News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by SulfurHexaFluri on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:28PM (#25652089)
IMO everyone related to a corporate crime should be responsible. If a company dumps toxic waste in to a river, the person who pressed the dump button, the person who told them to and any management that signed off on the idea should all be personally as responsible as if I just took a bucket and walked down to the local river.

Perhaps some exceptions for people who could not be expected to understand the law, for example an untrained retail staff being tricked in to violating laws usually only understood by management or legal teams.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:56PM (#25653517)
I agree, and I would go slightly farther. One of the lessons the mortgage bubble taught us is how much executives benefit from plausible deniability. For corporate crime, I think the standard of "knew or should have known" should apply. If CEOs are going to hoover up a lot of the profits when things go right, they should hold at least as much responsibility when things go wrong on their watch.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by harry8 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:35PM (#25653766)
For criminal behaviour from the organisation, the burden of proof needs to be reversed. The CEO should need to prove they did not know and did not endorse tacitally or otherwise and would have reacted strongly to prevent and effectively sanction those responsible if they had found out in advance.

It's their job to know. Only if they are a victim of a genuine criminal conspiracy performed by other employees and it can be shown without the CEO's knowledge should there be any defence.

CEO's are quite happy to tell people to do things without telling them to do the thing. That has been going on for centuries. Shakespeare wrote whole plays about it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Will_no_one_rid_me_of_this_tur...

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by will_pseudonym on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:49PM (#25653865)
OT, but "Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?" reminds me of a funny Mitchell and Webb sketch about evil villains using ambiguous phrases when ordering their henchmen to kill someone.

(NSFW) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U6cake3bwnY

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by interestica on Thursday January 07, 2021 @02:57PM (#25676447)
Corporations will hire 'plausible deniability officers' specifically to obfuscate decisions.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:28AM (#25655136)
I don't think CEO is the right level. It may be the top position with high pay, but a CEO is so high up the food-chain that they touch very little.

Any level of management with a direct responsibility is where blame should lie.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Larrikin on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:16AM (#25655358)
This is the same argument that tech corporations say should apply to them. They should be allowed to grow uncontrollably to make as much money as possible but it's actually impossible for them to know the details (moderate content in this specific iteration of the argument) of what they have grown. The point of this thread is the same argument against that very idea.

If the organization is so big that the CEO believes that, it shouldn't matter. They should be ultimately responsible for the entire organization. No one forced the company to be that big and no one made them take the job.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:03AM (#25655588)
But you can't know all of that.

Imagine some local wallmart having an issue with something (eg. a bunch of expired chemicals, that have to be disposed as dengerous), and they don't want to deal with that in a proper way, and some local manager tells some local worker, to just dump the chemicals into a stream behind the wallmart. Usually noone notices stuff like that, if the chemicals are not "too bad" (=fish die), the worker will lose his/her job if (s)he doesn't do it, and the manager will get someone else to do it. If the worker reports it, it's his word against the managers, the manager will just say it was leaked rainwater, and that they asked the worker to spill it in the gutter, so the worker has no real choice, if they want to feed the kids that night. People above the manager have no idea about that local wallmart, and that one time issue.

Then, the worker dumps the chemicals into the stream, the chemicals just happen to be very dangerous, and a million fish die in the river downstream. Is the CEO really the guilty on here? Did he really know?

On the other hand, you have the VW dieselgate, where a whole team had to work on the software, and atleast a few level of mangers had to have known about the issue. But on the corporate ladder, where every level is squeezing the level below it to "do more", "bring in more profits", it's possible that some manager in charge of something actually didn't tell the people above him, just how exactly he solved the exhaust issue, just that he solved it, and saved millions of euros (and got a huge bonus). On the other hand, coordinating a big team of coders, and such info not getting to higher ups or to members of different teams in the same company (with different managers) is probably unlikely.

