News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by flipbrad on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @08:24AM (#2559860)
Until the reviewing of service clauses become a normal part of product reviews (which it clearly should, in light of the PS3 OtherOS saga and current class action), most consumers simply aren't going to be properly exposed to this info until they've spent their money and things have gone pearshaped, and their only avenues of action are speculative class actions, pointless consumer complaints, and longlasting, potentially harmful boycotts.

Please, if you're ever going to review a device that has internet connectivity and is capable of remote bricking and feature removal, please also review the T&Cs and express your opinion in light of what you find. You wouldn't hold your tongue over substandard hardware, and you'd probably hold back your dollars until a better performing, more reliable machine came out. Be consistent, and consider the device's lexware too; in time, it'll be a feature for the manufacturer to improve, just like all the others.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by CodeMage on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @09:05AM (#2559998)
While I do agree with you that T&C should be included in product reviews, there's one thing that worries me: T&C can change easily. Picture a scenario where a manufacturer comes out with a good product and acceptable T&C, gets great reviews and subsequently -- when the consumers are hooked -- starts introducing changes to T&C.

Maybe I'm missing something, but it seems like this can only be mitigated, not solved. I'm getting more and more worried by the ever-increasing degree to which the manufacturers dictate how we can use the products we buy from them.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @10:28AM (#2560241)
Let's take it a step further and write a T&C that is written by the consumers. Like GPL, but for T&C and privacy policies. Something like:

* All content generated by the user with the help of the product belongs to the user

* The user is free to take apart, modify, reverse-engineer, etc., the product

* No data is to be sent to any outside network without the user's explicit permission.

* No sensitive data, including but not limited to location data, communications, usage patterns, identifying addresses, personal information is to be stored without the user's explicit permission.

* These terms may not be changed without the user's explicit consent. If the product producer wants to change the terms, and the user does not consent, the old terms stay in effect.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by BrandonM on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @12:05PM (#2560585)
I really like this idea. Now we need to find a well-known consumer advocacy group that can publicize such a standard and start getting some adoption.

It would be really great to have various standards like this for companies to opt into. Then reviews could say "product X is great and it follows the accepted Respected Consumer Rights Agreement."

I think this a good example of how capitalist companies can be reined in without government interference.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by LokiSnake on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @05:21PM (#2561880)
It would be good to have a clause stating something along the lines of "Any modifications or addendum to these terms need to be prominently displayed and clearly communicated".
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by koudelka on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @03:41PM (#2561437)
It'd be really great to see Creative Commons-style licenses printed on product boxes.
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by omouse on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @11:06AM (#2560367)
You're basically saying "down with capitalism". There's no way to work within the current system because everything that goes through it is bent towards profit and power. Do you really think companies would adopt such a T&C? Which would take precedence, the T&C or local/state/federal law?
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by jonprins on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @11:21AM (#2560417)
No, GP is not saying 'down with capitalism.' They're saying 'down with restrictive terms of service similar in scope to the prevention of the Hush-A-Phone from being used on the Bell System in the 1950s.' Which, well, is pretty much the opposite of 'down with capitalism:'

The restriction from connecting your own devices to the Bell System forestalled the production, sale, and invention of devices such as the answering machine (Bell invented one in 1930, along with magnetic storage - but scrapped the project because they thought it would cause people to use the phone less), fax machine, and so on and so forth. The 1956 ruling against Bell in favor of Hush-A-Phone effectively allowed the invention, sale, and use of foreign attachments to the Bell System.

The restriction of doing what you want with your own console/computer is essentially the same damn thing. We've already fought this war against monopolists in technology; it's sad that we have to do it all over again.

Further reading:

Hush-A-Phone vs. United States (Hush-A-Phone appeal to an FCC ruling): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hush-A-Phone_v._United_States

The Master Switch (Tim Wu): http://www.amazon.com/Master-Switch-Information-Empires-Borz...

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by dhimes on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @02:04PM (#2561023)
OT, but: As I recall, it was the breakup of the Bell monopoly which ushered in the new devices. Until then, I don't think you could even own a phone. You had to lease.

I was pretty young then, but I do remember that after the breakup the market saw a rush of new phone devices.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by wrs on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @06:19PM (#2562072)
It's true. In fact, some people still rent their phones. http://blogs.computerworld.com/node/3538

I still have the first phone I ever bought, in 1985 right after the rules changed. (And because it was made by Western Electric in the good old days, it still works!)

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by jonprins on Friday May 20, 2011 @11:53AM (#2568166)
Not really. The breakup of the Bell monopoly helped, but Hush-a-Phone vs. US helped set the stage for competing long distance carriers like MCI. It set the stage for devices like the Carterfone ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone ). Things really didn't take off much until the breakup, because of the monopolistic practices of Ma Bell; even though interconnect was legal, they brought insane market pressure to bear.
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by dhimes on Friday May 20, 2011 @03:39PM (#2569131)
I agree with your last sentence.
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @11:16AM (#2560401)
Not at all. Capitalism is still the best we've come up with so far to align individual goals, desires and morals with those of the society as a whole (at least on average).

However, I don't see how this is different than a EULA. Not all the companies would adopt this. In fact most won't; but imagine a company, say a cell phone manufacturer, or a car maker (think Tesla) that says "We are adopting the XYZ T&C and privacy policy because we respect our users. We are committed to making the best products in our industry and do not need to rely on a bunch of legal traps to sell them." Would you buy from a company that does that? I would.

And of course the law takes precedence, just like it does with current T&C. The only thing is that the users are the ones who are originating the T&C, not the companies. That may be a very radical shift for corporate lawyers, but I don't see how this is science fiction otherwise. Just like the GPL, it could operate perfectly within the current system.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by masterzora on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @01:55PM (#2560993)
If the UN Guidelines for Consumer Protection haven't brought down capitalism, why do you think having pre-written T&C that a company can opt to use would?

If anything, having easily understandable pre-written T&C in the style of similar license could only support capitalism: companies would opt to use them if they deemed it profitable, and consumers would be more able to make the informed decisions on which capitalism should thrive.

Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @02:05PM (#2561032)
I also wonder how much cash the companies could save by not having to have lawyers involved in drafting custom T&Cs. One nice thing about GPL is that once a precedent is set, it's more or less followed everywhere. Same here: once the courts establish what this public T&C includes or excludes, it becomes much more clear what a company can and cannot do.
Re:Brick Nintendo before they brick you by chalst on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @01:38PM (#2560925)
There's the germ of a bait-and-switch case with a mfer who drums up interest with reasonable T&Cs and then switches to rapacious ones when sales take off.