News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by joshklein on Friday May 20, 2011 @09:41AM (#2567588)
I think there are a number of issues:

1 - People relate fat the nutrient to fat the body type because they share the word "fat". Not much to do there. In high school I was taught that carbohydrates were "energy" and fat was "waste". People should probably be taught the right way our biological systems operate.

2 - Medical authorities have worked with the best science they had available at the time, and are almost always managed by bureaucrats, not physicians. This isn't limited to the governmental level; hospitals, medical organizations, medical schools... the people in charge often have administrative training, not medical training. As a subpoint; sure, medical authorities have led us astray with nutrition information, but let's not jump to the conclusion that they have done something intentionally evil here.

3 - It's hard to prove any one way is the right way because of so many variables, including genetics, activity level, co-morbidities, and so on. More importantly, when something is right for 95% of people, that also means it is wrong for 5% of people. In the absence of easily testable datum, those anecdotes get a lot of attention. And even if it were easily testable, 5% of the time it would be wrong.

To me, the key is two-fold:

1 - People need to be educated about the facts of how their biological systems function. They need to know how calories work, insulin and blood sugar regulate, and gain a general appreciation of the science of their bodies.

2 - People need to be willing to "listen to their bodies" and experiment. That's the only way to know what really works for you, because you ARE different than everyone else. A healthy diet isn't just about finding mathematically optimal foods, it's about finding stuff you like to eat, that fills you up, that you can eat in moderation, that is easy to make. You need to be willing to mix health and convenience, taste and availability, etc... and that takes a bit of time to figure out.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by jpk on Friday May 20, 2011 @09:54AM (#2567635)
Related to your key #1, this[1] talk by Robert Lustig (who's work has seen some exposure on HN in the past) has a pretty good run-down of how some of the carbohydrates are metabolized. Specifically, he points to fructose as the culprit when it comes to obesity.

I recommend watching the whole thing, but skip to about 36:00 to see the biochemistry.

[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by matwood on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:25AM (#2567764)
Sigh. A good criticism of Lustigs demonizing fructose:

http://www.alanaragonblog.com/2010/01/29/the-bitter-truth-ab...

Key takeaway that Lustig ignores - USDA numbers by the way:

Total energy intake in 1970 averaged 2172 kcal. By 2007 this hiked up to 2775 kcal, a 603 kcal increase.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by djackson on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:40AM (#2567811)
And Lustig responds to those criticisms here:

http://www.kqed.org/a/forum/R201104211000

Key takeaway is that Lustig doesn't make any claim that you can't get fat by eating too many calories, regardless of the source. Lustig's research is on the metabolic pathways for fructose and glucose, and they are substantially different.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by matwood on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:57AM (#2567895)
I'll listen when I have some time later. Does he also address the dose dependent problem in his cited studies? Of course if I'm drinking 6-7 sodas a day that's generally going to be a problem, but it doesn't mean sugar is evil. Too much water can kill me also, but I don't see people saying water is evil.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by djackson on Friday May 20, 2011 @11:24AM (#2568014)
Like I said, he talks about metabolic pathways, which are independent of dose, though not your body's current state of glycogen deficiency.

He also speaks to the effect of insulin resistance, and how the very rapid metabolism of fructose in the liver (7x faster than glucose) can lead to insulin resistance. Insulin spikes redirect calories eaten directly to fat, without them ever being metabolized into energy. As a result you gain fat and have less energy available, leaving you both fatter and hungrier.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by watmough on Friday May 20, 2011 @12:53PM (#2568439)
Thanks for giving such a great summation. This was the key point for me from Lustig's presentation.

Essentially, if you treat sucrose and fructose as a condiment, rather than as a key source of kCal, you will be consuming simple sugars, protein and fat, food that actually nourishes and sates you directly, versus sucrose and fructose that in high doses simply transform to fat.

