News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by opportune on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:58PM (#25607634)
I don't really think these are compelling arguments, since at least for me, the only better thing than working for a megacorp as far as finances and QOL would be running my own company and succeeding which is substantially riskier.

>If you quit, remember that they will have forced you to sign an NDA and a non-compete.

Not really likely considering there is a huge revolving door between all the major tech companies. There is also a risk I get hit by a car on the way to work.

>You will probably be much happier at a small to mid-size company. The “dream job” megacorps have sold you on is just good marketing.

Actually I've worked on interesting, highly used stuff at megacorps in mature work environments, and was paid much more than most random small companies would. The concept of a "dream job" doesn't exist, neither in big companies or small companies, IMO.

>They could hurt you, and they could make you hurt others.

I could just leave and get another job at any time. I don't understand why this author is so paranoid.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ssklash on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:01PM (#25607652)
I feel like you skipped the most compelling reason. I posted it in this thread already, but it's the abhorrent behavior that these companies routinely engage in and the harm they cause, enabled by well-meaning engineers who just want to solve problems and do interesting work.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by opportune on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:10PM (#25607740)
Yeah, the issue with that is that for most megacorps only one or two of those criticisms are valid. I've definitely refused to work at companies (like Facebook) on the grounds that I think they are doing much more harm than good in the world. But there are also megacorps which I consider to be doing less harm per capita than other technology businesses which I would work for.

Part of the issue is that media companies have darlings and enemies that they don't really cover proportionately to their offenses, IMO (for example if Google even considers doing any business in China - uproar. But Bing actively sells out Chinese users to the Chinese government and nobody cars, because right now Microsoft is a media darling). And the media doesn't write about smaller companies doing bad things usually, unless they are particularly bad, because they fail the "who cares" test.

There is also an inherent chaos that comes with companies with hundreds of thousands of employees - bad people will get through hiring and do bad things, people will make very high impact mistakes, things become uncoordinated. So for me personally I try to think of companies in terms of badness-per-capita and whether the rot is coming from the top (Facebook) or is seemingly "random".

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by rightbyte on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:35PM (#25608947)
I would rather work for a weapon manufacturer than Facebook. It is way more honest work to drill guns than to "bring people together" a la Zuckerberg.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by Bancakes on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:12AM (#25611236)
You kidding, working at raytheon or BAE sounds must more engaging and impactful (puns intented) than running web apps.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by Youden on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:57AM (#25614137)
I have a couple of objections to that:

- These companies aren't monolithic. If you object to say Google's monopoly on advertising, you can take a job on a team that has nothing to do with it, like image compression.

- If you disagree with the company's practices, you might have more impact by changing the company from within than trying to compete with it.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by abdabab on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:06PM (#25607703)
> ... and they could make you hurt others

This is the part you missed. You can’t easily walk away from that.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by opportune on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:20PM (#25607817)
I don't see how that's possible. I could just quit if I felt I was doing something unethical. It is easy to get hired as a software engineer, though if you are on a restrictive work visa "just quitting" becomes a much harder decision.
[dead]
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by throwaway3699 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:13PM (#25608312)
By working in a supermarket, you're directly supporting an unethical business which relies on modern slavery in China, Africa, etc... along with being damaging to the environment (single use plastics, animal farming) and pushing wage slavery onto you and your colleagues. You have sold your soul, quite literally.

Reductio ad absurdum.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:17PM (#25608352)
The cashier at the supermarket does not enjoy a job market with exceptionally high salaries, benefits, and mobility. They don't have any choice. You do.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by throwaway3699 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:25PM (#25608425)
Mobility in entry-level jobs isn't as bad as you make it out to be (I worked plenty of these as recently as a year ago).

There are zero jobs in the world without a dark side. Or as you say, "blood on their hands". Even the tiniest non-profit, village bakery might accidentally source ingredients from exploited farm workers in 3rd world countries, or pay tax dollars which goes into US war efforts.

The only reason we're having this conversation is because it's trendy to shit on FAANG companies. For any other case people would rightly say you're holding them to an unreasonable standard.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:44PM (#25608563)
>Mobility in entry-level jobs isn't as bad as you make it out to be (I worked plenty of these as recently as a year ago).

