First of all, I applaud your proper use of the semicolon in a sentence. As someone who should probably step away from my computer a lot more though, I've got to disagree that "it's getting late" isn't a valid excuse, because I use it all the time and I mean it when I say it (i.e. it's 4am and I have to wake up for work in 6 hours).
I definitely wasn't intending to be snarky, my compliment was genuine. I don't see people use semicolons properly in sentences often, or much at all outside of coding. I meant no offense, I was giving you an honest compliment.
I really don't want to make it later for devs that give me so much. I'd be ok with: "Closed: Too little info" from a bot. I may decide to have another crack at it later when I have more time.
Edit: Btw, I'm using software for fee but, I'm also beta-testing for free. It's not just a one-way street: "I derive value from a free product so I should never complain." Is that really true?
I also invest time beta-testing (some times for products that make money on support or are open-core or are a gateway to paid software). Sure there are trolls, but there are also many users that make crappy reports that really want to help but just don't understand how (or why their report is a waste of everyone's time).
Assuming you're talking about a beta release for some open source software package, versus a full release, I don't think the distinction matters. You're using software that you got for free. It doesn't matter if it's beta- or release-quality. You aren't entitled to different/better support for it just because the developer chose to put out a version they admit isn't quite release-quality[0]. You're entitled to exactly the same amount of support as for a release version: none whatsoever.
> "I derive value from a free product so I should never complain."
I think that's framed the wrong way. I do agree that you should probably never complain about something you got for free; that smacks of undeserved entitlement. But constructive criticism and useful bug reports are (usually, depending on the maintainer) welcome.
[0] A developer might put out a beta version for a variety of reasons. One reason, yes, might be because they intend to jump on support requests faster in order to shape things up for a proper release. But another reason might be because they simply wanted to share with people as soon as possible.
There is a difference between not complaining vs raising issues constructively and valuing the maintainers time at least as much as you value your own time.
1. Create crappy bug report and move on quickly to get things done or:
2. Do not create a bug report and move on immediately, to get things done
I try to file whenever I can but when it's getting late and I want to go to bed I choose option 1 sometimes. Maybe I should choose option 2?
For example, take the Nextcloud bug filing template on GitHub [0]. It's quite a long read but sure, worth the effort for free software I agree (Nextcloud is my favorite project, my life is in there, on my server)! However, I may not know exactly where these things are:
They also want config.php, contents of `sudo -u www-data php occ app:list`, ask you to do this: Also all versions: Moreover, I'm quite afraid to put my domain names or even more sensitive info onto a public website if I just copy and paste. All I'm saying is that a big button that generates everything a dev needs with sensitive stuff redacted (which should be doable here and yes maybe I should make a PR for that) will make the experience a lot nicer for the reporter and the dev.As said, the Geyser MC project [1] can do exactly this and to me it is a game changer, the whole process was fast and pleasant and it was easy to test the automated builds they made in the branch based on my issue and report back in context on GitHub. Pasting the JSON their report feature generates into their Discord channel together with your question and their ability to just !docs/something point you to relevant docs with a small command feels like magic. I found the whole process inspirational.
I love all FOSS devs. You are my heroes.
[0]: https://github.com/nextcloud/server/issues/new?assignees=&la...
[1] https://github.com/GeyserMC/Geyser