What i'm trying to say is, that blaming the CEO by default is bad, because in the first case, it's unrealistic to expect the CEO to even know that that local walmart exists.... and in the second case, that there should be a very thourough investigation just how high the knowledge went, and have the whole chain of comand held responsible.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by beefield on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:05AM (#25655935)
> it's unrealistic to expect the CEO to even know that that local walmart exists

Maybe, just maybe we then should not have so large entities that nobody can be responsible for? Limited liability is a massive handout from society to the owners of the Limited liability company and should be priced accordingly. (I do not propose banning limited liability. I propose being more selective how and which operations actually deserve limited liability. And tax it appropriately.)

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:10AM (#25655969)
But this is true even with companies that have only two stores. Even one if it's open for more than one shift.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Symmetry on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:56AM (#25658265)
That would be nice in a way but then we couldn't have complicated products like laptops or iPhones. Abstraction barriers aren't optional when managing sufficiently complex processes.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by beefield on Thursday January 07, 2021 @05:57AM (#25669628)
"I propose being more selective how and which operations actually deserve limited liability"
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:12AM (#25657885)
> just maybe we then should not have so large entities that nobody can be responsible for

But who says no one is responsible? There are clearly guilty parties, just not the CEO.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:55AM (#25658259)
You are confusing "really guilty" with "really knows".

The whole theory behind paying CEOs their current absurd salaries is that they are 5-D chess geniuses, responsible for the value created by up to millions of people doing actual work.

How can a CEO be in control enough to deserve all of the profits but so out of control that they deserve none of the blame?

The practical outcome is that high-level executives create plausible deniability. In your story, they issue edicts like "our chemical disposal bill is too high! Fix it!" or just "Our per-store costs are too high!" and ride roughshod over objections. "Don't bring me problems! Solve them!" The pressure rolls downhill. People trying to do the right thing get yelled at or fired; people doing the wrong thing skate on by, because the metrics look better. So everybody learns to do what the CEO implicitly wants: cutting corners to increase profits.

If the CEOs don't know that's the natural outcome of their behavior then they're negligent or criminally incompetent. If they do, they're just criminals. But they have plenty of money to create enough deniability that they can walk away. Possibly using some lower subordinate as a scapegoat, when he was just responding to incentives that the CEO set up.

In my view, whether or not a CEO has direct knowledge of a direct crime is irrelevant. At the CEO level, they don't have direct knowledge of anything, but they have power over everything. It's not clear to me positions like that should exist, but as long as they do exist, they should be responsible for the whole system that they have so eagerly taken charge of. Ignorance cannot be an excuse.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by orhmeh09 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @06:12AM (#25656656)
It is the duty of the CEO to demand the types of observability, monitoring, and training so that this scenario could be avoided.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by avianlyric on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:51AM (#25658222)
In this scenario the CEO should be able to point to a body of evidence that show the Walmart has strong and robust procedures for dealing with type of waste, and they provide enough time and training to employees to follow those procedures.

Thus this specific act was the result of an employee failing to follow procedure, despite being given the training and time to do so.

This is the exact burden of proof that is used for health and safety. When an employee is seriously injured, there’s a burden on the employer to demonstrate that took all reasonable precautions to prevent the injury. That mean procedures, training and evidence that those procedures and training is followed, enforced and enough time and space to provided for employees to follow them.

This should exist through the entire chain of command, with each level ensuring that the level below isn’t cutting corners, and it part of a CEO responsibility to build that management framework. I mean it already exists for controlling costs and ensure health & safety in most successful companies, why can’t it exist for all legal and social obligations?

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by canofbars on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:59AM (#25655901)
The problem is management can just abuse this by saying something like "Dispose of these chemicals safely, you have 5 minutes to be back". The manager clearly said to do it safely but 5 minutes only leaves time to dump them unsafely. How do you assign blame to the manager or even higher systems which tell people to do these things without literally saying it.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:12AM (#25657886)
This just means there is nuance to correctly assigning blame.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:31AM (#25656074)
> but it's actually impossible for them

but what is "them" in this case. You are talking about the corporation, but does this mean CEOs, managers, or some combination of the two?

