TLS clients can do a bunch of different things, but, unlike in SMTP, where it's mostly reasonable to do whatever servers will let you get away with, both sides need to follow the protocol to the letter to make TLS do what it's supposed to do.
> This proposal overtly changes the security boundaries of that handshake.
Could you outline that in more detail?
It seems to me like the overt change in the handshake security boundary is that in a FalseStart handshake, a man-in-the-middle attacker can make the initiating side send application data encrypted with relatively arbitrary parameters (until the TLS implementation realizes it can't decrypt the final handshake message properly). There is a good chance this is just annoying (like, on a denial-of-service level of attack) but my intuition is there could be some application circumstances where this is a significant problem. Off the top of my head I can't come up with a specific example however - so I could just be imagining things :)
There are also operating system/application level architecture challenges as well. For example, I'm not sure the idea of FalseStart is compatible with the calling convention of Windows SSL/TLS (InitializeSecurityContext and AcceptSecurityContext) given the separation between transport layer and security context negotiation components. And because of that existing convention, the recommendation in sections 4 and 5 of the draft that "TLS implementations allow the application layer to query whether the handshake has completed" could be potentially tricky for applications using Schannel (Windows SSL/TLS).
"Creating an Schannel Security Context" : http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa374781(v=VS.85).as...
> If certain conditions are met, application data can be sent when the handshake is only partially complete ...
I'm surprised this hasn't be done before -- spammers have used this idea with SMTP for years, for example. Well done Messrs Langley, Modadugu and Moeller.