https://www.vox.com/2019/10/14/20910510/microsoft-government...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
I don't know how much of it is lip-service, but webkit.org talks about using webkit on non-Apple platforms, and webkit-gtk gets discussed on their mailing list.
It feels to me like a truly collaborative open-source project, in a way that's unlike most of what Apple does. Again, I don't know how much of this is an aberration, but I've always been impressed with the whole thing.
Here’s the relevant snippet from the Pylance language server’s T&Cs
> INSTALLATION AND USE RIGHTS. a) General. You may install and use any number of copies of the software only with Microsoft Visual Studio, Visual Studio for Mac, Visual Studio Code, Azure DevOps, Team Foundation Server, and successor Microsoft products and services (collectively, the “Visual Studio Products and Services”) to develop and test your applications. b) Third Party Components. The software may include third party components with separate legal notices or governed by other agreements, as may be described in the ThirdPartyNotices file(s) accompanying the software.
Ref: https://github.com/microsoft/pylance-release/issues/4#issuec...
———
That they would forbid their holy language server implementation from integrating with other editors exposes the perfidy at the heart of their LSP advocacy.
If they want to keep the extension proprietary and charge for the language server, that’s fine! But allow people to use it with whichever editor instead of forbidding it through the license. It’s wholly malicious to use a language server implementation to extend control to the editor landscape. This is exactly the kind of nonsense that got them in trouble in the 90s, in the first place.
Seems like Microsoft is back to pissing in the public pool.
I agree with you that it's pretty crap, and it leaves a bad taste in my mouth, but I'm willing to cut them some slack because of how great lsp is.
Seriously, the pushing of this makes up for a lot of nonsense, especially as its a standard which means that if it's successful, Microsoft will be mostly forced to abide by that standard within their products.
I don't want to say MS is good, proprietary software is good, etc. But we're approaching the 4th decade of Free Software, and people should know better than tangling their free software with megacorp offering. I shed no tears.
https://cdn0.tnwcdn.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/files/2015/04...
Furthermore, there are programmers using other languages where the extensions are already open source, so it would be viable for some users from the start.
I'm also reminded of how some companies built their business on open source servers only for Amazon to create a competing service with their code. This makes me more sympathetic to the partial open source business model.
I personally feel lucky that unlike for categories like web search, social networking or mobile messaging, the IDE market features some reasonably-priced paid alternatives of extremely high quality.
But many people - including some truly outstanding developers - will continue to use VSCode because they believe that free as in free beer is always better, no matter what. There may be privacy violations, a desecration of FOSS ideals, shady business practices - you name it - and they will continue to use it as long as it’s free and the negative externalities are not too bad. I wouldn’t agree, but I do empathize.
Vscode kinda brought me back towards MS, or at least closer to them. Once I'd started using it on Linux (Kubuntu) then trying Win10 again was less of a leap.
I've not bought in to the New Friendlier Microsoft, but the hope was growing.
How so? language server is a standard.
But if MS wants to create a VS Code specific language server, just because they are using LSP doesn’t mean they should be required to support it on other IDEs as well.
anyone can implement an LSP server and the IDE (or editor) will understand it because the protocol is an open standars, it doesnt't mean that the implementation should be open or support any combination of HW/SW platform
there is plenty of proprietary software using open and standard protocols
one example: HTML
is Slack open source?
can I use Slack client with other chat protocols?
I have yet to get a good response to how to make money in a world where everything is open source.
Because I notice on Edge, if I visit the chrome store, it gives me an option to install extensions from there.
It is like using two different messengers then
Will Linus pay for your internet bill if you use Linux on your router?
Which parts are closed-source?
It’s like complaining that Google won’t open source, or support, the Google Cast feature in Firefox or Edge.
It’s worse because a non MS entity can always put in the effort to create a Python language server and have that used across IDEs that support the LSP, but the Google Cast protocol is proprietary itself and one cannot even create their own implementation without severe reverse engineering.
Actually, in this specific case, it really hurts, because Microsoft had been the one pushing for LSP to enable reusability and interoperability. You can’t take M*N to M+N if every editor refuses to let their implementation be used by anyone else. Honestly, Microsoft, what are you getting from taking a bunch of open source code and making the good bits proprietary, and then sabotaging your own messaging around standards that you want adopted? Because I can’t see any reason why you have to do this :/