When people overeat grossly, those 5% won't make much of a difference. On my binge days, I consume upwards of 5000 kcal and it doesn't really matter if it's actually just 4750 kcal - it's still too much.
So yeah, in practice, a calorie is pretty much a calorie.
The study this cites early on suggests that a low-carbohydrate diet with N calories a day is roughly equivalent to a low-fat diet with only 70% of N calories a day. So a 2000 calorie-a-day low-carbohydrate diet is equivalent to a 1400 calorie-a-day low-fat diet. That result is huge. (And makes me regret having had pasta three times this week!)
As other people said, the results of this study are not new. We learned that in basic biochemistry when the metabolic pathways were discussed.
> So a 2000 calorie-a-day low-carbohydrate diet is equivalent to a 1400 calorie-a-day low-fat diet.
It is so not.
Perhaps there is some reason to doubt this study, but saying "It is so not" is hardly a rational rebuttal.
> Some of the available energy is lost as heat and in the internal rearrangement of chemical compounds and other changes in entropy.
So not all of the difference in efficiency is made up in the form of heat. Unfortunately, I don't remember enough biochemistry nor thermodynamics to dive deeper into this, but I think this article is a good starting point for a discussions, which has otherwise just been dismissed with the "a calorie is a calorie" argument.
Calories derived from fat vs protein vs carbohydrates have different inefficiencies in converting them from their theoretical caloric value to their useful work in the body.
Fat is the most efficient with a loss of just @ 2-3%, carbs are at 6-8%, protein 25-30%. [edit Most of] this loss is in the form of heat.
It was not mentioned why this excess heat would not simply be offset by the body avoiding the normal processes it takes to maintain body temperature. Presumably the body generates enough heat as a by-product at room temperature and thus there is nothing the body can back off of to make use of the waste heat described above.