News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by pg on Sunday July 27, 2008 @06:53PM (#258469)
That is false. I tell reporters stuff off the record all the time, and if anything what I tell them that way is truer, in the sense that I'm willing to tell them more.

I suspect if you asked reporters they'd say it was this way with most of the people they talk to. In fact, I have some evidence already that it is. Steven Levy told me that he hated it when people told him stuff off the record, because he couldn't use it. If it wasn't the truth, he wouldn't care.

Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by nikete on Sunday July 27, 2008 @08:20PM (#258537)
You tell reporters stuff about yourself off the record?

Because that, not off the record generally which Dan spends a whole paragraph defending, is the relevant bit.

Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by pg on Sunday July 27, 2008 @08:42PM (#258555)
You know, I was just guilty of doing what I always make fun of trolls for doing: commenting based on the title without reading the article first. But I've just read it and I see that I've also done the second thing I make fun of trolls for doing: attacking something other than what the author said. So I take back what I said. It's true, but beside the point.

I do still disagree with him slightly. It's not hard to imagine things one might want to tell about themselves only off the record. Especially about one's health: there are lots of medical conditions someone might be embarrassed to have other people know about.

But I was wrong to suggest that he distrusted off the record statements generally. It should have set off warning signals that I was accusing an experienced reporter of making such an elementary mistake.

One reason I didn't read the article was that it was so long. That's probably one reason people so often do this to me.

Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by Alex3917 on Sunday July 27, 2008 @11:06PM (#258660)
"That's probably one reason people so often do this to me."

It seems like a lot of the time when people do this to you it's because they've skipped over one of the qualifiers to your argument, especially when the qualifier comes a couple paragraphs before the actual anecdote or metaphor.

Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by anewaccountname on Sunday July 27, 2008 @11:31PM (#258680)
I think the most disturbing thing is that your original post was immediately modded up very high in spite of the reality of the article.
Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by mattmaroon on Monday July 28, 2008 @12:50AM (#258754)
It's PG, on PG's site, being voted on by PG fans who probably also didn't read the article. Disturbing, perhaps, but not shocking.
Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by Hexstream on Monday July 28, 2008 @12:25AM (#258731)
Yeah, I'd really need an undo-upmod feature right now. When you upmod something the down arrow could stay and become very pale.
Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by pg on Monday July 28, 2008 @09:22AM (#259034)
Well, this happens with the sort of troll posts I mentioned too.
Re:People who are telling the truth about themselves do not ... by rw on Sunday July 27, 2008 @09:30PM (#258603)
> That's probably one reason people so often do this to me.

You're probably the only author that gets them to read at all.