How would it be possible to allay your concerns? I think we've tried to be as clear as possible with our intentions - how could we rule out such possibilities with our license agreement?
It isn’t that I don’t trust you or your intentions now, it’s that intentions (and requirements) change.
You asked about allaying fears. Personally for me this means actually take-to-the-bank licensing that I could get through a legal audit, even if hypothetical.
Talk of “secret sauce” and future closed source and IP licensing of future maybe-must-have magic... that’s way too much future risk for me.
An example of what I think is good licensing is JUCE (https://juce.com). Everything from “free” to “paid with support”, all open source… but the point is I always know exactly where I stand legally, what I can and cannot do... and what I can and cannot do in the FUTURE.
We're very keen to make sure that the end-user developers are totally unencumbered and license-free, because we want lots of people to adopt it.
All our licensing is more aimed at device and driver builders - think of it like e.g. openGL - the industry making GL cards and drivers is legal complex, but none of that stuff affects the coders writing GL apps.
Or what if want to write a Vulkan to Metal like MoltenVK?
What if I want to write an interpreter for your bitcode?
What if I want to port soul secret source on top of Apple's Accelerate framework? Would you sue me to oblivion?
And good point. I understand where you’re coming from, but... I didn’t understand it when I read the post and blurb(s).
I never want to agree to an EULA before starting to develop something outside of a professional setting. That's an immediate dealbreaker for me. But even if I did - I wouldn't be able to disassemble or reverse engineer your software (2.2)? Also - why are there so many clauses in the EULA telling me to obey really specific laws? Aren't these redundant to section 2?
- end-user developers. This is kind of like being a user of any other language, there's no EULA, nothing to sign, you just write SOUL code, test and debug it with whatever tools (which may themselves have a EULA, but probably nothing heavy)
- device and host developers: These are the people writing DAWs, plugins, hardware that can run SOUL code, audio device drivers etc. These are professionals, and licensing is a normal part of life when you're doing this kind of work.
But that doesn't stop you as a developer from freely writing a 3D game that runs on it.
Same here. Think of it as a device driver. Ideally we'll open-source everything eventually, but anyone who's ever been involved in real-world commercial software development will understand that things aren't always quite that idyllic when you're building a business around it.
What secret sauce is this? What parts of https://github.com/soul-lang/SOUL are closed source?
Real answer: Mainly the JIT engine, and the very complex rewriting algorithms that turn multi-threaded soul code into a form that can actually be executed.
We're certainly keen to open-source everything when possible, just been advised by our lawyers not to do that yet. C'est la vie.
> What is the licensing/business model?
> Our intention is to make SOUL entirely free and unencumbered for developers to use. All our public source code is permissively (ISC) licensed. We’re currently keeping some of our secret sauce closed-source, but the EULA allows use of it freely to encourage its adoption in 3rd party hardware and software. Ultimately, we plan to commercialise SOUL by licensing back-end drivers and other IP for use by vendors who are building SOUL-compatible hardware products.