News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:30AM (#25802359)
Really not trying to pick a side here, but to pontificate on the Capitol events without even mentioning BLM, CHAZ, or any of the other civil unrest of the past year just seems unnecessarily biased. Almost all of that was organized, enabled, and inflamed by the exact same technologies.

Can anyone recommend a commentator on recent political events that isn’t deliberately biased? Or maybe the lack of such a person is merely a reflection of the ideas the author is trying to explain.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by msgilligan on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:33AM (#25802381)
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by bob33212 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:39AM (#25802429)
Taibbi openly says that Trump is incompetent and is taking advantage of his idiot supporters. I doubt that Trump supporters will consider him objective.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by TheAdamAndChe on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:14AM (#25802677)
Objectivity is a hard thing to find or determine. I consider myself somewhat objective on this issue. I have biases that run counter to most on this site(I lean right politically). I would consider Trump's incompetency to be an objective assessment when considering the massive amount of political blunders that he has made combined with the instability that he has triggered, or at least amplified. I'd say he also took advantage of his base as well, seeing how wildly different their assessment of the election is compared to the mainstream narrative.

If you disagree with me, then how would you measure or determine objectivity?

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by aklemm on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:53AM (#25802542)
But this is either true or it's not. If it is, then is there really much value in giving the "other side" equal time to say "Trump is very competent. Some would say the most competent. We are patriots, not idiots."
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:59AM (#25802578)
Where have we heard this binary logic before...

“You’re either with us or you’re with the terrorists.”

Yeah, let’s avoid that.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by aklemm on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:07AM (#25802637)
That is not the case. It's absurd to entertain all absurd ideas EQUALLY. You're missing the simple point here.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by letstalk7 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:37AM (#25802412)
Nobody is perfect and can have both good and bad work. I think Matt is a very gullible person who has bought into many conspiracy theories, some of which are Russian propaganda unfortunately
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by mistermann on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:01AM (#25802593)
Can you provide two or three of the very best examples of conspiracy theories Matt has bought into which are Russian propaganda?
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by mightybyte on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:37AM (#25802416)
I recently discovered Axios and have been very impressed with them so far. They are the closest I've seen to the type of news coverage I'm looking for. You can see a summary of their approach here: https://www.axios.com/about/ They stick to the facts and refrain from opinion. For example:

> 3. Every item will be written or produced to inform, analyze and explain. Axios will never be a platform for incitement or argument. We will never have an opinion section.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by aklemm on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:47AM (#25802503)
False equivalence is insidious and you would do well to reflect on that. More broadly, seeking an "unbiased" source is a bit of a fool's errand. The best you can do is seek "honest" sources, and the difference is massive.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:52AM (#25802538)
It’s not about equivalence. If you’re going to talk about a phenomenon, but leave out all the examples which make your “side” look bad, it just seems like straight bias. I’d prefer commentators leave their identity at the door and just explore the ideas and events themselves.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by newacct583 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:46AM (#25802493)
That seems like a very narrow definition of "bias". You demand not only that news be reported from your perspective but that other news be brought into the analysis before you are willing to listen to someone? Isn't that going to lead to the standard rehash of the BLM arguments instead of understanding of what happened among the Trump base?

I mean, how do you know you aren't just looking for an excuse? It's very upsetting to see people on "your side" doing stuff like attacking their own government. Are you absolutely sure you don't want to talk about left violence just to make yourself feel better?

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by pepperonipizza on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:40AM (#25802441)
I would recommend Sam Harris who criticizes harshly the Trump presidency and the Capitol events but who also had the most nuanced view of the BLM protests. I am not american but from the few commentators that I heard, it seems that he is a rarety in the US, and tries to have the less bias, even if he admits that he has one.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by krapp on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:48AM (#25802511)
Do you also feel that any discussion of BLM, CHAZ or left-wing violence must include a mention of violence by Trump supporters and the events of the Capitol in order to be unbiased?
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:50AM (#25802525)
The article is about technology leading to subcultures and echo chambers, subsequently leading to political actions. Leaving out some prominent examples of such (eg. last summer) just seems like bad writing to me.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by throw0101a on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:52AM (#25802539)
> Really not trying to pick a side here, but to pontificate on the Capitol events without even mentioning BLM, CHAZ, or any of the other civil unrest of the past year just seems unnecessarily biased.

I disagree.

BLM (e.g.) was about protesting against police brutality and racism. These are bad things in themselves. The fact that some of the protests turned violent is bad, but it was not their intent. In the course of 2020, how many millions of people marched in support of BLM movement? 15-26:

* https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/07/03/us/george-flo...

On a 'per capita' basis, what was the rate of violence for all of that activity? They were overwhelmingly peaceful:

* https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/10/16/this-summ...

Settle and Portland were the main two exceptions:

* https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1302643852545646594

Should we go into the violence instigated by the authorities against peaceful BLM protestors?

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump_photo_op_at_St._J...

Meanwhile the insurrection was about fighting the results of a valid election. The purpose of gathering was bad in itself (notwithstanding the delusion that the election was stolen) and the violence only added to the badness.

Lastly, major political leaders on both sides condemned the violence occurring at BLM:

* https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/09/01/fac...

* https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/01/07/fac...

Whereas some political leaders seemed to encourage aggression/violence at MAGAstock.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:55AM (#25802553)
The article and my comment are not about determining which was better or more justified. If you’re going to talk about social media leading to political action, but you leave out the single biggest political action of the last year, it’s hard to see that as anything but biased. At best, it’s deeply uninformed.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by neogodless on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:07AM (#25802635)
This kind of debate is likely to go nowhere. As outlined in the article, "reality" varies based on where you get what you consider "information."

One perspective is that centuries of systemic racism lead to Black Lives Matter protests, which were largely peaceful. Social media was a tool used to organize the protests, but did not lead to them.

