News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Apple Tells Lodsys Patent Troll to Back Off. Parent comment

Re:Apple Tells Lodsys Patent Troll to Back Off by brudgers on Monday May 23, 2011 @05:04PM (#2577582)
I don't see why Lodsys would take Apple to court given that both parties acknowledge that Apple and Lodsys have a licensing agreement for the technology. And the given the fact that Lodsys's claim is that Appstore developers do not have such a license their pursuit of individual developers makes sense.

As it stands now, if there is to be a suit between Apple and Lodsys, it will require Apple to act as plaintiff on behalf of its developers and that could potentially open up a huge can of worms for Apple because it could establish a higher level obligations and responsibilities between Apple and its developers. The fact that Apple responded via public letter rather than lawsuit is indicative of approaching this as a PR issue rather than a serious licensing issue - i.e. if it was clear that Apple's agreement with Lodsys allowed them to sub-license the technology to third parties they would have sought an injunction rather than issuing what boils down to essentially a press release.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Apple Tells Lodsys Patent Troll to Back Off by knshaum on Monday May 23, 2011 @06:34PM (#2577864)
Seems to me (IANAL) that Apple could sue on fraud or breach of contract: if Lodsys sold a license to Apple on the pretext that the developers were covered, and then later went after those developers as if they weren't covered, Apple could claim that Lodsys either misrepresented themselves, or failed to honor their side of the contract.
[ Parent | on HN ]