In this environment, what is sane (you purchase a CD, rip the bits for use space-shifted to the cloud) is not seen as "legal" without "license fees".
Apple paying dues to the music cartel does win in this environment; Google and Amazon playing to rational logic do not. Apple groked this 20 years ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sosumi
To me the fact that Apple will have deals with the music labels and will probably only allow you to play music you bought from them - that's no surprise at all.
A fight they have no guarantee they can win still. The jurisprudence is against them, although Amazon definitely seems to think they can be successful.
Amazon is one of the largest music sellers in the world. Google is has enough money to buy the whole industry.
Pick your fight.
Which matters not at all.
> Amazon is one of the largest music sellers in the world. Google is has enough money to buy the whole industry.
Being big is not sufficient, nor is having money. Apple has more cash on hand than Amazon and Google at the same time.
> Pick your fight.
You don't even make sense.
This isn't about what's right, it's about what will work.
I'm not sure Amazon (or Google) really think they can be successful but I'm not sure that's the point. I think they're just manoeuvring - potentially trying to show the record companies that there is demand, that there is money to be made and to encourage them into a mutually agreeable licensing deal.
Around 1952.
> I must have missed that.
Were you asleep the whole time? Did you miss the my.mp3.com case ugh referred to above?
Spending more and more on lawyers is likely to really only benefit the lawyers.
1. As pointed out below, Google and Amazon are likely to pick this fight. I would imagine Apple is more then happy to let those two companies spend the blood, sweat, tears and dollars on what will surely be a lengthy legal fight.
2. With the labels opening a deal, they'll feel more inclined to shutdown/stop Amazon/Google pressing their need to move legally in return.
3. While all this is happening, especially if injunctive relief is given to the labels, Apple has the legal solution in the U.S.
4. They continue to sell silly amounts of content and done right the process of shopping by my iPhone now becomes building a playlist, that can sync later to physical files in my iTunes, if at all. Or a subscription stream model, where again just putting together a list from the largest online retailer of music.
It's certainly positive for Apple's customers that they don't have to spend hours and hours and tons of bandwidth uploading their music.
It's certainly positive for Apple and their customers if the fees are lower then they would have otherwise been or if Apple was able to get other concessions from the labels.
Only MG Siegler can spin this into something positive.