One perspective is that decades of polarization has led to more extreme views further from an objective reality, which was further enabled and amplified by social media.

One of those realities argues that a massive conspiracy coordinated a secret interference with the election, so that Joe Biden won (but Republicans were allowed to gain quite a few seats in Congress.)

(Yes you can tell which reality I believe, and I can't quite figure out what reality is believed by those that support the invasion of the Capitol building. Perhaps someone can educate me.)

If you cannot agree on some of the above perspectives, then we aren't starting from a shared reality in which we can debate which comments are justified, which are biased, which are uninformed.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:12AM (#25802664)
Good thing it wasn’t a debate I asked for or mentioned whatsoever in my comment.

Clearly technology has affected politics in the last five years. That doesn’t mean it was the sole source of said political action.

This seems so tritely obvious to me I don’t know why it needs to be debated.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by loceng on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:00PM (#25803465)
You're gatekeeping here, interesting tactics you've developed to avoid having to counter valid arguments people put forward - along with claiming one of my replies to you was https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop - here, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25802608
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by neogodless on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:21AM (#25802725)
Your insistence that the necessity of Black Lives Matter protests is an equivalent phenomenon to the demagoguery of Donald Trump suggests that you do not believe there is systemic racism, that police unequally target and murder black people, that perhaps the election was actually stolen.

Using social media for disinformation campaigns is not equal to using social media to organize peaceful protests. The fact that 7% of those protests involved some kind of violence (which includes escalation by police, counter-protests, opportunistic looters and yes, perhaps some protestors who have plenty of reason for anger escalating to violence) does not take us to the conclusion that social media caused these protests. They were not based on a disinformation campaign. They were based on violent events that took place.

The belief that the election was stolen is not based on violent events taking place. The claims of evidence have all been hand-waving, such as misunderstanding the Blue wave due to a much higher percentage of mail-in ballots going to Democrats, which was caused by disinformation about mail-in ballot fraud.

Looks like we're debating which reality is based on facts, and it does need to be debated. If we had a shared reality, then perhaps there could be debate on what data points need included in an article exploring social media used in disinformation campaigns, but we do not share the same perspective on what is reality.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @02:37PM (#25804780)
Nowhere did I say they were equivalent. I said they were both manifestations of the same technological phenomenon.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by loceng on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:40AM (#25802449)
Don't you think it's a bit of a apples to oranges comparison, the raiding of the Capitol in an attempt to supposedly kill Mike Pence and Nancy Pelosi and disrupt the election certification - essentially lead by Trump - is different than mass, mostly peaceful protests - that were inflamed by the police?

Head on over to http://thedonald.win if you want to see the narratives they're believing, I check it out a few times a week, some comments from today: "Remember, it's not over til it's over," "Follow Trump's lead," etc - they don't understand, nor do they care to understand the election process - that there are poll watchers from any party that are present at the counting, they don't care to reason to understand they lost the election. They also have bought into a whole bunch of different conspiracy theories - they consider the Democrats as tyrants when it's Trump who's clearly attempting a coup to become a tyrant, suggesting maybe he'll even be President for 3 terms, etc; there's countless proof points relating to his behaviour that he's a tyrant wannabe.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:43AM (#25802468)
I don’t like Trump, didn’t vote for him, and want him to go back to the reality TV fantasyland from whence he came. But the “counternarrative”, displayed aptly by your comment here, strikes me as very hypocritical and not attempting to understand the Trump supporters’ narrative.
Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by loceng on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:03AM (#25802608)
You're assuming I don't understand the Trump supporters' narrative or where it comes from. There's plenty of proof points that that multiple people at the riot, infiltration of the Capitol, was planning more than just breaking shit and disrupting it; there are also anonymous FBI leaks, maybe they're not true - aside from the truth of people at the riot chanting "Hang Mike Pence" - that Mike Pence and Nancy Pelosi were targets to assassinate; https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2021-01-15/capitol-ri...

The cause is Trump et al's rhetoric of lies to rally his base, along with the problem with the political system and mainstream media - more specifically, the duopoly and how mainstream media conglomerates that perpetuate whatever industrial complex fed narratives for "their side" want, leading to only two core mainstream narratives for either the Democrats of Republicans.

Andrew Yang's main policy proposals would break apart the duopoly - expanding the narratives - and take power away from the current mainstream media companies:

- Freedom Dividend/UBI so people can think clearly with less stress,

- Ranked Choice Voting so people aren't wasting their vote and don't feel obligated to vote one of two incumbents,

- Democracy Dollars to wash out lobbyist money from industrial complexes/bad actors by a factor of 8:1 (via $100/year to every eligible voter to contribute to politician of choice),

- Journalism Dollars - same idea, each citizen can "vote" with money allocated to them for journalism - local or national to cover what they have interests in knowing about.

I think I'm forgetting another core policy - but also he wants to implement a government option for healthcare similar to "Medicare For All" - but not killing off private insurance due to the consequences of disrupting that industry immediately - will all strengthen Democracy because it's strengthening, taking care of, people.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by ceilingcorner on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:06AM (#25802624)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop

I can’t really respond to your comment if you just write a block or rambling text that has little connection to anything.

Re:The Insurrection Will Be Live Streamed: Notes Toward a Th... by loceng on Saturday January 16, 2021 @11:57AM (#25803451)
Hilarious way to cop out of responding to well explained points and reasoning, and if that's overwhelming to you - I guess you've never written or read an essay before. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have if anything doesn't make sense or confuses you. If you felt overwhelmed by everything I said, you could also just read it slower - if you even bothered to read it before responding. It sounds like you don't put much effort into honest conversation though. I added some spacing to my previous comment, hope that helps you be less overwhelmed.