News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by xvf22 on Friday January 08, 2021 @12:52PM (#25687481)
Tesla seem to do a lot of running changes, are they certifying each one?
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by tobyjsullivan on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:07PM (#25687663)
I don't see why they'd be exempt, generally. Obviously they only need to certify the changes that make it to production but, yeah, that still seems like more than other automakers.

I'm guessing one advantage Tesla has over traditional automakers is their entire company has been built around the existing regulatory environment. I'd be willing to bet their recertification process is quite streamlined compared to companies that have iteratively patched it on to their tradition vehicle design processes. Just a guess though; I have no background knowledge on this topic.

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by turbinerneiter on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:55PM (#25688478)
The traditional automakers are the ones making the regulation, trough lobbying (in the good and bad sense of the world). There isn't a regulation passed on the car industry that the car industry isn't part of writing.

I highly doubt that the traditional carmakers are slowed down by regulations.

Would be cool to find someone who has actual insights to ask this.

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by mywittyname on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:21PM (#25688934)
There are lots of mechanisms to fast-track changes. If Ford changes the headlight assembly on the next year Mustang, they don't go and crash the car again. They (or a supplier) fill out the certification form showing that their testing indicates the new headlight assembly abides by all the regulations imposed on vehicles, and submit it to the relevant state and federal bodies.

You can generally tell what revisions are straight-forward to certify and which are not by noting common year-to-year changes in a model.

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by brundolf on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:11PM (#25687716)
"Continuous [Regulatory] Integration"
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by vslira on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:19PM (#25687806)
Frankly it's a brilliant innovation, assuming that's the case. Applying new regulations quicker is definitely a moat in a heavily regulated environment, as long as it's not half-arsed
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by terafo on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:11PM (#25687719)
AFAIK Tesla tries to produce as much as they can in-house. They are designing their own chips for their cars, for example.
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by taneq on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:23PM (#25687864)
That sure would make it easier if the regulation is written as "you must use the same supplier" and they can just say "yup, it me".
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by MichaelZuo on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:33PM (#25688008)
Perhaps it is the biggest reason why they did that in the first place.
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by numpad0 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:05PM (#25689653)
And that contributed to their stupid issues like skipping conformal coating and cars getting runaway power steering from it
Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by londons_explore on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:26AM (#25697963)
Not unique to them... An entirely reproducible power glitch in my early honda hybrid causes the power steering to steer at full power to the left... End result is the wheel spins with so much force it broke my thumbs... Lucky I was only doing 5mph at the time!

It's 100% a design fault, and applies equally to any car of this model (I tested it on a friends, same result!). There are simple reproduction steps which can totally happen by accident, yet there has been no recall or service bulletin issued.

I ended up pulling the power steering controller apart and adding my own safety circuit to the microcontroller output so my car is now the only car of this model which won't break your thumbs or steer you into a ditch!

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by WalterBright on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:00AM (#25698774)
The design fault is having a failure mode that leads to full power to the left, not the fact that there was a failure.

I've noticed that automakers are about 60 years behind aircraft makers in design methodologies that prevent things like hardovers due to single component failures.

I'm not exaggerating about the 60 years thing. I worked in Boeing engineering 40 years ago and the "no single component failure causing a crash" was the rule and literally the law.

(A lesson Boeing had to relearn with the 737MAX MCAS system.)

Nuclear reactors (Fukishima) and drilling rigs (Deepwater Horizon) are far behind, too.

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by londons_explore on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:24PM (#25703644)
This isn't even this level... There is a certain sequence of actions to make it do it... and it isn't hard to do by accident - it basically involves turning on every electrical thing (as you would do on a cold dark night), having a quite flat 12v battery (as would happen if you left the car unused for a few months), then turning the steering wheel while revving the engine (as happens while you're pulling out of a parking space).

So park the car for a few months, then go to unpark it on a cold night... Not at all rare!

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by zaroth on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:01PM (#25696714)
Can you point to the recall from this?

The recall I can find is to replace 3 bolts that can corrode due to salt which would cause loss of power steering.

I’m not sure what runaway power steering is?

Re:Car manufacturing hit by global semiconductor shortage by numpad0 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:39AM (#25698049)
Crazy in a general context of cars but not sure they issued recalls? That seems normal wrt Teslas. IIRC the root cause was water intrusion into power steering ECU on MS P100D, could be rain or condensation.