News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:36PM (#25703090)
The thing that has surprised me the most with the current crypto-craze is the number of people that I consider generally quite rational/thoughtful who could nonetheless not resist the temptation to jump onto the bandwagon. I'm left thinking that they must know what they're doing and that they simply enjoy the thrill of a game of musical chairs.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:50PM (#25703242)
Most situations aren’t black and white. Crypto (in particular Bitcoin) is an investment asset. Every asset comes with risks. The way to adjust for the risk is to have the right proportion of your investment into the asset. It’s the same for gold, equity or any other investment instrument.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by kgwgk on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#25703610)
The key is diversification! You put part of your fortune in bitcoin, part in ethereum, part in dogecoin, part in beanie babies, part in baseball cards, part in fine wines, part in vintage comic books, part in tulips...
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:34PM (#25709295)
Let’s try it your way. You can put 1% of your fortune in all those assets you mentioned. Hopefully, you will see the point in trying to make about asset allocation.

On a side note, sarcasm and snark don’t aid better understanding in a discussion. I appreciate your point but it would be better made being direct.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:26PM (#25704353)
Durability of tulips is suspect. And some bitcoin miners are stealing electricity in the third world. So maybe double down on the surer bets like Dogecoin.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by ada1981 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:30PM (#25705642)
Folks grandfathered into the Tesla supercharger network can set up a sweet trunk mining rig...
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:14PM (#25703526)
If there were no investor protections then anyone following this “just put a bit into different things” strategy would get hosed by scams. It only works because investment laws keep out most grifters from raising funds.

Bitcoin isn’t a typical investment instrument in that sense, so I’m not sure applying the same heuristic works.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:56PM (#25706520)
Your comment actually embodies one of the most ironic parts of this whole fiasco: Bitcoin, which is purported as the anti-fed/anti-government savior of the future world economy (maybe I'm exaggerating a bit, but I don't think I'm too far off the mark), is ultimately going to serve as one of the best examples of exactly "why" we have regulation and oversight in the first place.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:31PM (#25707454)
Kgwgk put it better than me I think, with their examples of diversification across bad asset classes.

Also a thought occurs. Many people reading this will think “but these cynics are mistaken. Those who invested in bitcoin have seen massive returns”.

Not so. The paper value of bitcoin is up, but unlike a stock, you don’t own anything. You need someone to actually buy the bitcoin in order to gain value.

Whereas as long as a company has profits, there’s a floor on things. The shares will have real use value so the price can’t fall too low.

Meaning buy bitcoin at $200, own now at $41,000. Only has value if you sell. If everyone tries to sell and no one is buying there’s no floor, none.

Whereas bought Apple at $20, own at $132. The price could fall, but there’s some kind of floor below which it could not fall based on current profits and dividends, and that floor is almost certainly above $32.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by elif on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:20PM (#25706162)
If you are characterizing crypto as irrational or a thoughtless temptation, I have to imagine you are comparing it to traditional investments like stocks, bonds, etc. Maybe you are right there, maybe you aren't. Personally, I've done terrible at stocks and wonderful at crypto, so i disagree due to experiential knowledge.

If you are comparing crypto to USD savings, it is quite obvious from a 10 year chart which one is irrational. Even if you completely write off the growth of crypto entirely, it is quite easy to beat negative value growth.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:39PM (#25707565)
> Personally, I've done terrible at stocks and wonderful at crypto, so i disagree due to experiential knowledge.

That basically means that you were early to the party for crypto, and made some bad decisions with stocks (which have yielded some 5% pa in real terms for many decades).

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:21PM (#25706708)
A few thoughts:

1. It's not "easy" to beat negative value growth at baseline. EG: a risky investment that loses your entire investment is much worse.

2. If this was year 1999, could you have written exactly the same about .COM stocks shortly before they crashed and burned? If not, what is the thing you see about Crypto that makes that value feel real vs bubbly?