I'm not sure I'm arguing along those lines at all. What I'm saying is most CEOs are far removed from anything direct, but I'm not sure how that translates to "and therefore no one is".

> They should be ultimately responsible for the entire organization

I disagree. You don't really argue why, and I argue, at least, that it's not at all practically. Best case it leads to scapegoating the CEO for things they aren't best positioned to control, and/or executive-levels micromanaging lower levels for fear of liability.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:41AM (#25658132)
If a CEO is so high up the food chain that nothing they do matters, then why should they have the high pay? I don't understand the notion that they're responsible for all of the good things their employees do but none of the bad ones. Especially when, as here, it's the bad ones that are so profitable.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by CRConrad on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @07:25AM (#25657080)
> I don't think CEO is the right level. It may be the top position with high pay, but a CEO is so high up the food-chain that they touch very little.

Funny then how the CEO is the right level to take that high pay, which is generally defended as compensation for the ultimate responsibility.

Either the CEO is responsible for what happens under his reign, or he isn't. If he is, why shouldn't he shoulder the blame for the bad parts; if he isn't, why should he be paid for the good parts?

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by PakG1 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @10:37AM (#25658615)
It is the CEO's job to set the organizational culture and expectations. CEO doesn't need to know what's going on farther down the food chain, but the CEO is responsible for setting the culture in which they make their decisions.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:58PM (#25654245)
One of the things I found incredible about the antitrust hearings this past year was how heavily every Big Tech CEO relied on "I don't know", "I don't recall", or "I'll have to get back to you". Often about things I, an outsider, know of.

It strains plausibility they didn't know, they're just punting to a time they aren't under oath.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by onethought on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:17AM (#25655366)
If it’s a crime for you to misspeak wouldn’t you err on the side of caution?

Anti trust hearings of 4 tech companies at once... ridiculous... All 4 of you have a monopoly on... something!

Bullshit politics. You aren’t being forced to use ANY services from big tech in the US there is HEAPS of competition. Just US lawmakers shoring up constituents

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @10:01AM (#25658315)
This would be more plausible if VCs weren't spending billions openly trying to create the sort of market dominance that lets them exercise outsized pricing power. The book Super Pumped, for example, shows clearly that Uber was seeking a monopoly. They only got a duopoly in which they're the dominant player, but from a pricing perspective that's nearly as good.

It follows from VC efforts that market dominance produces massive profits. That money comes from somewhere. Anti-trust enforcement is way too weak in the US. Congress's motives in going after the tech companies is decidedly mixed, but given decades of laxity, I'll take it as a good start.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by onethought on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:54PM (#25663113)
... are you assuming the US = world?

Uber didn’t get a monopoly... and there are a bunch of competitors in lots of different countries. And Uber is paying for this with epic losses every year... where is the anti trust?

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @05:51PM (#25663797)
We were talking about US-based tech companies speaking to the United States Congress about possible anti-trust violations in US markets. A bunch of competitors in other countries doesn't mean anything for US markets. And epic losses are a sign of the antitrust violation: they're burning capital unsustainably to buy market share from which they can extract oligopoly rents.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by onethought on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:22PM (#25688960)
So which city doesn’t have taxis any more in the US?

Before Uber... where were the taxi anti trust hearings?

