Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
by djrogers on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:48PM
(#25782252)
> This isn't about speech, it's copyright infringement.
Are they committing copyright infringement on Twitter?
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
by wittyreference on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:26PM
(#25784530)
Yes. The featured article notes that they were providing links on their Twitter account. Their quoted defense includes, to paraphrase, the account was /mostly/ discussing open access issues, it wasn’t /primarily/ for sharing pirated materials.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
by devwastaken on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:41PM
(#25783022)
They're an organization who's purpose is to commit copyright infringement. They don't have to be doing the infringement on twitter itself for twitter to reasonably suspend them. Again, they suspend them to prevent the platform being inevitably used for direct infringement or to be used as a guide on where/how to participate in the infringement.
Twitter may not be responsible for user content as per section 230 but it's also not a good idea as a company to step on the toes of intellectual property holders without good reason.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
by TeMPOraL on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:02PM
(#25783298)
Does Twitter automatically ban everyone using the hashtag #CanHasPDF? That's how scientific papers were spread before SciHub; what Elbakyan did was to move the copyright infringement off Twitter and to a dedicated service.
This isn't about speech, it's copyright infringement.