News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by dralley on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:40AM (#25848509)
(RH Employee)

> First, they should have announced this when they killed CentOS.

I agree.

>Second, this is only of value to the teeny tiny companies and individual users with a single server in their home. Small companies with any expectation of growth should probably just use Rocky instead from the get go.

Without saying too much - stay tuned for further announcements.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by justapassenger on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @04:31PM (#25852272)
> Without saying too much - stay tuned for further announcements.

It's a horrible way to treat users.

They aren't paying customers, so whatever for RH short-term bottom line. But amount of community backslash approach like that is bringing can have negative long term impact.

RH pulled the rug from under the people, and is telling them to stay tuned. I wouldn't base my infra on a system like that.

But that's good for overall Linux community - RH has way too much power there.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @02:51PM (#25851084)
Red Hat was not expecting the reaction to killing CentOS.

The need to expand the developer program into production seats could not have been anticipated.

I don't know of any other vendor that wraps developer accounts into production licenses.

Notice that this access is in no way promised to the end of support for RHEL 8.

I will say again, Red Hat has terminated two major Linux platforms over the last two decades - the original Red Hat Linux, which was terminated at v9, and now CentOS.

Oracle has "somewhat" terminated a Linux platform, Oracle Linux for SPARC, which was only supported for two minor releases. Oracle Linux for ARM64 and AMD64/x86 seem reasonably healthy.

There is other baggage in and between these corporations, but the track record on Linux OS platforms between these two is demonstrably different.

The free converters between them should be used fluidly.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @03:05PM (#25851250)
> The need to expand the developer program into production seats could not have been anticipated.

I don't follow. Are you suggesting that RH actually didn't realize that people were running CentOS at scale in production?

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @03:12PM (#25851324)
I see the decision to convert to CentOS stream as driven by two motivations, cost containment, and facilitating outside contributions by pushing CentOS towards Fedora (and away from RHEL stability).

I might be misreading these motivations.

With this management perspective, the CentOS community reaction to the retraction of the end of life date, and potential reduction in stability, was likely not anticipated.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by BossingAround on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @03:50PM (#25851817)
> pushing CentOS towards Fedora (and away from RHEL stability)

CentOS streams is literally RHEL with fixed major version and rolling minor versions. So, in the past, you got CentOS 7.1, then 7.2, etc., with streams, you get CentOS 8.x.

Saying that this is moving away from RHEL stability sounds highly disingenuous. Are you saying you've seen RHEL 7.X to break as opposed to 7.(X-1) version, and your solution was to wait for RHEL 7.(X+1)?

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @03:58PM (#25851912)
Is a "preview" as stable as the base release?

Are we not reading this correctly? If not, could you get Red Hat's CTO to retract this [mis]information?

'Another official part of it is, as [Chris] Wright [RedHat CTO] said, is that CentOS Stream as a "rolling preview" of what's next in RHEL, both in terms of kernels and features can be used in today's containerized, cloud-native IT world.'

https://www.zdnet.com/article/why-red-hat-dumped-centos-for-...

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @04:49PM (#25852443)
> CentOS streams is literally RHEL with fixed major version and rolling minor versions. So, in the past, you got CentOS 7.1, then 7.2, etc., with streams, you get CentOS 8.x.

> Saying that this is moving away from RHEL stability sounds highly disingenuous.

If it were so great, they'd do the same for paying customers. That they don't move RHEL to being just 8.X makes me think that Red Hat does in fact understand that that undermines the stability of the platform.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by goatinaboat on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:38PM (#25852916)
Red Hat was not expecting the reaction to killing CentOS.

It’s funny how everyone still says Red Hat when we mean IBM.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by lucideer on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:27PM (#25849998)
I understand as an RH employee you're likely not in a position to make decisions about what you can disclose when, but... (I'm sure you're aware) your first answer contradicts your second.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by dralley on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:49PM (#25850277)
There's no contradiction, only an acknowledgement that (in my personal opinion) the piecemeal way these plans are being announced is understandably frustrating, but that they are legitimately serious about making RHEL easier to use across a spectrum of use cases (which the official post is pretty clear about).
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:40PM (#25852932)
It's worse than frustrating, it's damaging for Red Hat.

It doesn't matter much to me anymore, I've already migrated my small business internal server that was running Centos 7 to Debian. We had basically just a fileserver, FTP box, and a couple VMs for some time clock, wiki, and building security systems, so nothing we were running yet was CentOS specific.

But in case it can be useful to you, please share with your team that the writing they're putting on the wall looks pretty bad. Knowing I'd have to update eventually, I just took the safe option, which is no longer any distro controlled by Red Hat. I didn't want to leave our server in a state where we could be building dependencies on a platform that was likely to be pulled out from under us, and while RHEL isn't too expensive to just buy for one server, and we might have qualified for something free or something you've not yet announced, my test was surprisingly painless and the migration was easier than I anticipated.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by syshum on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:26PM (#25853775)
I Agree 100%

RedHat seems to forget the for the majority of CentOS users STABLITY was the driving factor in the choice to use CentOS.

I am not sure what internal metrics they have, or if I am missing a glaring use case somewhere but from where I sit RedHat seems to completely miss the boat as to who is using CentOS in the real world.

I want STABLE UNCHANGING SECURE systems, not the latest and greatest features, or some new shiny "cloudy" technology...

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by ghaff on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @08:01PM (#25854041)
And yet you're not willing to pay for it.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by syshum on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @08:10PM (#25854102)
I dont drive those decisions butI will say if they had better "no support" options my org probably would buy it. We have no desire for RHEL support, they had had bad experiences in the past which was one of the driving reason to drop RHEL for CentOS, why pay for support if it sucks?
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:56PM (#25853522)
My guess is that at least 10% of the CentOS yum repository traffic was immediately lost at the announcement, as it switched to Oracle.

When your house is on fire, and you have a very short time to save your prized possessions, haste easily leads to observable contradictory actions.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by Traster on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:01PM (#25853087)
That's fine, but it would be negligent of a company to wait and hope that Red Hat pulls a rabbit out of a hat. The plan for most companies is going to be a new distro, and they're not going to reconsider when RH announces something new because by then decisions have been made and trust has been lost.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by arbitrage on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:25PM (#25849977)
yeah, stop playing games, redhat? just say what you're going to say already. i have no idea why you're trying to focus so hard on building mindshare, building a mystery around it like you're a sarah mclachlan tribute band, but you already blew it. go back to what you're good at, please.