News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by croes on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:37PM (#25616264)
OSM is non-profit, Google is not. Google tracks the users, OSM does not.
[dead]
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:08PM (#25618990)
Purists are unrepentantly unsatisfied and will be unhappy without perfection. They are an edge case not to be optimized for.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by zelphirkalt on Sunday January 03, 2021 @08:02AM (#25621523)
I was happy with how OSM was run before. Only recently became unhappy with it, when they decided to make that move. Note also, that it was a silent move for the casual OSM visitor. There was no big sign saying: "Hey, we switched to fastly! This means your requests will go through their servers. Just wanted to give you a heads up for you privacy conscious people." No justification, no asking for donations for running their own instead. I've supported multiple other projects, which I feel are important for the public and would have considered it for OSM to stay at OSM and not outsource stuff to fastly.

Now I cannot, with a clean conscience, recommend it to people any longer. What will my answer be to anyone, who asks me: "Well, if you are not using Google maps, what map service are _you_ using?" Now I cannot answer OSM, because then it will be: "But they are also allowing big companies to track their users! You are a hypocrite!"

Basically I need something better now, in order to stay consistent and not become a hypocrite. Perhaps I will use my months ago updated maps.me on my phone instead. However, with maps.me issues of late, I will need to switch that eventually as well.

Remember: Ignorants and uninformed people are not to be optimized for, if we want any quality standards to survive on the WWW. To keep standards, one cannot always go for the lowest common denominator.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by matkoniecz on Sunday January 03, 2021 @08:45AM (#25621710)
"no asking for donations for running their own instead" OSM asks for donations already and entire infrastructure was run by two volunteer sysadmins.

Tile serving infrastructure was basically on fire.

While it would be nice to avoid this...

> Basically I need something better now

I am honestly curious what you will use.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by zelphirkalt on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:57AM (#25632935)
> "no asking for donations for running their own instead" OSM asks for donations already and entire infrastructure was run by two volunteer sysadmins.

They did? How come I've never noticed during any visit to the map website? That's a pity, I'd probably have donated.

> Tile serving infrastructure was basically on fire.

I also did not know that! I never felt any too long lag or anything.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by matkoniecz on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:47AM (#25643830)
See green text in bottom-right at https://www.openstreetmap.org/ linking to https://donate.openstreetmap.org/

There are also popups during part of the year, but someone with axe to grind ensured that they were added to the adblock filter lists.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by tordanik on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:51PM (#25626815)
Although I understand that using any external service provider is a potential concern, are there specific issues with Fastly's terms or practices that you consider worrisome? I'd be interested in anything we may not have fully considered when we decided to make that move.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by zelphirkalt on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:05AM (#25633076)
Primarily I am worried about fastly being used by loads of other websites and them getting data about me from usage of multiple websites, especially location sensitive websites, like map websites like OSM. If I allowed their scripts on all those websites, holy moly, the profile they could build about me ... Best way to protect your privacy is to not let the data be collected in the first place.

I am no lawyer and do not wish to read many pages of their legalese. However, if they somehow managed to convince me, that they are not building profiles, that they are not transferring or selling data to anyone else, and that none of the software they use does so behind their backs, then I might trust them. Now that is very difficult to do of course, almost impossible. I would rather trust a single entity, that is not present in any requests to any other website I visit. That seems to be much lower risk than putting data all in the hands of a single party, which is present on many many websites.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by matkoniecz on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:30PM (#25624391)
Too late to edit that, but note also that this was donated by Fastly - see https://www.fastly.com/open-source
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by rmc on Sunday January 03, 2021 @11:20AM (#25622647)
The tile servers were under massive load, and massively negatively affecting performance. Many people were not happy
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by Bancakes on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:00PM (#25622971)
Apps are meant to be used. If an app is meant to be obscure, it's an experiment.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by BlueTemplar on Sunday January 03, 2021 @04:02AM (#25620593)
Same thing could be recently said about not using Google Maps though…
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by rmc on Sunday January 03, 2021 @10:58AM (#25622462)
That's for the website tiles. If a transit authority is using OSM data, they would download & process it directly themselves, and hence this doesn't apply at all.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by rualca on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:48PM (#25618241)
You can download the entire OSM data catalogue and host it in your servers.

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Downloading_data

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by meibo on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:12PM (#25618701)
I feel like when saying this, you have to mention that it is(or at least was when I was tasked to do so 2 years ago) notoriously crazy to host an OSM tile/nominatim server for a mid-size country, and even more so for the entire world.

Requires some dedication and lots and lots of disk space and bandwidth - probably most feasible in a box at home with only you yourself having access and not having to pay monthly for high-traffic storage.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by matkoniecz on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:17AM (#25620878)
It is a bit crazy, but at least it is possible. So if someone has special requirements (100% pure software, special rendering, special routing, special data analysis) they can do this.

What is both illegal and basically impossible and even more complicated technically to do with Google Maps data.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by adevx on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:13AM (#25621334)
I think an easy to setup self-hosted vector/tile server could help increase adoption. I'am currently looking into replacing Mapbox with a self hosted solution. My last attempt ran out of disk space building the docker images (with european maps) from https://github.com/Overv/openstreetmap-tile-server. Haven't found the time to setup a larger VPS but this looks like a great project to get started.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by m4rtink on Sunday January 03, 2021 @10:48AM (#25622408)
There is the OSM Scout Server project, that makes it possible to download various OSM based data packs for offline use:

https://github.com/rinigus/osmscout-server

Then it provides various services (routing, PoI search, geocoding, etc.) over this data set to all applications running locally on your machine. It targets mainly various mobile Linux distros but works perfectly fine on desktop as well and is available in flatpak form.

Like this all navigation and mapping can share the same data set and no potentially sensitive location related metadata is leaked to a remote server other than what data packs have been initially downloaded.

Also the community run infrastructure just needs to be able to store and store and distribute the ~150 GB of data packs covering Earth but does not need to have any extensive compute and memory requirements to handle lots expensive of individual API queries.

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by MattBlissett on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:53AM (#25621479)
I use https://openmaptiles.org/ at work. For normal, Web Mercator maps we just use the free download of the whole world, available at [1]. Running the OpenMapTiles tools to generate a current tileset for a particular region is straightforward, but if you need all of Europe you will need some decent compute capacity. Unless everything can be done on a single computer, you'll also need to implement some missing pieces, e.g. a message system to distribute the rendering across your computers.

[1] https://data.maptiler.com/downloads/dataset/osm/

Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by adevx on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:12PM (#25623082)
Thanks, I looked into this but commercial use is prohibited for the free download which makes it a no go for my use case.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by ryantgtg on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:17PM (#25619383)
But at least you can host the world wide tileset for $11/mo on linode! It’s not the data, but it’s still valuable and easy.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by adrianN on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:23AM (#25619722)
Last I heard the situation improved somewhat because of vector tiles.
Re:Openstreetmap’s product fails to compete with Google Maps by rmc on Sunday January 03, 2021 @11:21AM (#25622656)
A server capable of hosting a minutely updated global OSM tileserver costs about €100 per month on Hetzner. That's not nothing, but “crazy” it is not.