Him: I would much rather we have A so that we didn't need B
You: Or, we could have this thing B
I know I'm on the record as saying that rationality, which is to say empirical philosophy, is incomplete. Let me clarify that by saying that it isn't the same thing as rejecting it outright anymore than rejecting Newtonian mechanics outright is the same thing as admitting it is incomplete.
That anyone can believe that simply "letting them be wrong on the internet" is a viable course of action at this point is utterly baffling.
I sincerely hope there is an alternative to totalitarian control of public discourse, but I am becoming increasingly worried that there is not.
Why Twitter posts if not punishment of children? Are children that unimportant to this society?
Incidentally I absolutely love it when conservatives advocate for more government, whatever happened to the market is perfect let it decide the winners and losers.
Or they can choose to moderate and/or editorialize the content they host and the conversations that happen on their platform AND be held responsible for it.
I'm not saying it is bad that a company moderates their platform, please do it! But don't pretend everyone can voice their view on their platform and be clear and forward about what you are doing.
The government is one small part of the State (as an organization). I should have probably said "Let the legislative and judiciary powers of the State handle it".
>whatever happened to the market is perfect let it decide the winners and losers
This is already happening: some people, disillusioned by the service Twitter provides, are moving to Parlor, for example.
In the end Twitter have the power to ban Trump from their platform the same way a bar owner can ban people who they don’t like. Just because everyone thinks and feels Twitter is a public forum does not make it one; it is private property like virtually everything on the Internet.
Humans are instinctively divisive. Our species relied heavily on small communities working together and excluding other communities throughout our entire human history. Tribalism is engrained in our nature as a direct effect of our evolution. It would take another thousand years to unlearn that. Social media is a global tool, and therefore social media has just brought out the worst in humans on a global level, but it hasn't created that intrinsic tribal instinct in us to begin with. Humans are just not meant to cooperate on such a large scale. We'd all be much better off (aka leaving more harmonious) if we'd live in smaller communities and would revert a lot of what globalisation has given us.
"Warning: This site contains highly speculative & offensive gossip and might cause anxiety, stress, unattainable standards and lowered self-esteem. Information on this site should not be considered credible, and might cause radicalization and extremism."
Jesus Christ man. You think you can educate the population to the point they don’t believe conspiracies and “fake news”?
I mean, how many anti-vaxers are postgraduates?
You’re absolutely nuts if you think you can “fix” the human condition through education.
As for your very specific example, the arguments post-graduate anti-vaxxers will make are going to be different than people who're mislead and aggravated by 600-word articles or even shorter chain messages spreading bullshit. The vaccine to this bullshit is education, believe it or not.
Decentralization, encryption and anonymity is the only way to deal with this.
Aether is a good first draft: multi part app with a back end that can live on a single board computer in your closet and costs $4 to run for a year and a front end that you can use on your phone.
Be prepared that it's a distributed system, it takes a while for posts to show up when you first run it.
Could we have been more diligent in educating people on ways of debating and understanding, could we have built a society that is not obsessed with perfection and winning?
If it wasn't Twitter, Facebook, Google etc. it would simply be something else in their place who had to perform the job of the gatekeeper. We were on course to enabling global communication at an unprecedented scale regardless of these companies establishing themselves, it wasn't news that we'd get here. Did we just discount the discourse on this that it's 'suddenly' a concern?