Having been there, too, and knowing many others who have had similar experiences, I don't think you fully understand what it's like for most people working low-wage jobs.

>There are zero jobs in the world without a dark side. Or as you say, "blood on their hands". Even the tiniest non-profit, village bakery might accidentally source ingredients from exploited farm workers in 3rd world countries, or pay tax dollars which goes into US war efforts.

There is an important difference. The bakery accidentally sourced those ingredients - and I'd expect them to change if it was brought to their attention. Megacorps deliberately and cognizantly engage in the behaviors we're discussing. Everyone is required to pay taxes, so that point can be dismissed. We are accountable to our country's misdeeds, but in a much different way and with a much different approach for addressing the problem. You can change your employer (as a tech worker enjoying excellent mobility) much more easily than you can change your nationality.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by throwaway3699 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#25608668)
> Having been there, too, and knowing many others who have had similar experiences, I don't think you fully understand what it's like for most people working low-wage jobs.

FWIW I'm from the UK so things might be very different here.

> The bakery accidentally sourced those ingredients

So your argument is about intent, rather than just the final effect? So what do you think about the tech workers who believe their job puts out more good than evil into the world?

I work on healthcare tech and the above calculus works for me.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:11PM (#25608768)
>FWIW I'm from the UK so things might be very different here.

Yeah, it's different. One obvious difference is that you don't have the threat of preventable death or debilitating injury bankrupting you overnight.

>So your argument is about intent, rather than just the final effect? So what do you think about the tech workers who believe their job puts out more good than evil into the world?

No, it's not about intent, it's about accountability. You can only address the problems that you are aware of. If you're talking about unreasonable standards then it is unreasonable to hold someone accountable for problems that they're not aware of.

And if you believe your job to do more good than evil, and I disagree, then that reflects poorly on my opinion of you. I do not hold the ignorant accountable, but I do hold the irrational accountable.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by dan-robertson on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:02PM (#25609514)
On the accountability of megacorps, I think there are roughly two groups they are accountable to:

1. The shareholders, who care about growth and potential future profits

2. The pampered employees

For the first group, I don’t think they will effect much positive change (from time to time some massive fund like blackrock will say that companies should have better corporate governance, and positive environmental and societal effects, but this is purely words and won’t affect their investments. Other investors want to invest in ESG funds of “good” companies but they also want those funds to have the same returns as the S&P500 ...)

For the second group (who are also likely shareholders but only to a minor extent), I think they have a lot of power to hold these companies to account, otherwise they wouldn’t be so pampered. So I think it’s an important question as to why they don’t succeed in doing this at all. I suspect many employees either don’t care or think about ethics at all, or don’t particularly object to what the company does. Being charitable, they may nor care because the issues concern parts of the vast business which are not so close to what the person works with. Others may just not know about many objectionable projects (surely the company would be motivated to keep them relatively secret if internal backlash seemed likely.)

But there also seem to be many employees who do find out about these things and care and complain. The energy seems to be dissipated entirely by internal discussion or meme boards (people can post “company is doing X and it’s awful” and nothing will change but maybe the poster feels like they’ve done something now) and the few instances where someone tries to do some kind of workplace organising, gets fired, wins some money in an unfair dismissal suit, gets some media attention, and goes to work at a think tank or something, hence no longer posing a threat to the company.

Perhaps one reason people don’t organise around such issues is that they feel some kind of embarrassment about it—they have this relaxed pampered lifestyle and high pay, so they would look silly to be complaining about it.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by throwaway2245 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:15PM (#25608339)
> You are directly supporting an unethical business and generating at least as much revenue for them as the salary you take home.

Whoever benefits from this value/excess value can behave unethically with it: is it evident that Bigcorp will behave (on average/net) more unethically than Smallco?

If you work for Bigcorp and act to help them behave more ethically, are you making more of a difference than you would elsewhere?

