Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged
by cptskippy on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:53PM
(#25652990)
So you're arguing that Tesla should apply R&D costs to vehicles but not count credits directly resulting from the sale of a vehicle?
The sale of a vehicle results in a credit that can then also be sold, so why can't that profit be tied to the vehicle?
On the flip side, the company can spend lots on R&D that never makes it way into a vehicle. Why should that then count against the profit from selling a vehicle?
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged
by reitzensteinm on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:50PM
(#25654749)
Unlike parent, I agree credits should be included in gross margin, whether positive or negative. Companies in Europe facing significant CO2 fines should have that reflected in their reported margins.
I don't understand your R&D point though. It's perfectly logical either way to include or exclude it. There's nothing wrong with how Tesla does it, and there's nothing wrong with how the rest of the auto industry does it. It just means you can't blindly compare the figures.
But that's not all: Tesla adds regulatory credit sales to their "automotive" gross margin figures.
Yes, that's right, Tesla's "automotive" gross margin isn't just vehicle sales like it is for other car manufacturers. For example, look at Q2 2020 filings. The clean-car credits that they sell to other manufacturers are treated as automotive revenue, and that accounting chicanery is entirely what lets Tesla claim a 20+% gross margin on their vehicles. (The clean-car credits are also what lets Tesla claim to be profitable, though it has yet to make a profit actually selling cars.)
Without treating the sale of clean-car credits as automotive revenue, Tesla's gross margins are at best in line with industry gross margins (and fall below industry margins once you apply automotive GAAP to standardize the financials).