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by elif on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:27PM (#25707400)
Don't get me wrong, crypto is incredibly bubbly. It is physically stressful to keep up with at times.

The bubbles are observable, though, and we have over a decade of time elapsed in order to show that in addition to bubbles (and full corrections!) on that basis of hype, there is an overall growth trend that results from the mathematical scarcity which .com shares lack.

As far as comparison to a dotcom, they had to make payroll, nurture a profitable market, predict changes, outpace rivals etc. Many ways to suffer catastrophic death in that equation. whereas a bitcoin has no such requirement. All it has to do is not inflate too bad.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:41PM (#25707606)
> All it has to do is not inflate too bad.

So, question: All the other coins, which are also strictly limited mathematically, they are also good long term investments, since they won't inflate too bad? They do all have "an overall growth trend that results from the mathematical scarcity", do they?

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by elif on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:01PM (#25707854)
You can't essentialize "all the other coins" as if bitcoin is just one. Coins which do not have first mover, publicity, hash power, market cap, and capital inflow rate on their side like bitcoin does will behave entirely differently, and must justify themselves existentially.

Why bitcoin? because dollars suck. Why altcoin? is a legitimate question, but bitcoin has flaws. Personally I like to believe that the 'flip' will occur at some point to ethereum due to its technical and monetary superiority, but I think its more likely that due to the network effect, bitcoin will keep its crown as main coin.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:52PM (#25707745)
// All it has to do is not inflate too bad.

Just for fun, I want to share what I conceive as an easy disaster scenario for crypto.

Let's be clear on one thing - the dollar price of BTC is driven by supply and demand. To the extent that more and more people want to buy it, while the available supply for sale is limited, the price goes up.

Let's be soberly clear that the there's another side of the coin - IF there was a case where there were relatively few buyers compared to the supply for sale, the price tumbles.

Then to conceive a disaster scenario we just need to imagine a situation where this happens: where people are selling and there's nobody to buy.

I can easily conceive such a scenario.

Let's first think about who's driving the buying. I guess there are now institutional players but there's also a lot of "wow I heard people made money in BTC so I am going to convince my wife to let me buy some instead of fixing our roof" people. To the extent that such people enter the market, they drive the price up.

At some point, such people will be tapped out of dollars, and the world will be tapped out of such people. In other words, every dollar that someone was going to aggressively/recklessly (from their own position) put into BTC, is already in BTC.

Let's imagine an idealized scenario where no new dollars are going into BTC because of the above, and no dollars are being taken out (because people are HODLing) and ignore mining for this. In this scenario, the price gets "stuck" at whatever level the last trade happened.

Now the thing about people who invest money they can't afford, they very quickly need it. The guy's wife says "the roof has been leaking for 3 months now and you aren't making money in BTC, sell it and fix the roof."

So the guy goes to sell - but there's nobody to sell it to. There's no people sitting on the sidelines because as mentioned above, everyone's already in. So he has to drop the price lower and lower until someone buys it.

Now other people see that the price has moved down. So the prior "greater fool" things "wait, I cashed out my 401k because BTC is going up, but it just sat flat for 3 months and now moved down and I am losing money, OH SH*T, BAIL (or, his wife makes him have this "realization"). So that drops the price even more.

Now there are other people who are looking at this downward movement and going "wait a minute, 3 months ago I felt like I was going to be able to buy an island with my BTC holdings, but now it's starting to look like I can only buy a condo. I better cash some out just in case it slides more because my loss aversion is kicking in and I was bullish before, but now I am experiencing the feeling of "not as rich as I once felt" and it's messing with me.

But this guy doesn't have that many willing people to sell to either, so it keeps sliding and snowballing down.