Per Lustig, it's important to differentiate between starches found in bread, potatoes etc., that break down to simple sugars like glucose that are metabolized directly by the body, and added sucrose and fructose that are metabolized in the liver to fat. For people saying that our carb consumption was the same back in early 20th Century, take a look at how much of that was likely breads and the like, versus the highly sweetened cereals of today.

edit: added a para on why looking at 'carbs', misses Lustig's point.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by dkarl on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:41AM (#2567819)
Intake is the key point in the entire argument for me. The dose makes the poison, and at this point we're arguing over whether it is healthier to poison ourselves with excessive calories from fat or excessive calories from carbs. If you don't eat too much, you don't have a stake in the argument at all.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by terio on Friday May 20, 2011 @03:56PM (#2569204)
Not really. It depends on each person's metabolism. I know people that get fat just by having regular desserts for a few days, and others (generally very young) that can eat anything until they burst without moving the needle.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by sambeau on Friday May 20, 2011 @04:29PM (#2569326)
There is no such thing as 'metabolism': just body mass, muscle mass and activity.

Big people burn more calories even when still. Active people burn more than still people of the same size. Muscular people burn more calories than the non-muscular as they have to feed their bigger muscles.

In sealed room tests fat people use more calories than thin people.

Skinny people who can eat anything they want without putting on weight tend to be very fidgety - they never keep totally still. Just wiggling a leg all day can use a large amount of energy.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by jpk on Friday May 20, 2011 @05:46PM (#2569544)
"Skinny people who can eat anything they want without putting on weight tend to be very fidgety - they never keep totally still. Just wiggling a leg all day can use a large amount of energy."

Hm, this is interesting. I've never heard that before, but it seems intuitive. Do you have any sources for that idea? (Not that I'm challenging, just curious.)

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by ajslater on Friday May 20, 2011 @06:03PM (#2569583)
In the literature its referred to as N.E.A.T. Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis

Many people's body's response to overfeeding is to up NEAT, up fidgetyness. But not always. Your body thinks getting fat is a good thing. Famine used to be common. When dieting almost everyone down-regulates NEAT. On a severe diet you feel like being very still.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by abrown28 on Friday May 20, 2011 @04:38PM (#2569356)
Awesome... I will tell my coworker who is always complaining about my fidgeting legs that I'm exercising ;)
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by terio on Saturday May 21, 2011 @09:22AM (#2570824)
"There is no such thing as 'metabolism': just body mass, muscle mass and activity."

Those factors are not enough. The human body has many more important factors in play there, like hormones, intestinal flora, and so on.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by dkarl on Friday May 20, 2011 @05:39PM (#2569520)
In general, you can't trust self-reported data, especially not data reported to social acquaintances. Not only do people underreport how much they eat (it's the norm, even for people who aren't overweight), they don't do a good job of measuring their weight and reporting weight loss or weight gain. People really do say and believe that they've gained five pounds in two days, or lost ten pounds in a week, when it's clear they are just measuring fluctuations that have nothing to do with muscle or body fat.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by Hawramani on Friday May 20, 2011 @11:06AM (#2567939)
The reasoning in that line shows the classic misunderstanding that has led us here. As Taubes says, saying you get fat because you eat too much doesn't explain anything. Of course you need to eat more calories that you expend to gain weight. But why do people do it, and why didn't they do it before?

Taubes says we eat too much because we eat carbs. If people had eaten a carb-free diet since 1970 we wouldn't be seeing that spike in calorie intake. Therefore the fact that calorie intake increased is in complete support of Taubes and Lustig's ideas.

Carbs increase insulin secretion, which encourages fat cells to take in blood sugar and turn it into fat, and discourages the body from burning fat for fuel.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by yummyfajitas on Friday May 20, 2011 @12:22PM (#2568288)
What if we increased carb consumption far above the levels of today (from 43% of our diet to, I dunno, 54%)? Would we be even fatter than we are now?

https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnpp.usd...

History tells us the answer. In the early part of the 20'th century, we ate nothing but carbs. We weren't fat.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by gojomo on Friday May 20, 2011 @03:21PM (#2569063)
Were the early-20th-century carbs the same carbs as today? (Corn and potatoes aren't the same as sugar-cane and HFCS.)
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by yummyfajitas on Friday May 20, 2011 @11:38PM (#2570181)
You might try reading the report I linked to.

