I read about a few places doing it, but never any discussion on the following: are the houses well looked-after? And in particular, do they last?
Stereotypes and needs aside, isn't this a common issue with e.g. social housing? I guess perhaps because people who need this kind of help often have severe mental issues alongside.
I'm wondering about the sustainability of such approaches, rather than any kind of 'worthy/not worthy' arguments.
Also, how does one avoid creating ghettos? This is already an issue with low cost / subsidised housing, this sounds related.
The term of art for this is permanent supportive housing, which is handy if you want to look for more research and documentation. Seattle currently has 1,900 units (building more this year) and we have a 99%+ success rate at keeping people from re-entering homelessness. Our homeless problem is still awful, but that's because a) pandemic and b) we've been hanging around 10,000 people living on the streets, so the units are a pretty small percentage of what we need.
We're not putting all our housing in one place, which alleviates the stigma problem. There is not a ton of research on the effect supportive housing has on the crime rate nearby, but the research we do have suggests that it's a relatively minor problem that can be solved:
https://www.huduser.gov/publications/pdf/support_1.pdf (Denver, PDF) https://furmancenter.org/research/publication/the-impact-of-... (NYC)
“In terms of preventing homelessness, it’s pretty straightforward. It’s housing.” Preston Cochrane, former executive director of Shelter the Homeless.
There are still homeless in Utah, but the government priority is House them first then figure out why they became homeless after.