This is obviously an idealized scenario but you can hopefully see the forces that would cause any bubble to unravel. Once the supply of naive inbound dollars dries out (as it inevitably must), the people who invested last because they were sure it was going to be easy money, get nervous, sell, price slides, that unravels more people who now have something to lose whereas before they felt invulnerable, etc etc all the way down.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by elif on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:03PM (#25707873)
I think you should be concerned when your reasoning quickly slips into narrative.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:30PM (#25708196)
Sure? It was an illustration of supply and demand as I envision them operating as a bubble pops. I think narration is a good way to convey it. Do you follow it but disagree that it's a possible outcome, or something else?
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by pontifier on Sunday January 10, 2021 @12:24AM (#25710667)
There's a sucker born every minute
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by AznHisoka on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:48PM (#25703214)
Putting money into Bitcoin is a rational decision because others are irrational and bidding it up.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by netrus on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:16PM (#25704257)
Isn't "putting money into Bitcoin" the same thing as "bidding it up"? Both actions have the same level of rationality, whatever that might be.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:23PM (#25704328)
While true there are other factors keeping some money out. Like those concerned with the environmental impact of the electricity generation and short lived ASICs.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:27PM (#25706763)
>> Putting money into Bitcoin is a rational decision because others are irrational and bidding it up.

It all comes down to: investing is great if you buy low and sell high.

Let's just say this - if you aren't able to imagine the scenario under which your BTC (or any investment) crashes down to near zero, you're just not thinking well enough.

I can conjure up a disaster scenario just standing right now in my kitchen, and I don't even own crypto.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:26PM (#25709154)
You are right, one should conjure up a disaster scenario. So, here’s a question - if you had 100$, what number between 1-100 would you put as investment into Bitcoin? You can’t use any number outside the range provided.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:31PM (#25709246)
It's kinda a weird question. If I only had $100, none of it would go into BTC.

Personally I am not invested in BTC at all because I have a pretty thorough "short thesis" on it (you can see a bit of it in my comments in this thread.)

I wouldn't be opposed to betting some play amounts on it (I'd bet short, however) - same as money that I had "invested" in prediction markets - not investments in the "I am building my wealth this way" kind of sense.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:41PM (#25709412)
It was hard question and intentionally so. I allowed you to lie within your boundaries and yet you chose to not answer. You picked zero despite me explicitly stating the only number you could pick was between 1-100$.

If you go outside the framework of a thought experiment, to play safe - we can’t move a discussion forward. So pick a number based on the hypothetical scenario you mentioned. That’s the entire point of a thought experiment, to test boundaries.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:45PM (#25709476)
Not sure I follow but I am intrigued. OK well given that the least I can bet is $1, I will bet $1.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#25709693)
Thanks for your answer. Since you chose $1 since it is the least bet, I would like to increase your options. You can now choose any real value between 0.01$ to 100$. You are free to change your answer of $1 to anything you'd like.

You do not need to answer the question. The point I'm trying to make is that as an investor you can invest in an asset class even if you can imagine an Armageddon (crash to zero for BTC) scenario. You just have to allocate the right proportion towards the asset incorporate the volatility. Remember, the same scenario could also happen for any investment asset. The lesser the likelihood of the Armageddons the higher the allocation. You can simply reduce your asset allocation to what you perceive as the likelihood of the Armageddon scenario. I can tell you for sure that none of us can predict a scenario with a 100% probability. Given that, an allocation of 1$ or even 0.01-0.99$ is not a bad idea.

Oh, as far as BTC getting to zero - I can't imagine how that can happen without every government on the planet banning it [0]. Currently, you have governments in well developed economies consider it as an ordinary tangible asset [1] and even trading them from exchanges (9th largest in Europe) [2]!

[0] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-feds-balance-sheet-the-...

[1] https://www.winheller.com/en/banking-finance-and-insurance-l...

[2] https://www.bsdex.de/en/

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:28PM (#25710029)
This sounds like a weird way to invest. According to this logic I should invest $.01 in BTC and then to borrow from a funny commenter in this thread, $.01 in Dodgecoin, $.01 in Ether, $.01 in baseball cards, $.01 in wine, $.01 in beanie babies, etc etc etc etc etc - that basically any investment that exists deserves my dollars.