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by jjeaff on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:08AM (#25655953)
While I very much dislike the anticompetitive practices of these companies, I have to agree they aren't really close to monopolies. Google and Facebook are not social media companies. They are advertising companies. They sell ad space. There are still a lot of different ways to spend as money.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wpietri on Thursday January 07, 2021 @02:22PM (#25675899)
This is wrong in a few ways. One, antitrust includes more than monopoly, including oligopoly and monopsony. Two, there is no generic advertising market; there are a variety of specific ones. Three, Facebook and Instagram are the only way a lot of small companies find buyers, because their platforms give them rich data for ad targeting not available elsewhere. This came up during the Stop Hate For Profit campaign; large companies joined easily, but many small businesses couldn't. Having zero effective choice is a clear sign of anti-trust concerns.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Escapado on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:49PM (#25652310)
And with (financial) protection for those who refuse to partake and report the crime. I guess the person pressing the dump button would usually make just above minimum wage and would be considered unimportant enough to fire if he stood up for what's right so there is no incentive except for a moral one which I would argue is not enough for most people.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by hchz on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:30PM (#25652745)
CWA, CAA, CERCLA, and RCRA provide these protections for whistleblowers and a framework for financial incentives, though these incentives are paltry compared to SEC whistleblower rewards.

https://echo.epa.gov/report-environmental-violations

https://www.whistleblowers.gov

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by ineedasername on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:06PM (#25653117)
The problem is also that the power imbalance is severely stacked against the whistleblower. Sure, retaliation isn't allowed, but it's a far stretch to think it doesn't happen.

I've seen it happen, or what probably was retaliation, but how do I know for sure? They said the person wasn't competent or doing their job when they got fired. I don't know for sure if that was true, but I do know they reported significant theft that would likely have involved someone higher up, and not long afterwards he was fired.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by hchz on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:13PM (#25653622)
My point was only that such protections and rewards already exist.

I find it obvious that such retaliation happens, otherwise it would be strange to have such laws.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Spivak on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:25PM (#25652703)
As much as the liberal-libertarian crowd on HN likes to be vocal against most forms of government licensure, protection from ethical breaches like this is one of the best things about them. You can tell your employer to pound sand because neither you nor anyone they could replace you with will be willing to risk their license to do something unethical. And even if they could find someone sketch to try and push it through you’re protected by your professional review board.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by bitcharmer on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:58AM (#25655284)
I'm not leftist and I haven't observed any strong bias here. HN crowd is leftist only by US standards but then US is a country where most people think public health care is communism.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by pessimizer on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @08:30AM (#25657530)
"Liberal-libertarian" isn't "leftist," and that's pretty clear from the context of the comment. It's minarchist, free-marketeer, etc.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by adventured on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:06AM (#25655938)
~42%-45% of the US population is in Medicaid, Medicare or other government healthcare solutions. It's very clear that most people in the US do not think socialized / public healthcare is tantamount to Communism.

The US is left leaning compared to the majority of all nations.

Besides that, the US is far more progressive than eg Europe in many respects (and that's ignoring parts of Europe still ruled by actual fascism and dictatorship, countries where it's perfectly legal to beat your wife if you so choose and being gay is practically a crime). In the majority of Europe gay marriage is still illegal. How much more regressive and backwards can you get? The US is at least a decade ahead of Europe when it comes to gay rights and identity / gender matters.

In Denmark they're committing vast human rights violations against minority Muslims while the world looks the other way. Is that left by US standards? I don't see the US forcing cultural eradication upon Muslims or taking their children away from them and indoctrinating them with nationalistic propaganda.

Across Western Europe de facto Neo Nazi parties hold immense political power.

In France Macron has practically declared open cultural war against Muslims.

Formerly open immigration nations like Sweden have become hyper xenophobic and have locked down access. Neo Nazism is rampant in Germany and so is xenophobia. Meanwhile the US is one of the few affluent nations on the planet that still welcomes the poor and the non-skilled, you don't need to be rich or successful to immigrate into the US (and that's before Biden's Presidency begins, in which the Democrats will dramatically liberalize immigration).

Progressiveness is vanishing from Europe, while the US is becoming more progressive by the decade. So where are all these nations around the world that are a lot further left than the US? There are maybe a dozen, tops.

The US now spends more on its welfare state as a share of its economy than either Canada or Australia. In the next 10-15 years it'll catch up to Britain on that point.