I say this lovingly, as someone who has actively chosen not to work for Bigcorps because I find them unethical. It's not always immediately obvious that the alternatives are more ethical. A smaller company might do more harm and face less scrutiny.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:20PM (#25608384)
>is it evident that Bigcorp will behave (on average/net) more unethically than Smallco?

Smallco is certainly capable of unethical behavior, and I would encourage you to critically examine your both prospects and the companies you end up working for. But, for most values of Bigcorp that anyone could name, there's clear evidence of ongoing unethical behavior.

>If you work for Bigcorp and act to help them behave more ethically, are you making more of a difference than you would elsewhere?

Definitely, and I would support anyone who is doing so. But this isn't easy, and the typical software engineer plugging away is almost certainly not doing this. It takes a lot of hubris to presume that you, an engineer worth .00075% of your employer's revenue, can exert the necessary influence to cause substantive changes in unethical behavior. Perhaps if megacorp tech workers collectivized, it would be more realistic.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by triceratops on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#25608670)
> for most values of Bigcorp that anyone could name, there's clear evidence of ongoing unethical behavior.

Yeah, 'cuz they're big. They have a ton of people working at them and some fraction will do unethical stuff. I'd be surprised if the actual rate of unethical behavior was higher than average (barring fundamentally corrupt orgs like Enron or Theranos).

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by throwaway2245 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:45PM (#25608572)
> But, for most values of Bigcorp that anyone could name, there's clear evidence of ongoing unethical behavior.

This slightly missed my point:

Bigcorps engage in a lot of behaviour, some of which is evidenced to be unethical. Smallco engages in less behaviour, which is not evidenced. You have no way to judge if it's more unethical.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:49PM (#25608601)
You're comparing a known with an unknown. We can judge that the known is unethical. We cannot judge either way on the unknown. It follows that the only possibly ethical choice is at Smallcorp.

And I'm sure we could make a much better argument for it if we substituted Bigcorp and Smallcorp with actual options you were deciding between as a prospective employer.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by edmundsauto on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:57PM (#25608158)
Your perspective requires agreeing with a specific interpretation that is just your opinion, then is wrapped into an accusatory tone that is unlikely to be particularly effective at getting OP to consider any changes that you think they should make.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by triceratops on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:50PM (#25608611)
It sounds like your problem is with capitalism in general. If participating in capitalism is selling my soul, I'd rather sell it dearly.

I've worked at small companies that did flagrantly unethical things. I've worked at small companies where my work was meaningless, I was unappreciated, or colleagues were unfairly forced out. Big companies don't have a monopoly on doing "evil" stuff. If anything their evil gets called out more frequently due to their size.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by WJW on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:43PM (#25608039)
Did you not read the part in the GP where he said "I could just leave and get another job at any time."? How is that not easily walking away from it?
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by abdabab on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:34PM (#25609330)
You may not walk away if the BigCorp is subtle enough to hide how your actions are supporting an unethical intention.

I don’t blame people for working in a BigCorp. You gotta pay rent or mortgage. I’m wary of the uncontrolled power they hold over humanity and the prestige we associate working for them. These two together can be lethal.

[dead]
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by opportune on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:17PM (#25607796)
Ok. To be more blunt I think many of the things you have written are simply not true, or are at least not broadly applicable.
[dead]
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by WJW on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:51PM (#25608118)
Your own viewpoint is pretty biased too Drew. Your entire software philosophy is based on your own model of ethics and admitting that the software megacorps might not be the very epitome of evil would invalidate most of the reasons for the existence of sourcehut and your other projects.

I hope you continue to explore other places in the design space, but calling people evil because you disagree with them makes people disengage. It makes you look like just another zealot screaming his viewpoint into the uncaring masses.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:57PM (#25608157)
I have called no one evil. I have spoken of behaviors that I believe are unethical, and necessarily if someone in this thread is doing these behaviors then they may be offended by this. If we are unwilling to talk about ethics for the risk of offending someone who doesn't meet them, then we are inevitably going to fail to uphold our ethics at all.

Some of the stuff megacorps are doing is so unethical that we would use it as a grandiose example for the purpose of debate. If there is a point at which it's acceptable to call behavior out as unethical, and we aren't there yet, then I don't know where it is.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by rossjudson on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:49PM (#25608096)
Your response, like your article, is essentially useless. You have massively overgeneralized, telling an elementary schoolchild's story.