I disagree. There's plenty of stuff one "could" invest in and very few one "should."

I look at it on expected value basis and then, risk adjusted. Because I have a short case on BTC, I expect any investment in it to have expected value of 0 so any $ allocated to it would be wasted. Instead I spread my money in investments I expect to have positive value, and I invest in many of them for diversification benefits (which may be is what you were getting at?)

But the point of diversification is to secure uncorrelated positive returns. A negative return on the other hand is just a negative return. I totally agree with you that I could be wrong in my short case on BTC, my logic rests on it.

And just in defense of my case - I think about markets as someone who's studied and worked in them for 18+ years. Doesn't mean I am right and I have an open mind. So whenever I encounter someone who has the opposite view, I explain to them my case with the hopes that they can point me to what I am missing, but I always walk away with the impression they hadn't thought about the issue deeply and with nuance. Again, I could totally be wrong, but as an investor if it seems like I did my homework and the others are driven by hype/FOMO/not understanding then I am gonna sit it out :)

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by tchalla on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:41PM (#25710178)
> This sounds like a weird way to invest. According to this logic I should invest $.01 in BTC and then to borrow from a funny commenter in this thread, $.01 in Dodgecoin, $.01 in Ether, $.01 in baseball cards, $.01 in wine, $.01 in beanie babies, etc etc etc etc etc - that basically any investment that exists deserves my dollars.

Honestly, I found that comment disrespectful and making a mockery of a point - it's all too common these days. If I were to take the opposite of the comment, we should NOT invest in anything and stay 100% in cash because each and every asset has risks and volatility.

> I disagree. There's plenty of stuff one "could" invest in and very few one "should."

You know that I agree with you right? I never said you SHOULD invest in BTC. I was making the point that IF one wants to invest in the BTC, then one can do so by a minimal asset allocation. It fits within your "expected value" framework.

> But the point of diversification is to secure uncorrelated positive returns. A negative return on the other hand is just a negative return. I totally agree with you that I could be wrong in my short case on BTC, my logic rests on it.

I agree. But, surely if you were willing to consider an Armageddon scenario for BTC; you could also consider a 100% upside scenario too. We did a thought experiment on the Armageddon scenario, I haven't seen any calculations on the upside.

> And just in defense of my case - I think about markets as someone who's studied and worked in them for 18+ years. Doesn't mean I am right and I have an open mind. So whenever I encounter someone who has the opposite view, I explain to them my case with the hopes that they can point me to what I am missing, but I always walk away with the impression they hadn't thought about the issue deeply and with nuance. Again, I could totally be wrong, but as an investor if it seems like I did my homework and the others are driven by hype/FOMO/not understanding then I am gonna sit it out :)

I am grateful for you that you took the time to listen. I could not find a e-mail or contact on your profile. I'd be happy to take this offline and I want to understand what I am missing here.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Sunday January 10, 2021 @12:21AM (#25710645)
To be clear - you're right, I did the run-through the worst-case scenario, but I did it for someone else who wasn't seeing it. It's not that my own view rests on it.

I won't share my email or other contact here since I tend to share somewhat personal stories on HN so I'd rather it not totally tie to who I am (though really who cares) so let me lay out the simplest view of my short case on BTC.

I believe that valuation matters. I "believe" in the price of an oil futures contract for example because I know it represents the best effort of invested parties to arrive at what that price ought to be (through a market mechanism.) So people say things like "I am bullish on oil as long as it's under $X" - and once it goes above $X (plus some margin perhaps) even the bulls sell. This is good because it's sane behavior in the market.

With Bitcoin, I don't see anyone say "I am bullish until it crosses $X" - the culture of the marketplace is that it's going up no matter the price. In market terms it creates unchecked upward pressure on the price, which in my mind equates to bubble conditions.