The US is also progressing much faster on drug decriminalization and legalization than Europe is. And half of Europe is guaranteed to remain backwards, regressive, on all of the previously mentioned items.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by bitcharmer on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @05:07AM (#25656272)
> The US is left leaning compared to the majority of all nations.

I stopped reading after this

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by CRConrad on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @07:31AM (#25657118)
> [T]he US is far more progressive than eg Europe...

This post is the craziest collection of misconceptions and outright untruths I've read in... A very, very long time.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by bserge on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @05:04AM (#25656260)
Wow, uh, where do you get your news on Europe?
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by bitcharmer on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @05:13AM (#25656308)
This is a good evidence for what I refer to as the rise of redditism on HN (US-biased views pretty much detached from reality, but constituting the majority of up/down-votes). This is further supported by the dynamics of up/down votes. You will see GP comment up-voted when the US wakes up.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by pessimizer on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @08:27AM (#25657511)
This is not a change, it has always happened here. Also, saying that HN is turning into reddit is so old that there's a rule about not doing it.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by africanboy on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @08:43AM (#25657613)
You mean Americans being average Americans?
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by africanboy on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @08:42AM (#25657609)
> ~42%-45% of the US population is in Medicaid, Medicare or other government healthcare solutions

Please, not this argument again!

Medicaid is an health insurance, not free health care!

They are completely different things (no, it's not the same thing as providing free healthcare)

And btw, only 23% benefit from it

"providing free health insurance to 74 million low-income and disabled people (23% of Americans)"

> Progressiveness is vanishing from Europe, while the US is becoming more progressive by the decade

The only progress US has made has been the number of homicides...

A nation where a thousand people every year are killed by the police and that has almost 700 people in jail every 100,000 of population (25% of the global jail population) looks more like a dictatorships than a progressive country.

As a comparison in Italy for the police to kill a thousand people it would take 333 years. USA has only 5.5 times the population of Italy.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by gameman144 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:33PM (#25654687)
I like the concept of this, but it seems like it'd be tough to validate that something was actually illegal from the individual actor's level. For instance, if management made clear that the hack here was illegal, the individual person doing the typing is just as culpable. It seems like it'd be very easy to mask that from above, however (e.g. telling a junior developer that there was a contract with Songkick and they needed to just do a database dump).
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by rectang on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:55PM (#25654778)
> I like the concept of this, but it seems like it'd be tough to validate that something was actually illegal from the individual actor's level.

By design. The corporate structure of plausible deniability protects executives, and ultimately shareholders, when lower level actors are subtly "encouraged" to commit criminal behavior which advantages the company — and then cut loose if they get caught.

The incentives provide a strong force ensuring corporate criminality in the aggregate which completely overwhelms the weak force discouraging it at the individual level.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by saghm on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:44PM (#25654735)
Okay, so whoever lied about there being a contract (and anyone who authorizatied the lie) should be culpable.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by canofbars on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @04:01AM (#25655909)
I guess the problem is the higher ups know not to put any of this on record and the new person doesn't know that they should be recording this info so when it gets investigated its all "I never told him to do that".
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by himinlomax on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:41AM (#25655815)
> the person who pressed the dump button

That person would often be paid minimum wage, have at best a high school education and so on. That may not exactly be fair in all cases.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by wieghant on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:48PM (#25662264)
During my time in conscription, one thing that stuck with me was 'Forbidden Order'.

If a superior gives you an order that violates set rules or laws (e.g shoot civilians). You HAVE to obey and BOTH parties will be accountable.

It's crazy how severity of ignoring an order can be worse than tribunal. However I totally agree with accountability.

Though corps would figure out a way to weasel past this regardless.

Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by Uhhrrr on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:34PM (#25654691)
Should be that the board of directors is responsible.
Re:Ticketmaster admits it hacked Songkick before it went out... by nswest23 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @10:53AM (#25658765)
plausible deniability at every level makes this impossible.