News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @09:59AM (#25715191)
Just a random idea: perhaps we should extend democracy to the spreading of information. I.e. you can spread information but only if the majority of people agree with it. (A post is evaluated/moderated by a small group, then a bigger group, etc., until perhaps it reaches the entire population). Moderation is not limited to groups, so echo chambers would not have a chance.

EDIT: minorities still have a chance in two ways: (1) they can have discussion groups which can be large but still limited (2) the majority will have some tolerance and thus will only suppress the ideas of minorities if they find them objectionable.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by rleigh on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:18AM (#25715420)
That would be a terrible idea.

In times gone by, that would have prevented people spreading information about the world being a sphere and orbiting the sun. The flat earthers and proponents of the earth being the centre of the universe would have suppressed Copernicus' and Kepler's discoveries of heliocentrism and elliptical orbits.

New ideas displace old ideas all the time, and that displacement can only occur if there is both a rational evidence-based reason for displacing it and there is the opportunity to do so. To suppress an idea is to remove opportunity for discussion and to entrench the established viewpoint irrespective of its merits. It's the very antithesis of modern liberal thought.

Suppression of ideas also conversely prevents the objective discussion of bad ideas and dismissing them. Too much conversation in the present days is not grounded in objectivity, and this lets bad ideas fester. Open and fair minded discussion is a basic requirement for living in a free society.

There is a disturbing tendency to wish to suppress discussion of "sensitive" or "controversial" topics in recent years. That is a path which will lead to tyranny. Because it boils down to other people telling us what we are and are not allowed to say, think and do. This would not be a fair or free society.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:29AM (#25715557)
I believe that what I'm suggesting is more like how spreading of information worked in the old days (increasingly bigger groups have to approve of the information). The problem is that today we have social media and false information can spread instantly to an entire population. This needs a new approach, because it creates problems like extreme polarization.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by rleigh on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:59AM (#25715947)
I still think this is horribly wrong.

Having groups "approve" information means having gatekeepers who wield a lot of power. Censors. Who is to ensure that they exercise that power both fairly and accurately? It opens a huge can of worms. It might seem to make sense for "obviously" black and white issues. But most are not so clear cut, and choosing a "correct" side is impossible.

"False information" isn't countered by suppression. It's countered with facts and open discussion.

I absolutely agree that the current state of affairs with social media is problematic. That's the reason I quit all of them and deleted my accounts permanently. But what you're advocating still amounts to censorship and a failure to treat individuals as capable of evidence-based rational thought, and is still the antithesis of what we want in an open and free society.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @12:14PM (#25716815)
> Having groups "approve" information means having gatekeepers who wield a lot of power.

You can choose the moderators at random. This would be somewhat akin to the idea of sortition:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by jokethrowaway on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:05AM (#25715270)
I think we need to clear this misconception that democracy is good. It may be the least evil form of managing societies we attempted until now, but it's in no way good.

Democracy is violently (under threat or by direct action) imposing the will of majority on a minority.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by jfengel on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:20AM (#25715441)
All modern democracies have tools in place to protect minorities. It's never as simple as a bare majority imposing its will.

Ironically, it leads to the exact opposite, where certain minorities express disproportionate power. For example, the rules always favor the status quo, so a minority in power can retain power, and subvert even largish majorities from passing rules they favor.

Democracy may well be the least worst form of government, but it's even worse than I think most people give it credit for. The assumption is that at least half the people are happy with at least half of the results, and it doesn't even guarantee that much.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by jokethrowaway on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:52PM (#25720381)
In a purely democratic event, the majority will impose its will on the rest of the population (eg. think about Brexit).

I think you're conflating democracy in general with social democracies.

Social democracies are much more complicated - but they have a corruptible government which pretty much guarantees that the richest minority will be able to get laws that appear to satisfy everyone while benefiting them.

A clear example is progressive taxation - it sounds fair to a laymen. Then you see that all the rich people use tax loopholes to pay close to zero while middle class people struggle to get rich because of the extra tax hurdle.