And then I have seen enough bubbles burst (in my lifetime and through study of history) to know that unchecked upward pressure will stop just after it reaches its max. And since people aren't anchoring to an analytic $X price, there's likewise no floor on the way down. I spelled out the mechanics of this in what you call Armageddon analysis.

To boil this down very simply: 1. Whenever people are buying without an attempt to valuate, they inflate a bubble. 2. Bubbles always burst.

I have other, more technical and psychological elements to the short case, but this is the simplest piece. People bidding something up without concern for valuation always spells trouble.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by pontifier on Sunday January 10, 2021 @12:29AM (#25710718)
I can imagine several scenarios in which BTC goes to zero.

Some have even happened.

You lose your key, or get hacked, or send to the wrong address and everything you invested is gone.

Oh, and if someone manages to reverse SHA256, or finds a vulnerability in the public key scheme it all becomes worthless instantly... That is if they don't keep it secret and milk the whole thing for everything it's worth.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by AznHisoka on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:18AM (#25713527)
Of course there is a scenario where any investment goes to 0. If you a smart investor you understand the risks as well, and allocate appropriately. Which is why Bitcoin is just 1% of my overall portfolio.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by BeetleB on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:58PM (#25707815)
> I can conjure up a disaster scenario just standing right now in my kitchen, and I don't even own crypto.

Even if Bitcoin goes to zero, many who hold BTC when it hits zero will still have made a profit out of it.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by nmfisher on Sunday January 10, 2021 @12:04AM (#25710435)
Yeah, but if BTC goes to zero, it's more relevant to ask "for every 100 investors who ever bought BTC, how many made a net profit and how many made a net loss"?
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:29PM (#25708175)
I suppose you mean "because they had sold a bit of it before" - sure. And someone else has bought it off them and will have lost.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by BeetleB on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:44PM (#25708424)
> And someone else has bought it off them and will have lost.

Not the concern of the one making a profit off of this. Not sure it should be either. That's the role of the regulators.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:04PM (#25708775)
I am not making a moral argument. I am talking about the disaster scenario.

I guess I agree with your point actually - if someone got to a place where they already got more $USD out of bitcoin than they invested, it's safe to play.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by HarryHirsch on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:25PM (#25704931)
It's worrying, isn't it, people putting money into bitcoin because there are no productive investment opportunities available in the real world. That's secular stagnation.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by thebean11 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:43PM (#25705123)
Wouldn't necessarily call bitcoin non-productive, any more than an unprofitable startup is non-productive. The technology does currently have niche use cases, and the decentralization can be a positive. It's a bet that "productive" things will be enabled by it.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by HarryHirsch on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:44PM (#25706397)
One can make a good case for certain startups like Theranos or U-Beam to be the same type of non-productive investment as Bitcoin. Bitcoin exists only in the imagination, but some business models or products are just as imaginary because they are physically impossible. It's the same phenomenon, capital being thrown at things increasingly unlikely to yield a return.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by cratermoon on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:25PM (#25706213)
"Buying tulips is a rational decision because others are irrational and bidding them up"
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by AznHisoka on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:03PM (#25723844)
Substitute bitcoin for whatever you want: tulips, Beanie babies, etc. Even George Soros, the legendary investor is in favor of putting money in a bubble early on. It's how you make the most money.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by cratermoon on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:08PM (#25751790)
It's also how you lose most often. It's a gamble for rich people who have money they can afford to write off. It's not a sound retirement investment.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by 14 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:43PM (#25703160)
I think it is a high risk high reward system. For some there is very little risk in investing several thousand dollars, that is a pay check or 2. But if things go well the reward could be your money quadrupling or more.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by kgwgk on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:22PM (#25703634)
This applies to all Ponzi schemes. And despite the solid investment case most people end up holding the bag.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:36PM (#25706311)
It just non-stop amazes me. There might be some psychological defensive-bias at work here, but just in these replies to my original comment... it's predominantly pro-btc.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by randomopining on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:42PM (#25703147)
It’s a deflationary store of value, it does make sense to invest some into it.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by HarryHirsch on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:11PM (#25703486)
store of value

The value comes from being able to manipulate the price, one would suppose.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:12PM (#25703500)
How can you manipulate the price?