Is a city bad or good? It is both. Complexity is unavoidable. Different experiences in a large corporation happen.

I've personally seen counterexamples to every single point you've made, and they are not isolated.

Your failure to acknowledge that points directly at the most obvious bias -- your own.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by Rebelgecko on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:11PM (#25608297)
Out of curiosity, have you worked at a megacorp? A lot of the things you say in the article don't really ring true for me. Maybe it's team-dependent, but I actually have much better visibility here for how my actions impact "the bottom line", and I'm fairly confident that nothing I'm working on is being used to support genocide or slavery.

I've worked at small smaller companies and actually had the opposite experience. Way more NDAs, way more issues with HR (at a megacorp, it's true that HR might not give a shit on a personal level about outcomes when there's issues. I'll take that over the situation where HR is a blood relative or close personal friend of someone involved in an issue). This sort of vague apathy is awesome--I can make code contributions to a team I've never met and they're happy to accept them. At smaller companies I've worked at, crossteam collaboration was a lot more difficult because everyone had a little fiefdom they wanted to protect.

Even though I don't think (reasonable) NDAs are that big of a deal, I had way more of them at a smaller company. A bigger company is much more vertically integrated so they aren't necessary. And it's not like I'm gonna impress people at a party by reciting proprietary Xilinx datasheets.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by UncleMeat on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:55PM (#25608140)
That's an amazingly rude and closed-minded viewpoint. Everybody who disagrees with you is wrong, by definition. Any respect I had for what you had written is shattered. Instead I see this as childish anger.
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by ddevault on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:00PM (#25608202)
>Everybody who disagrees with you is wrong, by definition.

That's not what I said. I said the following:

>This post wasn't written for you[, a person who already works at a megacorp. The article is written for an audience who is considering a job at one.]. People who have already drunk the kool-aid [i.e. already works at a megacorp] need a much different approach to break their cognative dissonance[, a natural human bias which makes it difficult to critically examine oneself].

I annotated it here for clarity, but I understand that my comment relies heavily on context for this interpretation to work, and I understand how that would cause you to read it differently.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by UncleMeat on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:01PM (#25609510)
You assume that the only way somebody could conclude that working at a megacorp is right for them is that they are brainwashed ("drunk the kool-aid") and that they are so thick headed that they'd be unable to pierce with argument. You fail to consider that it really is possible for people to have different values and needs than you and honestly and coherently conclude that working at one of these companies is a good idea for them.

For the record, I also disagree with a lot of what was written in your post as straight of factually wrong. My manager's manager's manager's manager does know my name, for example. I do work that I choose almost entirely, my work has direct and meaningful impact on a problem I personally care about a lot (my friends and family care a lot too), and I've been able to be one of the primary voices involved in pushing an entire org of hundreds to change a major strategic approach over the last several years. I've never been asked to sign a non-compete.

There are problems with major companies. They aren't for everybody. That's fine. But telling people that they are just blind for disagreeing with you is just awful.

Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by BeetleB on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:56PM (#25608153)
Sorry, but responding to criticism with "you've drunk the kool-aid" is a sure-fire way of never correcting incorrect things you say/believe.

I worked at a megacorp in big tech for many years. They do not have non-compete clauses (and I'm in a state that allows them). I also never signed an NDA with them. People leave them all the time after disputes and not one that I know of suffered after they left. You contradict yourself in talking about how hell bent megacorps are in making money, and then talk about them spending 100x your salary on lawyers to go after you. Sorry, most "you's" are not worth even 10% of your salary to go after. You leave, and both you and the company move on.

> They could hurt you, and they could make you hurt others. Don’t fall for their propaganda.

This is definitely true, but as the GP said, it's quite simple to leave if you this is the concern. While there, I interviewed for an internal position that involved work for China that sounded to me like part of their mass surveillance program. I don't really know if that was the case, but it was trivial for me to decline their offer.

