Re:"A calorie is a calorie" violates the second law of therm...
by colomon on Friday May 20, 2011 @06:39AM
(#2567126)
"A low carbohydrate group (LoCHO = 1800 kcal for men; 1500 kcal for women), a low fat group (LoFat, 1800 and 1500); a third group also consumed a low carbohydrate diet but an additional 300 kcalories were provided (LoCHO+300, 2100 and 1800). The order of average amount of weight lost was LoCHO = 23 lbs, LoCHO+300 = 20 lbs LoFat = 17 lbs." That's not quite the same math I used, but it seems to pretty strongly suggest that a LoCHO+600 group would have have lost 17 lbs, exactly the same as the LoFat group.
Perhaps there is some reason to doubt this study, but saying "It is so not" is hardly a rational rebuttal.
As other people said, the results of this study are not new. We learned that in basic biochemistry when the metabolic pathways were discussed.
> So a 2000 calorie-a-day low-carbohydrate diet is equivalent to a 1400 calorie-a-day low-fat diet.
It is so not.