You also seem to think that decentralization would lead to less emphasis on local happenings. Why? If we moved away from a handful of services for the whole planet, wouldn't the logical next phase be a service or two per city? A decentralized web means knowing the guy who runs the server you're connecting to. A decentralizalized internet means configuring your router to peer with routers in the houses that you can see from your house. Relocalization seems like an obvious consequence of decentralizalization to me.
I have a slight different idea that is also very unpopular. I don't think you should be able to "broadcast" anonymously. When you say things that are illegal, like death threats and hate speech, you should be held responsible.
I think privacy is important, and I think you should be able to consume content anonymously, but I don't think you should be able to "post" anonymously.
I think we should stop running away from the fact that we are human. And we all have some quirky deep-rooted tendencies & desires that may not be socially viewed as moral.
Most of the times, these pseudo accounts provide amplification to that whispering inner voice harboring inside. Am certain we've all had experience with a peculiar post and go - "If it weren't for my boss following me back on my feeds I would have shared controversial view X, but hey am glad someone else said it."
Then proceed to share the screenshot of said view in a more private setting such as group channels/chats etc.
And make no mistake, what they mean in reality by the above is always the same, namely that "free speech" will mean you are freely allowed to repeat the talking points of the Party.
Allow politicians to censor? Well it will be available for for both Joe Biden as well as the next Republican president.
This is why one needs to be careful.
What does it mean to "remove the cancer before it decentralizes" in this context?
I think the important point is that most operators of nodes on a federated network are not in a position to benefit from this kind of garbage content, and have every reason (and the tools they need) to keep it away from their portion of the network.
Convince me. Your body has cancer, swift removal of it before it “decentralizes” is the only option.
I would be in favor of actual decentralization: Being able to broadcast 50km radius on the internet and improving communities, thriving local newspapers and localization of concerns. If you want to broadcast to state level, you must have education, journalism rigor, and standup to scrutiny, have to explain inconsistencies or your role is revoked.
“Decentralization”, the widely used term is a congregation of ill which cannot survive the scrutiny of public IMO.
Before you go touting for decentralization, ask yourself when was the last time you checked city news and county affairs? What happens at the National level has little effect on you locally. What Ted Cruz and AOC exchanged on Twitter has no bearing to your county. Internet gave everybody a centralized platform in the first place. Some good aspects (Wikipedia) and some horrifying consequences.