If you don't tolerate "intolerance", you are intolerant, it's as simple as that. And if you make yourself a clause to exclude some beliefs from acceptance and still deem yourself tolerant, you are a hypocrite.
[1]: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/toleranc...
I suspect actually tolerant people wouldn't be invoking the paradox.
There are very few ideas that can be invented and spread by a media personality without that idea already having a foothold. Unless you truly believe that 40% of the voting population are dumb mindless automatons. It's pretty condescending to anyone who considers themselves center right to be generalized like that.
Due to the realities of the two party system most people are going to "fall in line" with the party that is closest to their fundamental principles. For center right this means small government, lower taxes, merit based incentives, law enforcement, etc. You're asking a lot to ask a conservative to switch sides when the other side is so far from these fundamentals.
The same goes for republicans trying to convert democrats. Hard line ssues such as anti-abortion and "taxation is theft" are too much for center left people to handle. They're going to fall in line with whatever the Democrats are into at the time in order to make sure their fundamentals are upheld.
Trump was a symptom. The seeds were already planted. Once that weed began to grow it was inconceivable to the left and center left that anyone who called themselves human could look past the rhetoric and the character defects in order to support their deeper fundamental principles. The left began to see these people as less than human and showed their opinion with every newsreel, tweet, and post. It was, understandably, their moral duty. The only choice for someone on the right is to abandon their principles or dig deeper. He can't be THAT bad right? The conservatives are locked in and the other side isn't offering any olive branches to non-humans.
Both sides are then locked in a moral dilemma and the media is just fanning the flames. And then to top it all off during the reelection cycle we're forced to isolate and have our window to the world altered by bias confirming algorithms. There's no hope for unification under those conditions.
So many differences can be overcome by two people sitting face to face and seeing each other as two humans with different ideas experiencing the exact same stimuli. I just hope we can get back there some day.
Anger and distrust are sparked, stoked and fueled far more by personalities in media and politics who actively promote them than by de-platforming.
> Is it possible to bring fringe groups back into the fold of peaceful civil discourse
People organizing and advocating violence are not fringe groups. The paradox of tolerance applies here: You can't extend tolerance to those who advocate for intolerance without destroying tolerance in the process.