Re:Is Substack the Media Future We Want?
by wongarsu on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:25PM
(#25573006)
That's basically what sites like Reddit or HN set out to do: aggregate the good articles, using the wisdom of the crowd. Of course that's not that easy, and not necessary what people even want
The wisdom of the crowd quickly gets overwhelmed by the idiocy of the mob.
Re:Is Substack the Media Future We Want?
by names_are_hard on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:04PM
(#25574155)
I agree. Another potential solution is a kind of service that will enable users to look for articles that meet some criteria, and the service could prioritize articles of higher quality. Then you wouldn't need to browse Medium, you'd just look for what you want and the service would recommend quality articles.
Of course the question is always how to properly rank an article's quality. I'd say the best approach is to crowdsource it - develop an algorithm that takes into account how many other highly ranked articles reference a given article, and give a higher rank to articles that have more references.
If you do this, make sure to give the algorithm a clever name. Ideally name it after yourself, unless your name is Smith. You'll never do well with a business built around something called SmithRank.
Now if your last name happened to be something related the things you're ranking, like, say..."Article"...wow, call it ArticleRank!
Just remember you heard it first here on HackerNews.
Re:Is Substack the Media Future We Want?
by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:03AM
(#25579036)
Yes, good show, PageRank. Slight problem, though -- that measures popularity, which correlates with outrage rather than quality. Then you end up with results full of OAN and CNN.
There could be a market for a service that just does quality filtering as a news aggregation service. So basically the opposite of what YouTube is doing -- don't show anything from OAN or CNN or similar partisan outlets, don't show garbage blogs, show the good ones. Maybe easier said than done, but I bet there's a market there.