I think an unexpected side benefit to this sort of system is a reminder that you've got stuff. Why have more. Or to make you value quality. Like buying good quality tools.
Just a thought, but rather than a 'condition unchanged' link, randomly pick one of your review metrics and give the user a single click option to rate on that instead.
Another option might be to invite them to reply to the email with any follow-up thoughts on the product to add to their review.
I'll be happy to help you if it's two minutes once a year, and I think that's all the info you need.
"...rating by default is the equivalent of saying "everything is okay". That rating is made without you having to lift a finger. You only have to lift a finger to change it to "awesome" or to "sucks" or to add a elaboration for others to read."
Also, the final section of DefaultReviews [1] may also help solve your inevitable problem with faked reviews. Pull requests welcome.
[1] https://gist.github.com/iL3D/59df64947d42828d848ebfc1651a312...
On the other hand, I wonder how quickly it'll become annoying. If you have more than a few of these products, getting badgered to update your review every year for each of them might get tedious. Perhaps gamification and/or some other sort of incentive could help, but I'm not sure.
Also, if I've had something for 5 years and it's still going strong, I doubt I'll be able to add much new info at year 6 - unless it broke down of course. So perhaps decreasing the frequency of reviews slowly over time would be useful. Perhaps something Fibonacci based, so you'd review after year 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13,...