And I've found plenty of non-megacorps involved in hurting others. They merely do not have the scale that big megacorps do.

It sounds like you're conflating Internet companies, and FAANG, with megacorps. Most megacorps are not one of these.

Some people do get to do very interesting work, although broadly speaking, you are correct - you are most likely going to be a cog in someone else's dream job.

They occasionally do invest in people. They gave a coworker $50K to get an MBA (which cost a lot more, but they did contribute a nice sum), with no strings attached. He left soon after getting the MBA. They really shouldn't be this nice.

As for autonomy, it does seem independent of size. My last job at that company had quite a bit of autonomy. I got to pick the tech stack. Work wasn't assigned to me - I had to go examine the needs of the department and propose solutions - make prototypes and if it seemed useful then make it into an internal product.

> You will probably be much happier at a small to mid-size company.

Compared to where I worked, most of these companies in my area have some combination of these:

1. Pay less (and I don't get FAANG salaries - perhaps 60% or less)

2. Work you as much if not more (my life in megacorp had good work/life balance - and when it didn't, I'd simply do an internal transfer).

3. Are less stable. I spent 10 years in the megacorp. Most people I know working at medium sized companies simply did not have the choice to spend that much time there.

4. Are more at the mercy of market forces, often making it equally unlikely you'll get to do cool work. The need to pay the bills is greater.

I've found that there is almost some sort of conservation law at work. As an example, most small companies where I find average people do real interesting work get paid pennies (as in, many of them could qualify for food stamps). Ditto for work/life balance. A friend worked a tech job in a medium company where he'd routinely go home at 3:30pm. Pay was average, but he had to pay almost all of his insurance (quite a bit for a family of 4). He nevertheless was happy with the compromise of a lower salary.

I'm not doubting tech companies exist that let me work in my city and are better on all these counts - just that they're harder to find and get into then big megacorp.

Not all big megacorps are FAANG - in fact, most of them are not. Do not extrapolate from outliers.

[dead]
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by BeetleB on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:19PM (#25608373)
> See response here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25608202

Sorry. It didn't address the concern.

> I know of people who suffered after they left, and a cursory internet search will turn up many more stories.

All outliers. How many people leave a company in frustration? And then how many does the company go after? A tiny fraction! Not even 0.1%, which would be huge. I don't think I can find even one case for the company I worked for. It's not a small company - definitely makes more net revenue than Amazon, and comparable to at least one other FAANG.

> There is no contradiction in what I said, if spending 100 units on a legal battle for a single employee would save them >100 units on the next employee (or as a consequence of an unfavorable legal outcome), then it would be worth the cost.

The conclusion follows the premise, but the premise is extremely rarely true.

> You were generating revenues which financed the project even if you didn't directly work on it.

I never understood the desire to compartmentalize and draw boundaries only where it is convenient for you. Just because it is within my company makes it no different from a medium sized company providing services to another company who is involved in evil, even if those services are not directly related. If you work for a payment processor and provide services to my company, then your own logic would make you as complicit as I am. Your service is helping my company in its business, which raises our revenue, which is funding evil. Why am I complicit just because I am an employee, and not you because your company is providing us a service? We're both providing services to my company. Why draw the boundary only to within the company?

And at the end of the day, this is a hypothetical. I do not know what that technology was being used for. Surveillance was merely something I could imagine it's used for. I chose not to get into the business, but the decision was the equivalent of "Do not go work for any company that makes video cameras, or components for video cameras." I would never suggest anyone follow such standards.

Regarding my 4 points, you missed the point of me listing them. I didn't say all medium companies follow those - I said they usually are some combination of those.

I'd happily work for a medium company that has the positive attributes you speak of. I just have trouble finding them, let alone getting hired by them. I'm not at all anti-medium size company or pro-megacorp. When I apply to companies, I generally get a higher response rate with megacorps than with medium sized companies.

[dead]
Re:A megacorp is not your dream job by BeetleB on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:34PM (#25608503)
> This is exceptionally naive.

Occam's razor. If you have actual studies/statistics to support your case, I'll be happy to reconsider. But I'd wager I know a lot about the company I spent a decade at than you do.