News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by foreigner on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:31AM (#25629201)
So what's the long-term plan here? A country's population is just supposed to keep growing... forever?
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by FiReaNG3L on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:33AM (#25629208)
Yes, same as the economy, too many things depend on infinite growth (retirement funds being the main one).
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by nayaketo on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:04AM (#25629422)
Theoretically, if immigration wasn't an option, what would happen in this case? Just imagine entire earth is well developed, so this issue is present on every single nation on earth. What would happen then? Would economy just slow down or would everything come crashing down? Would automation see widespread adoption? Anything else?
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by mytailorisrich on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:23AM (#25629540)
Economic growth would slow down because it would be based purely on productivity gains rather than productivity gains and producers/consumers base growth (and automation would likely have a big part to play in that).

But that would not necessarily be a bad thing as that would force to indeed focus on productivity growth and growth of indicators per capita instead of overall indicators.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by ben_w on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:37AM (#25629238)
Retirement funds don’t strictly requiring that, they just require that there are more workers than pensioners — you could also sort that with a higher retirement age.

(Long-Term question I’ve had: how does this compare with UBI, which is kinda like a pension but for everyone?)

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by yulaow on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:18AM (#25629500)
Retirement age cannot be pushed higher much longer, we already have too many too much old people doing _badly_ their work because they are not sharp enough / willing enough / energic enough to do any better (so destroying any productivity value for that position + not allowing access to those well paying jobs to the new generations).

I am in a country which has the s.k. problem since a decade and since then tried to push retirement age over and over with extremely bad results (one of the higher young unemployment rate in the whole eu area).

Add to this that already now losing your job, especially if low-skilled, in your 50ies it's basically a sentence to never find another one and live under unemployment benefit until you get your small state pension.

For my generation (Born 1985-1995) it is already planned we will have to retire minimum at 74yo in the most optimistic situation. I mean, I don't even see myself capable of doing well my work at 65, and probably no one will want to keep me after 60, doesn't matter how sharp I will be. All supposing I am not gonna get pretty sick around that age, which is highly probable.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by ben_w on Monday January 04, 2021 @07:02AM (#25630242)
> not allowing access to those well paying jobs to the new generations

False dichotomy.

First: Employers which don’t allow people who are better suited to a role to have better chances to be hired for those roles, don’t grow as fast as those companies which do allow better candidates to get those roles.

This is basically what causes the situation in your 3rd paragraph, and is still more appropriate than relying on eternal population growth.

Second: Unless they are literally destroying value in their work (not merely being cost-ineffective, but actively damaging), then the economy still benefits from having more people working — the more value an economy creates, the more any given currency unit can buy, the more people are available to be customers, the more business can be supported by their spending, in a virtuous cycle.

This is why everyone is encouraged to work in the first place instead of jobs being treated as luxury or status symbols available to only the elite few.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by RobertoG on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:57AM (#25629365)
>>"Retirement funds don’t strictly requiring that, they just require that there are more workers than pensioners [..]"

That's not necessary. They require that the active workers (plus capital) are productive enough to keep life standards for everybody. There is not theoretical limit for how many workers are necessary. In the extreme it could be with one or zero workers.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by ben_w on Monday January 04, 2021 @07:08AM (#25630278)
Until we get fully automated luxury communism, capital can only be productive with workers.

Cows can milk themselves these days, but the cow self-milking machines can’t make themselves yet.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by mytailorisrich on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:16AM (#25629491)
Actually, retirement funds only require capital growth in real terms, which means the economy growing faster than inflation, because the principle of a retirement fund is to invest current contributions to pay future pensions.

More workers than pensioners is required when the system works by using current contributions to pay current pensions (which is usually how state pensions work). [Which should also provides some information about how (un)realistic UBI is]

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by QuesnayJr on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:37AM (#25629240)
Most economic growth comes from technological advance. Do you expect technological advance to stop before the Baby Boomers retire? It's possible, but it's not obvious to me.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by sideshowb on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:53AM (#25629336)
What's your source for "most"? I'd always thought a small fraction was technological advance while a large fraction was unsustainable use of resources
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by tooltalk on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:34AM (#25629222)
unification with the North, which has higher birth rate (1.9) than the South (1.1)?
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by absolutelyrad on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:35AM (#25629625)
Why does the north have such a low birth rate? I thought this was a phenomena exhibited by women's rights/education and increase in wealth. All of which the north lacks.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by oblio on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:55AM (#25629740)
Don't women have equal rights in the North? Almost all other Communist states did this right, despite their many other flaws.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by lasagnaphil on Monday January 04, 2021 @06:35AM (#25630038)
On paper (in law) and in national policy, women's rights advanced a lot faster than South Korea (for example, in inheritance and marriage/divorce laws.) In practice, although it is hard to know extensively because of the secrecy of the nation, it's studied that there are still some economical/cultural inequalities (although North Korea's human rights for both sexes isn't isn't really a thing to show off overall...)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_North_Korea

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by oblio on Monday January 04, 2021 @06:56AM (#25630204)
Well, I wouldn't be completely surprised. In dictatorships there's the official doctrine and there's "do whatever the dictator tells us to do".

Many of the recent advances in human rights are from people protesting, convincing other people that their plight is real, and slowly turning the tide.

In dictatorships this doesn't happen for obvious reasons so social progress can be frozen by 1 person or maybe a 1 group for decade after decade.

Similar story from Romania, where I'm from. Not necessarily with women's rights, but with other kinds of human rights.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by leereeves on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:57AM (#25629366)
How would that work? The South isn't going to submit to Kim Jong-un, and he isn't going to give up power.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by akmarinov on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:39AM (#25629249)
Yep, colonize other planets, spread humanity across the stars.
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by albertgoeswoof on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:51AM (#25629323)
Getting a human to another star is probably not going to happen without some crazy physics breakthrough. They’re just so bloody far away
Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by mytailorisrich on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:04AM (#25629421)
Currently it indeed seems impossible to get a human being from Earth to another star system because the trip is too long for a human lifespan.

But if we accept that the people leaving will never see the end of the journey then the problem is one of keeping a liveable, self-contained environment in space for 100+ years, which does not require crazy physics breakthrough at all, just technological advances.

This is not going to solve Earth's problems, though.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by jmnicolas on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:59AM (#25629386)
Even if you would manage to bring a few humans far away, it doesn't solve the problem for the rest of us.

As long as we depend on dwindling supplies of fossil fuel to send things in space, we're certainly not going anywhere.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by RobertoG on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:59AM (#25629385)
No need to go to another star. There is plenty of space around our star (1).

(1) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bishop_Ring_(habitat)

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by albertgoeswoof on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:37AM (#25629236)
Automation of almost all food and consumable production, combined with unlimited energy sources (renewables, fusion etc) and the need for continued population growth goes away.

Until we get there we import people from other countries.

Re:Alarm as South Korea sees more deaths than births by op03 on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:42AM (#25629274)
Reunification with the North.