The big difference is that we eat more calories, less carbs, more fat and more sugar.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by anthonyb on Saturday May 21, 2011 @04:47AM (#2570510)
Your report just has "Carbs" - nothing to do with what sort they were. That could be flour, sugar, or potatoes, and they stay relatively constant, there's no decline (p18).

There's a big increase in the amount of fat consumed, but I suspect a large part of the difference is going to be lifestyle, too. Around the turn of the century people walked a lot more and did a lot more manual labour.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 21, 2011 @05:15AM (#2570545)
See table 4 and 5. It doesn't give breakdowns of sugar vs HFCS or corn vs wheat, but it does separate sweeteners from potatoes from grains.

Regardless - total calories went up. Carbs stayed almost constant in absolute terms (a slight decrease) and decreased in relative terms. Fat increased in both absolute and relative terms. I guess carbs must be the culprit!

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by anthonyb on Saturday May 21, 2011 @06:33AM (#2570618)
Ok, I see that now, and it fits with what I know - if your blood glucose is saturated, then any extra fat and sugar you eat goes straight to your arse.

Interesting that whole milk dropped off so sharply in the 1970s and 80s - about the time that 'fat is bad' started up? From what I've read, low fat milk contributes to heart disease too - something about the level of fat-soluble vitamins?

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by rimmjob on Friday May 20, 2011 @11:02AM (#2567920)
that doesn't seem to be a very good criticism at all. he completely misses Lustig's point, skews the argument and tries to obfuscate his own lack of expertise with buzzwords and shallow analysis.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by terio on Friday May 20, 2011 @09:53AM (#2567630)
My strategy is simple: in general I avoid food that a hunter-gatherer would not be able to find. I said "in general" because I eat cheese, some hams and preserved meats and sausages, and I also drink wine.

After a short learning curve it became very easy.

In terms of convenience, I still find a sandwich and a canned juice pretty convenient, but I avoid them anyway. I have not had the need for other "convenient" foods like cereals, rice, noodles, and so on.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by mcantor on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:01AM (#2567660)
There happens to be an entire nutritional philosophy based on exactly that approach:

http://thepaleodiet.com/

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by terio on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:15AM (#2567721)
I know, that's was one of my starting points. My comment addresses the last part of the parent comment: you should experiment and find what works best your yourself. Although I consider myself a paleo, I am not a purist.
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by mcantor on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:31AM (#2567786)
Well-said. Lately one of my mantras has been "Do What Works For You". We tend to broadcast our opinions as if they were the only possible approach for all people, because our insecurities make us fear being wrong every time we see someone with a different solution. Or, worse; we choose to take the "easy way" of following someone else's belief system to avoid the uncertainty of nurturing our own, even if it obviously doesn't work for us. Each individual person experimenting and drawing their own conclusions seems like the most reliable way for everyone to actually see results.

If only everyone would just be quiet and follow my opinions about that...

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by troels on Friday May 20, 2011 @04:34PM (#2569347)
Wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that prehistoric man was optimised for a much shorter life-span than present day man has? In that case, wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that pre-historic diet isn't good in the long term?
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by Alex3917 on Friday May 20, 2011 @10:44AM (#2567835)
"People relate fat the nutrient to fat the body type because they share the word 'fat'."

That's like when people think that alcohol makes you depressed because it's a depressant.

Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by Travis on Friday May 20, 2011 @12:25PM (#2568301)
To be fair, alcohol (ab)use is highly correlated with depression symptoms. The nervous system depression, however, is not necessarily the same mechanism that causes psychological depression. (lots of available articles on alcohol and depression, e.g., http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term=alcohol%20depression)
Re:Why do people resist the idea that carbs are worse than fat? by Alex3917 on Friday May 20, 2011 @01:26PM (#2568603)
"The nervous system depression, however, is not necessarily the same mechanism that causes psychological depression."

Alcohol causes depression because of its longterm effects on the brain, as well as the fact that it causes cytokine inflammation. (And possibly for other reasons as well.) This definitely has nothing to do with the fact that it temporarily slows down your heart rate and breathing, otherwise we'd all be suicidal every morning when we woke up.