News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by emilfihlman on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:05AM (#25746257)
Not true, you can have a donation link on your page and projects just fine.

t. another Finn

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by Hamuko on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:08AM (#25746298)
How is that compatible with Rahankeräyslaki, which explicitly forbids soliciting money from the general public without a permit?
Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by emilfihlman on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:22AM (#25746445)
The iirc court of appeals has confirmed that merely having a donation link is okay.

So you might legally be somewhat limited in what you can write there (like "donate to me SO THAT I can write more code YOU enjoy"), but saying

"Support me / donate to me / Support my work through Ko-Fi"

is entirely fine.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by Ndymium on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:32AM (#25749154)
Can you link a court case to support this argument? I was once in an association (ry) and we tried finding out if we could have a donation link on our website and we were told it is not allowed. Even just having a bank account number was not allowed. The only way to receive a donation would have been for a person to ask us proactively and then we could tell _that person only_ our bank account number.

I run a free web service where some users have asked me to set up a donation system but AFAIK it is illegal so I haven't done it. Instead I set up a company and will sell premium accounts with some borderline useless but actual feature that normal accounts don't have, so that it's no longer a donation.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by Hamuko on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:34AM (#25746601)
"Donate to me" sounds like a pretty explicit appeal to give money, so I would personally steer away from that to not get in trouble with the law ("rahankeräyksellä [tarkoitetaan] toimintaa, jossa yleisöön vetoamalla kerätään vastikkeetta rahaa" & "yleisöön vetoamisella [tarkoitetaan] suullisesti, kirjallisesti tai muulla tavoin ilmaistua pyyntöä tai kehotusta antaa rahaa keräykseen").

AFAIK, just adding your PayPal details or bank account number to your website would be okay because you would not be making any sort of an appeal.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by emilfihlman on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:29AM (#25747321)
"Lahjoitukset minulle voi osoittaa tämän linkin kautta"

"Minua voi tukea tämän linkin kautta"

"Lahjoita minulle tämän linkin kautta"

All are acceptable.

And since "lahjoita" is entirely equal to "support" then also

"Tue minua tämän linkin kautta" is entirely fine.

Of course the Finnish justice system is known for being unjust and arbitrary in many cases so your mileage may vary.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by hpeinar on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:57AM (#25749654)
Very interesting read as an Estonian. Apart from being legal, we even have a special field on our income declaration form (which we fill every year) that is specifically for money earned through ways like that. If I recalled correctly it's under "Income received abroad -> Salary and other remuneration".

I also run a donation based site (which also has ads) and I declare both of these on the form and pay my share of taxes from it. But it is then fully legal money and I can do whatever I like with it from government perspective.

I don't speak any Finnish at all, but if the wording is so important, wouldn't it work if you ask the money to pay for the services cost instead? Not as a donation to yourself. Servers cost, your time costs etc. Could all be counted as an upkeep of the project.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by hopia on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:04PM (#25751744)
You have to remember that we're talking about a country whose police considered Wikipedia to be fundraising money illegally with their global donations based system, due to Finnish laws: https://yle.fi/uutiset/3-7144745

I don't think it's a worthwhile risk to take for Finnish open source developers to accept donations and think it won't be considered illegal by the authorities.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by u678u on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:37AM (#25746649)
If you say something like "Dont worry its not illegal you'll be fine" you really need a link to some proof. :)
Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by emilfihlman on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:27AM (#25747280)
https://is.fi/taloussanomat/art-2000001494059.html

https://rescue.fi/article.php/20070131_effi

It was only district court but the prosecutor did not seek the court of appeals (which they legally have to do if there's a chance their view might succeed), leaving the precedent.

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by Ndymium on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:39AM (#25749293)
Note that Effi no longer lists the mentioned donation details on their website[1] and their verbiage is much more limited now so I don't know how much they themselves count on the court case. I would like to see the actual court case transcripts but they were not linked in the articles, shame.

[1] https://effi.org/yhdistys/lahjoitukset/

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:46AM (#25747548)
So, just wondering - how important is precedent normally in Finnish Law?
Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by d33 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:30AM (#25746541)
Not a lawyer, but perhaps this perspective would work in Finland?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10863939

Re:I received my first donation on my open-source side project by Hamuko on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:35AM (#25746621)
Selling software should be okay, but I imagine that's a significant burden to a lot of open-source developers who are not aiming to make it a job.