I think the situation is slightly better in Switzerland because it's a semi-direct democracy and the greater use of referendums gives the population a greater chance to shape their society.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:16AM (#25715391)
I totally agree with this. But I believe we can only find something better by changing democracy's rules in an incremental manner.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by jokethrowaway on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:56PM (#25720431)
I believe we will just crash eventually, learn a lesson and try something else. Or we will all die before that. Or we will all get unlimited energy, defeat aging and become gods.

The reason I think this is because of the USA: the USA started as a minarchy, it became very rich (probably because of it) and then slowly became the largest, fattest government ever.

Similarly, tons of smaller governments in EU keep growing larger and more inefficient instead of cutting down and freeing the economy.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by sanp on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:20AM (#25715442)
Or, depending on how you implement it l, imposing the will of the minority (red state populations) on a majority
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by spzb on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:03AM (#25715226)
That seems like it would just silence minority voices.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by roflc0ptic on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:05AM (#25715257)
Right. How would anyone argue for the repeal of popular, unjust laws? Having free speech tied to current moral fashions seems disastrous.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:14AM (#25715371)
> Having free speech tied to current moral fashions seems disastrous.

Well, the entire point is that free speech is not the same as broadcasting rights. You can still have free speech. You just don't get a "free platform".

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:07AM (#25715288)
Not if the majority would allow them.

Minorities can still have discussion groups. It's just that their ideas never achieve mass broadcasting if the majority finds those ideas objectionable.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by rleigh on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:05AM (#25715997)
You are advocating censorship of "objectionable" views. Who is to judge what is and what is not "objectionable" and what can and cannot be spoken in public? This is absolutely wrong.

To do this is to revisit some of the worst days of the 20th century. I am astonished that views like this are getting more popular. Have we learned nothing from history?

In all seriousness, what do you think will be the eventual outcome when you marginalise people this way? Don't just reply to me here. Go and do some real reading.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by rhexs on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:21AM (#25715459)
I’m amazed how a large portion of the Internet can hold two diametrically opposed ideas in their heads like this as the same time. Really bodes well for the next decade.

“You still have freedom of speech, but can only talk about subjects I approve of”.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:25AM (#25715508)
> “You still have freedom of speech, but can only talk about subjects I approve of”.

No, it is:

“You still have freedom of speech, but not a free platform”.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by pjc50 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:33AM (#25715619)
I'm old enough to remember when the government made it illegal to mention homosexuality in schools. And when it was illegal for a particular elected MP to speak on television.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by amelius on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:57AM (#25715915)
> I'm old enough to remember when the government made it illegal to mention homosexuality in schools.

Even today, there are teachers who spout that homosexuality is somehow a bad thing.

Controversial topics will take time to reach mainstream agreement, no matter how you shape the spread of information. The question is how to do it in a way such that society is not disrupted by a strong opinion.

Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by pjc50 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:52AM (#25716565)
Not quite sure what your point is - section 28 made it illegal to "promote" homosexuality, precisely to prevent it achieving mainstream acceptance. It was effectively illegal to say that it wasn't bad to be gay.
Re:Trump Twitter ban 'raises regulation questions' – UK govt... by gwbas1c on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:32AM (#25715602)
In the abstract, that's how information spreads. Just look at conventional media: A small group judges something or someone newsworthy, and then the other outlets repeat it. Or, look at the old email chains that were popular before social media.

But, more importantly, people like to spread what they want to believe, even if it's not true. Trump really played into that: He started by promoting the birther theory, which people who didn't like Obama chose to believe. Finally, he promoted the theory that there was widespread election fraud, even though it was thoroughly disproven. Again, people chose to believe Trump's lie even though it was thoroughly disproven.

IMO, we need to strengthen our slander laws, and have a higher "burden of truth" on our media companies. Specifically, if a media company covers provenly false information in a way that implies it is, or could be, true, that media company needs to be prosecuted for slander, or worse.

But, more importantly, we need to prosecute elected officials who contradict fact; and ban candidates who brazenly contradict established fact.