News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The University Has No Clothes by wyclif on Sunday May 22, 2011 @11:57AM (#2573505)
I find most of what you say here fairly uncontroversial, but this raised eyebrows a bit:

This will eventually translate to higher social status for a degree (as used to be the case) and cheaper prices (and so less debt necessary).

That seems to violate a fundamental law of economics to me: If the demand for a good increases relative to the supply, the price will increase, which will reduce demand. If the supply of the product increases then the price will fall, encouraging more people to buy the product. Prices adjust up and down until the demand matches supply. So cheaper prices for degrees, by allowing more students to enroll, would seem to me to decrease status, not increase it.

Re:The University Has No Clothes by nagrom on Sunday May 22, 2011 @12:21PM (#2573579)
Yes and no. If fewer people have degrees, the status will go up. If more people don't even consider them, demand also goes down and hence prices. So status and cost can both drop until it becomes cheap enough that everyone gets a degree as a matter of course. And then the cycle starts again...
Re:The University Has No Clothes by hnhg on Sunday May 22, 2011 @02:56PM (#2573937)
Just like any luxury good, they'll restrict the supply while keeping the price high. Simply because many people don't even consider Prada shoes as an option hasn't made them any cheaper.
Re:The University Has No Clothes by nagrom on Sunday May 22, 2011 @06:03PM (#2574352)
We're not considering only luxury goods though. There'll always be other suppliers of shoes willing to cut their prices to match demands, just like other colleges will cut their prices to match a spectrum of demand.

I think the point is that a Harvard degree will remain viewed as worth more than a Podunk College degree, regardless of the demand because the supply is naturally self-limiting. However, the cost of Podunk College will oscillate with the demand/supply.

Re:The University Has No Clothes by quanticle on Sunday May 22, 2011 @04:55PM (#2574203)
If the demand for a good increases relative to the supply, the price will increase, which will reduce demand.

That only applies for normal goods. For luxury goods, an increase in price acts as a signal indicating increased quality. These goods (and I count a college diploma as one) act as status symbols, indicating the superior wealth and social status of their possessors. In this case, an increase in price only serves to amplify the signaling function of these goods, and can engender increased quantity demanded.

In other words, the demand curve for a college education is non-linear. On at least some segment of the curve, quantity demanded increases as price increases. We are in one of those segments right now.