Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th...
by newacct583 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:47PM
(#25806255)
True enough, but the notion of the "Big Lie" itself, and the archetype for which it was named, were driven by the age of radio. The idea that social media is uniquely to blame here seems laughable to me.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th...
by dredmorbius on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:57PM
(#25806312)
The operational concept here is not the specific technology, but the relationship of that technology to others of its time.
Radio was the most engaging and direct medium of its age. Paired with magnetic tape recording, a speech or address could be simultaneously broadcast through multiple stations simmultaneously to an entire country (of at least European scale) at high fidelity on a few hours' notice. The allies marvelled at this ability, as their own capabilities were either restricted to single-studio live broadcasts, or vastly lower-fidelity recordings on wire or shellac disks.
Mobile-device-delivered, datacentre adtech-targeted, computational propaganda social media are now, as was radio in 1935, the pinacle of mass media. And similarly destructive.
But historically there is ample evidence that changes in media and communications have profound effects on societies. This is the premise of Elizabeth Eisenstein's The Printing Press as an Agent of Change (https://www.worldcat.org/title/printing-press-as-an-agent-of...), much of Hanna Arendt's work, that of the Frankfurt School.
Changes in writing, mathematics, printing, accounting, distribution and computation have had profound effects, often directly tied to periods of conflict: the Reformation, revolutions of 1776--1848 (widespread literacy), the Boer, Spanish-America, and First World wars (yellow journalism), the Second World War and cold wars of Jim Crow, the Red Scare, McCarthyism, and Father Coughlan, as well as the more recent Rwandan civil war (radio and audio recording, playback, and amplification).
Television, Internet, social media, and adtech delivered the "Twitter Revolutions" --- fine when they were in Egypt, Tunisia, and Ukraine, less so in Washington, DC.
The Big Lie cannot exist without mass media.