Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps
by distances on Sunday January 03, 2021 @06:24AM
(#25621153)
I really wany to love OsmAnd, but I'm not sure I agree on the user friendliness yet. First thing user feels is how slow the rendering is while panning. I can't measure it but I'd guess about 10fps on my phone, and the area revealed by panning is all grey for a good while before it gets drawn.
It's fine for a tool, but has no chance to compete for casual end users like this.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps
by usrusr on Sunday January 03, 2021 @09:18AM
(#25621888)
But fast OSM renderers exist. Take a look at
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=gr.talent.crui...
for an example. It's perfectly smooth. The application is closed source but the underlying renderer (VTM) is LGPL3. The renderer, https://github.com/mapsforge/vtm, is basically an OpenGL alternative for the mapsforge offline maps format and maintained by the same guy (the original mapsforge renderer is arguably a bit slow, struggling to hide its slowness behind cached tile bitmaps).
I wrote about this in another comment in this thread (and talked about a solution to the problem), but I believe the existing OSM navigation apps that exist work well, and that the remaining friction point preventing them from competing with google in the consumer navigation market is address lookup. OsmAnd for example is very user friendly and I use it almost exclusively, but looking up addresses is the main difficulty.