I suppose there are now some whales, including governments that seized BTC from criminals, that could induce a crash by selling thousands of BTC within a short frame of time. But that may be true for many stocks as well.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by strathmeyer on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:25PM (#25703659)
The more dumb stuff people say about Bitcoin, the more room you know it has to rise.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:30PM (#25704390)
Why is the comment dumb?
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:56PM (#25704660)
Because it is not so easy to manipulate the price, presumably.

It depends on the trading volume. For many "altcoins" or "shitcoins" it may be true, because they have low trading volume. Bitcoin probably less so these days.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by ricardo81 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:20PM (#25704877)
Given the market cap of 800 billion for BTC at the moment, presumably it should by relatively hard to manipulate.

I'd read elsewhere that there was a tiny minority of BTC holders that own 95% of it, no idea of the authenticity of that.

As a Layman, my assumption is the more liquidity in the market, the harder it would be to manipulate and less reason to dump onto the market if a large stakeholder.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by fsdfgsfsdfsdfsd on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:35AM (#25712830)
I think some of the whales could make the price tank, at least temporarily. They include some governments who seized thousands of BTC from criminal operations.

But I think the same applies to many stocks. If Musk of Bezos would sell off a majority of their shares in their own companies, it would perhaps also move the price.

At the moment, crashes in Bitcoin can also be seen as a good thing because it helps give more people access to Bitcoin. It's even possible that some of the stakeholders (whales with thousands of BTC) occasionally deliberately induce crashes for exactly that purpose.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:07PM (#25704746)
There's only so much that my dog can poop per day. Some of the poop gets lost when I scoop it off the sidewalk. And eventually he will die and not poop any more. Thus my dog's turds are a deflationary store of value but I wouldn't say "it makes sense to invest in some."

Disclosure - I made up the dog.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by thebean11 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:47PM (#25705160)
The dismissiveness of (presumably) otherwise thoughtful people on this forum still surprises me. Do you really find that comparison valuable in evaluating the tech?
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by xyzelement on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:39PM (#25705737)
I was looking to make a finance, not tech point. Specifically that there are many things that are finite and "deflationary" but obviously without value.

Point being that the scarcity argument of bitcoin is on its own not persuasive.

I used the cheeky example of dog poop because I though it was cute but I guess it was"too cute" and obscured the point.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:04PM (#25706580)
I think your point was made and those who are actually listening have understood it ;) I think your analogy does a good job in conveying the point that deflationary =/= valuable.

Almost ironically, having a deflationary system is something one would really like to avoid if you thought about it. It only rewards hoarding. The king, with his hoard of gold, only grow's richer by the year. As long as he is cash flow positive, the supply upon which the peasants rely on to trade shrinks and therefore the value of each grain increases.

I, for one, don't think this system is one we should be rushing to return to.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by jcpham2 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:41PM (#25707591)
Don’t confuse deflationary with the lack of fungibility.

No physical currency can be divided into 10 million pieces, no one has a crystal ball.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#25709692)
I'm not sure I follow?

If one year an apple costs 2 gold coins, but next year, that same apple costs only 1 gold coin - this would be deflation. I'm still trading gold coin(s) for an apple (fungible), it's just that the currency itself got stronger against the asset I wanted to purchase.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by jcpham2 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:56PM (#25710341)
Right, because mathematics-wise the deflating asset (if we’re picking on bitcoin specifically) is programmed to do so until 2040 or so when the block rewards run out for miners.

The currency (or asset) will continue to outperform the dollar or any fiat currency because it is setup that way to scale inversely and inverted-like through the magic of fungibility.

No one no where ever created a means of trade accurate to the ten millionth. Go look it up I’ll wait.

Just because something scales inversely to your currency that doesn’t make it a ponzi, it makes it mathematically and theoretically possible; as the market itself has proven for nearly a decade.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by randomopining on Sunday January 10, 2021 @08:02AM (#25714298)
Yeah deflationary is dumb but not bad when there’s also population deflation.

If millennials invest in btc before boomer pensions get in, it’ll be a needed transfer of wealth.

If there’s a deflationary asset wave, each person is incentivized to get in early. Which I think is what is happening.

Although I think one huge hack or whale unloading could drop the trust in Bitcoin for years.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:20PM (#25707305)
It was not dismissive, it was refuting the specific contention that something scarce and of limited supply is ipso facto valuable.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by dwaltrip on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:16PM (#25707245)
I get it isn't a terribly serious example, but I can't help myself... Your dog shit tokens are vulnerable to "counterfeiting", as poop from other dogs would be practically indistinguishable.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:43PM (#25707634)
DNA analysis would fix that.

Incidentally, I hear that there are all these forks and clones of BTC, many of which have strictly limited supply. So, they are also valuable long term investments, I assume?

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by dwaltrip on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:12PM (#25709837)
The forks aren't widely used and there doesn't seem to be much reason to switch from bitcoin to them. Network effects are quite important here.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by mythrwy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:35AM (#25711963)
It's ok. Made up dog turds are the best kind.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:19PM (#25703594)
With income inequality the way it is, there is intense demand for lottery tickets. That brings the dumb money. And smart money tends to keep an eye on where the dumb money wanders.

Disclosure: I think cryptos are this generation’s baseball cards. I have exposure to companies that make money trading cryptos and selling services to crypto investors.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:48PM (#25706452)
Smart move. They rake in the profits whether you're right or wrong. I've stock in something similar (plus500), but it makes an insignificant part of my overall portfolio. If you have a minute, feel free to PM a few that have caught your attention - the ideal would of course be something with valuation unaffected by the hype itself ;)
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by paulryanrogers on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:28PM (#25704378)
As someone who bought in the era of overproduced baseball cards I think this comparison is apt, if personally painful. At least I can burn them to cook and stay warm in an emergency.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Calamity on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:50PM (#25706467)
Yeh, well, that's what gets me the most about this. I can imagine the number of people jumping in on the bandwagon with money they can't afford to lose - and the pain that will inevitably ensue.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by mancerayder on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:28PM (#25706779)
You mentioned exposue to these companies; is that even possible without access to private equity?
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by thekyle on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:18PM (#25708028)
Both Square and PayPal are public and support "buying" of Crypto on their platforms. Coinbase is going to be IPOing soon into much fanfare.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by Findeton on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:48PM (#25704574)
Well if the FED and the ECB weren't printing tens of thousands of millions of fake money every month and calling it Quantitative Easing I might have agreed maybe. Truth is government issued money is worth less and less over time, as the scheme is designed to create inflation and thus make government debt sustainable by robbing everyone else's savings year by year.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by solinent on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:09PM (#25704766)
It seems to me the investment community has accepted bitcoin at this point, with major institutional investors finally buying in now--1 billion from microstrategy, for example--so expect to see it go up more. I think it will keep going up until it gets regulated, I'm sure they'll continue to find ways to "increase liquidity" despite Bitcoin.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:23PM (#25707350)
> Truth is government issued money is worth less and less over time

Yes, that's the deal with money, which incentivises you to either spend it or invest it in productive (unlike BTC) enterprises. As it happens, inflation has been very low, arguably too low in the last decade+.

Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by shaolinspirit on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:48PM (#25703227)
being rational is overrated, modernism is boring
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by FabHK on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:44PM (#25707645)
Just for the record, I disagree with the first contention. And, boring is underrated.
Re:To the moon: defining and detecting cryptocurrency pump-a... by pixel_tracing on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#25703335)
There’s money on the table what sane capitalist wouldn’t jump at the chance to take some in?